• Follow us

Automotive

Lyft Sues New York City Over Driver Minimum Wage Rules

On Friday, New York City plans to implement some of the country’s most progressive worker protections for ride-hail company drivers. According to new rules approved by the city’s Taxi and Limousine Commission in December, drivers for Uber, Lyft, Juno, and Via would have to make at least $17.22 per hour, no matter the time of day or how many rides they give. City officials say the move would increase the average New York ride-hail driver’s salary by 14 percent and would ensure that every driver meets the city’s minimum wage of $15, even after expenses like fuel and vehicle maintenance. The city says the 85 percent of drivers currently making below the minimum wage would net an extra $6,345 a year.

Or maybe not.

On Wednesday, ride-hail companies Lyft and Juno (which is owned by the Israeli company Gett) filed separate lawsuits against the TLC in state court, alleging the rules would unfairly advantage Uber, the city’s largest ride-hail provider. A judge denied the companies' request for temporary relief, which would have postponed the new rules set to roll out Friday. While the issue is pending, the difference between what Lyft and Juno would have paid drivers before and after the new law will be held in an escrow account. The companies' next day in court is slated for mid-March. (The two other ride-hail companies in New York, Uber and Via, have not taken legal action against the rules.)1

Yes, it makes sense that these companies would be against rules forcing them to pay drivers more per trip. (Reminder: Both Lyft and Uber are set to IPO this year.) But the Lyft and Juno lawsuits make more nuanced arguments about New York’s new rules.

What the companies dispute is the way the city regulator calculated its wage floor. The $17.22 figure is derived from a lengthy analysis completed by two labor economists last summer. The formula takes into account each ride-hail trip’s length, distance, and something called a “utilization rate.” The economists figured that New York wanted to come up with a fair minimum wage for drivers, sure—but that the city also wanted to incentivize these companies to keep their cars filled at all times. (The companies want to do the opposite: keep the number of drivers high to drive down riders’ wait times.) A company with a low “utilization rate” would have too many ride-hail vehicles on the road, circling while waiting for riders and clogging up traffic. New York wants to force ride-hail companies to up their utilization rates and become more efficient.

But each company’s utilization rate is different. Uber’s and Via’s are the highest, at 58 percent and 62 percent respectively. (That means riders are in NYC Ubers 58 percent of the time its drivers are logged on.) Lyft’s and Juno’s are lower, at 56 percent and 50 percent, respectively. Those companies argue they would have to pay drivers additional money per trip, compared to Uber and Via, to make up the difference between what drivers earn and the wage floor. And that they’d have no choice but to pass those costs on to New York passengers, who would end up paying higher prices for Lyft and Juno rides, especially compared to Uber.

They say that the city’s decision to use the companies’ current utilization rates favors the company that currently has the most vehicles on its app in New York—that is, Uber. (Via’s utilization rate is higher than Uber’s not because it has more drivers but because it offers only shared rides, much like Uber’s ride-pooling service, UberPOOL.)

“Our lawsuit does not target the law passed by City Council but instead addresses the specific way the TLC plans to implement the rules, which would advantage Uber in New York City at the expense of drivers and smaller players such as Lyft,” Lyft spokesperson Campbell Matthews said in a statement. “It’s no secret that Uber has tried to put us out of business in the past. They’ve failed repeatedly, and the TLC should not assist them in their efforts.”

Lyft also wants the TLC to let it calculate driver pay on a weekly basis instead of per ride. The company argues that the current formula incentivizes drivers to seek out higher per-trip payouts with a bunch of short-distance trips that take a lot of time—exactly the sort that happen in the most-congested areas. Calculating pay on a weekly basis, the company says, might push more drivers to head to less populated areas, like the city’s outer boroughs.

In other words: Lyft claims it would be willing to shell out at least $17.22 an hour to drivers; the company just doesn’t like the way the city has chosen to calculate what each driver makes per trip.

Representatives for Juno and its parent company, Gett, did not respond to a request for comment. Uber declined to comment on the lawsuits.

In a statement, lawyers for the city defended its new wage regulations. “These rules protect thousands of hardworking drivers who work for the four busiest app companies,” a spokesperson from the New York City law department said in a statement. “The rules ensure minimum income protections, are fair and legal, and we'll vigorously defend them in court.”

Worker advocates also slammed the lawsuits. “This is an indefensible attack on workers by the billion-dollar corporations that profit from their labor,” Jim Conigliaro Jr., the founder of the Independent Drivers Guild, said in a statement. “The idea that this lawsuit is about anything other than avoiding paying drivers a fair wage is laughable.”

New York City regulators have taken the most aggressive stance in the US toward the app-based transportation companies. The city has forced the companies to share detailed data with city agencies, including information on pickups and drop-offs that the city says help it plan transportation infrastructure. The companies say that sort of data sharing threatens user privacy and their own proprietary information, and have resisted giving detailed information to other cities that do not have the regulatory authorities that New York does. And in August, New York’s city council capped the number of ride-hail vehicles operating in the city for up to one year, as regulators study how best to regulate the companies.

First, though, New York’s ride-hail regulation efforts will have to face a worthy foe: lawyers.

1Story updated, 1/31/19, 6:40 PM EST: This story has been updated with a New York state court judge's decision on Lyft and Juno's request for temporary relief.

More Great WIRED StoriesOne man’s epic quest for his Cambridge Analytica dataIt’s time to rethink who’s best suited for space travelNow, the weather: Mars-like, with a chance of apocalypseWeedmaps’ grip on the high-flying California pot marketThe prime challenges for Amazon's new delivery robot👀 Looking for the latest gadgets? Check out our picks, gift guides, and best deals all year round📩 Want more? Sign up for our daily newsletter and never miss our latest and greatest storiesRead More



Leave A Comment

More News

WIRED

Jargon Watch: What ‘Roadmanship’ Means to a Self-Driving 2019-02-18 06:00:00More than a century later, the quaint term is back as a basis for long-­overdue safety standards in autonomous vehicles. 

How a DIY Tesla Mechanic Resurrects Damaged Electric 2019-02-18 06:00:00Rich Benoit stumps for the right-to-repair movement, pushing uncooperative manufacturers to make it easier for owners to fix stuff themselves.

Digging Into Self-Driving Data and More Car News 2019-02-17 09:00:00Plus: We bid adieu to the Airbus A380, Amazon makes a move, and we take a tour of the gear that keeps Nascar racers on the oval.

Uber Sues NYC to Kill Its Ride-Hail Car 2019-02-15 19:42:26New York's mayor says the rule, which halts the granting of new licenses, is vital for reining in congestion. Uber says the city is overreaching.

See All the Tools and Tricks That Make 2019-02-15 09:00:00If perfectly arranged drawers and heart-stopping car racing is your thing, you'll be glad to meet the crews who make it happen.

Au Revoir, Airbus A380 2019-02-14 20:53:54It was so huge that it required a whole special bespoke transportation logistics setup, but no one wanted to buy it.

A New Robo-Car Report Card Isn't Quite What 2019-02-13 22:09:35The numbers are a little jumbly, but reports published by the state’s DMV show progress toward the day when humans are unshackled from the steer

Americans Are Abandoning Public Transit—but Don't Blame Uber 2019-02-13 09:00:00In a world of cheap gas, easy-come auto loans, ride-hail, and now a new breed of bike- and scooter-share, transit riders aren’t riding like they

Forget People, Elroy's Self-Flying Drone Hauls Heavy Cargo 2019-02-13 08:00:00The hybrid-powered aircraft will carry up to 500 pounds with a range of 300 miles and could enter service next year.

Softbank Invests $1B in Robo-Delivery Startup Nuro 2019-02-11 20:49:48So get ready to see a lot more of the company's toaster-inspired, human-free robots roaming the street, delivering groceries.

Amazon's Self-Driving Bet and More Car News This 2019-02-10 09:00:00The logistics giant invests in autonomous vehicle startup Aurora, the micromobility world ponders its future, we review the new Porsche 911, and more.

The Green New Deal's Trains and EVs Won't 2019-02-08 20:24:01Access to cars is the best short-term solution for connecting lower-income people to jobs, but the autos they can afford are the worst for the planet.

Automotive News Breaking

Ford investigating possible problems with fuel economy, emissions 2019-02-21 17:04:03Ford has been investigating concerns raised by employees that incorrect calculations were used to translate test results into the mileage and emission

Visteon Q4 net income rose 72%, shares climb 2019-02-21 15:54:41Despite industry headwinds, Visteon posted $43 million in fourth-quarter net income and forecast continued strong results for 2019.

Honda Passport will get TV push during Oscars, 2019-02-21 15:00:00Honda has put together a full marketing itinerary for its recently launched Passport crossover.

Auto origination bump in Q3 of 2018 smaller 2019-02-21 14:08:49Auto originations grew half a percent year-over-year, substantially below TransUnion's initial origination forecast of 5.5 percent growth.

White House confirms it ended California talks on 2019-02-21 14:04:52The Trump administration has ended talks with California over federal plans to roll back fuel economy rules designed to reduce greenhouse gas emi

Delphi reports $135 million in Q4 net income; 2019-02-21 12:53:38Delphi Technologies, the former powertrain unit of Delphi Automotive, reported a surge in fourth-quarter net income, aided by a tax gain, even as

Subaru reaches top of Consumer Reports' rankings; Tesla 2019-02-21 12:45:00In an annual reliability scorecard, Subaru narrowly topped last year's winner, Genesis, and Tesla's Model 3 failed to win a "recommended" rating a

Canada's Unifor faces Catch-22 in fight with GM 2019-02-21 11:12:02Unifor President Jerry Dias concedes there is mixed support for a general walkout among unionized workers at GM's Oshawa, Ont., plant. Some workers f

Is Tesla a cult? Sonic's Dyke wonders as 2019-02-21 07:03:06One of the largest U.S. auto dealers just had a rough quarter selling BMWs, and a top executive said Tesla played a major role.

Nissan downgraded on weak profit outlook after Ghosn 2019-02-21 06:31:34Nissan's credit rating was lowered for the first time in a decade by S&P to A- from A. The outlook on the long-term debt score is stable, the rat

Audi targets 10% of management jobs as it 2019-02-20 13:59:17"One thing is clear, our cost base is too high," CEO Bram Schot told German newspaper Handelsblatt.

So long, 'Cobo': Detroit auto show venue to 2019-02-20 11:30:25A bank has purchased the naming rights of Cobo Center in a 22-year deal that will change the brand of the city's convention center.

RSS Autoplus.fr

Du nouveau pour le Volkswagen Multivan (2019) 2019-02-21 14:16:30Le Multivan, descendant du Volkswagen Combi, profite de nombreuses mises à jour. Il sera même bientôt disponible en version 100% &e

F1 - Hülkenberg en tête aux essais de 2019-02-21 12:42:54Nico Hülkenberg a signé le meilleur temps lors de la dernière journée d'essais à Barcelone, avant d'avoir un probl&

Le Range Rover Evoque II tombe dans le 2019-02-21 12:33:02Découvrez le nouveau 4x4 Range Rover Evoque dans une vidéo insolite.

Série spéciale "N-Motion" pour le Nissan Qashqai 2019-02-21 12:06:57Nissan lance une nouvelle série spéciale dans la gamme du Qashqai : la N-Motion, qui fait notamment le plein de technologies.

L'Audi e-tron Sportback (2019) aperçu 2019-02-21 11:30:01L'Audi e-tron Sportback a été aperçu sur la route à quelques mois de sa mise en production.

DiRT Rally 2.0: bande-annonce de lancement [Vidéo] 2019-02-21 10:00:22VIDEO. Découvrez la bande-annonce de lancement officielle du jeu DiRT Rally 2.0 qui sortira sur PS4, Xbox One, Xbox One X et PC le mardi 2

Mitsubishi Engelberg Tourer : deuxième aperçu ! 2019-02-21 08:54:40Mitsubishi a dévoilé un second cliché du concept Engelberg Tourer en annonçant son programme pour le prochain salon de Gen

La Challenger Demon bat des records aux enchères 2019-02-21 07:14:13Les prix grimpent aux enchères pour la radicale Dodge Challenger Demon (photo).

La Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake (2019) à Genève 2019-02-21 06:46:01Le programme de Mercedes pour le salon de Genève compte plusieurs premières mondiales.

Pour Elon Musk, vous dormirez au volant fin 2019-02-21 06:19:35Le PDG de Tesla Motors annonce une conduite entièrement autonome à (très) court terme.

Genève 2019 : quoi de neuf chez Renault 2019-02-21 06:05:41Le groupe Renault vient de dévoiler son programme pour le 89ème salon automobile de Genève, qui se déroulera du 7 au 17 ma

1er teaser d’un concept 100% électrique signé Kia 2019-02-21 04:55:10Le constructeur sud-coréen Kia fera le déplacement à Genève avec un prototype zéro émission.

Motor Trend

2020 Porsche 911 Turbo 992 Leaks on Instagram 2019-02-21 17:53:32Porsche owner and enthusiast Todd Schleicher has posted what could be the first public images of the 992-generation 2020 Porsche 911 Turbo on his Inst

Spied! Chevrolet Caught Testing a Small Fleet of 2019-02-21 16:26:32Earlier this month, we caught yet another mid-engine Corvette prototype out testing on public roads. Interestingly, it wasn’t running around in

Rivian Files Patent for Removable Auxiliary Battery 2019-02-21 16:00:02Rivian shot to stardom last year with its stylish electric pickup and SUV. The R1T and R1S could give Tesla a run for its money with each boasting a t

Most Small SUVs Perform Well in New Pedestrian 2019-02-21 14:45:35The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety has introduced a pedestrian crash prevention test into its rating system. Overall, the first batch of vehic

Kia Teases Something Sporty and Electric for Geneva 2019-02-21 14:00:27Kia is on a roll with its exterior designs lately. From the sleek, premium brand-rivaling Stinger to the rugged-looking Telluride, Kia has made a name

How Autonomous Autobahn Could Rise from High-Speed Rail’s 2019-02-21 12:25:26After decades of posturing about how high-speed rail was going to be California’s transportation salvation, new Governor Gavin Newsom poleaxed t

Tesla’s Fully Autonomous Features Will Be Complete This 2019-02-21 12:15:11Tesla has missed key deadlines in the past, but that hasn’t stopped CEO Elon Musk from setting ambitious timelines for autonomous cars. Musk say

2019 Bentley Continental GT W12 First Test: If 2019-02-21 04:00:39Call it the Ocasio-Cortez Effect. We are witnessing a pendulum swing of sorts—a backlash against the trappings of excessive wealth and conspicuo

Spied! MKC-Replacing Lincoln Corsair Looks Like a Mini 2019-02-20 20:45:53It’s refreshing to see Lincoln finally getting the love and resources it deserves. Sure, they might not be getting poured into the Panther-platf

Is This the Next-Generation Ford Ranger? 2019-02-20 18:00:54The Ford Ranger arrived on our shores this year after a long hiatus, but the North American truck is based on a design that’s been on the global

Hero, Zero: The Rise and Fall of Carlos 2019-02-20 04:00:32January 2003. I’m talking with a senior auto industry analyst about Carlos Ghosn. “If it was announced Ghosn was about to take the top job

2018 Honda Civic Type R Long-Term Update 4: 2019-02-20 04:00:16In the last update, I relayed what editor-in-chief Ed Loh’s wife, Giulia—er, Julia—a self-declared CTR “newbie,” thought

Automotive news - from

Valeo 2018 net attributable income down 38% to 2019-02-21 12:15:00Valeo has posted 2018 net attributable income down 38% to EUR546m, with sales up 6% to EUR19.3bn in line with its guidance last year.

Malaysia vehicle sales rise 9% in January 2019-02-21 10:01:00Malaysia's new vehicle market expanded by 8.7% to 48,450 units in January from 44,560 units in the same month of last year, according to registration

Toyota invests in Thai EV/hybrid production 2019-02-21 09:47:00Toyota said it plans to invest THB10bn (US$320m) annually in its Thai operations in the next few years to bring on line new vehicle models including e

Visteon 2018 net income down 4.5% to US$164m 2019-02-21 09:11:00Visteon has posted full-year 2018 net income down 4.5% to US$164m, while sales fell to US$2.98bn compared to US$3.15bn

FTA adds voice welcoming HMRC admin move 2019-02-21 07:15:00Britain's Freight Transport Association (FTA) has added its voice to industry bodies welcoming HMRC's (Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs) announcem

Delphi Technologies Q4 revenue down 9% to US$1.2bn 2019-02-21 07:04:00Delphi Technologies has reported fourth quarter 2018 revenue down 9% to US$1.2bn.

Pennsylvania GBP3bn boost from EVs says DEP plan 2019-02-21 06:05:00Pennsylvania says it could gain almost US$2.8bn in benefits from lower greenhouse gas emissions, help reduce respiratory disease, increase consumer sa

Scania and Nobina to trial autonomous electric buses 2019-02-21 05:59:00Scania and Nobina, the largest public transport operator in the Nordic countries, will collaborate to commence trials of autonomous buses on regular r

BMW to add 2,000 more jobs at Dingolfing 2019-02-21 05:53:00BMW says it will add 2,000 jobs at its German Dinglolfing as it ramps up investment in electrification.

BMW Group to open Technology Office in Israel 2019-02-21 05:52:00BMW is to open an office for trend and technology scouting in Israel.

Veoneer partner in AI Innovation of Sweden 2019-02-21 05:05:00Veoneer says it is one of the founding partners in AI Innovation of Sweden, a new Swedish national centre for accelerating research and innovatio

PSA claims EUR5bn France trade balance surplus 2019-02-21 04:59:00PSA claims it was a key contributor to France's trade balance in 2018, with a surplus of EUR4.9bn (US$6bn).


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.