• Follow us


In the pay equity fight, Canada's biggest provinces are ground zero - Macleans.ca

Minister of Labour Patricia Hajdu during Question Period in the House of Commons on Oct. 23, 2018. (Adrian Wyld/CP)

In last year’s federal budget, Finance Minister Bill Morneau unveiled a plan to establish the Department of Women and Gender Equality, or, appropriately, “WAGE.” It was an all-caps commitment from a self-proclaimed “feminist” Liberal government to address a big issue and make strides toward pay parity after a decade of stagnation.

Canada has a problem paying men and women equally for equal work (no matter what the internet trolls tell you). Recent numbers from Statistics Canada suggest that women working full-time earned 74.2 cents for every dollar made by a man. Pay equity has been baked into the Canadian Human Rights Act for decades, but progress has been slow.

So Morneau’s announcement in February was seen as progress. As was the Pay Equity Act, tabled in late October by Patricia Hajdu, the minister of employment, workforce development and labour. That law will require federally regulated employers—in the banking and transport sectors, for example—to proactively spot and remedy unfair pay practices, rather than dealing with them on the basis of case-by-case complaints. The government will also appoint a pay equity commissioner to conduct audits and regulate enforcement.

READ MORE: Why the gender pay gap is everyone’s problem

These steps offered reasons to be optimistic about the arc of our nation’s pay progress. But, in keeping with the time-honoured seesaw of politics, where there are steps forward, there will inevitably be steps back. We’re seeing them at the provincial level.

Pay equity battles in Canada’s two biggest provinces will be litmus tests for how the federal legislation might fare. Most provinces still rely on complaints-based handling of pay equity grievances, putting the onus on workers to highlight discrimination. But in Ontario and Quebec—just like in Denmark, Australia and the United Kingdom—employers are expected to root out inequities themselves. In Quebec, employers with 10 or more employees must file annual pay equity plans, demonstrating that they have looked for—and addressed—any imbalances between the wages of female workers and men in similar roles. Further, the Supreme Court recently ruled that changes to the law that created five-year audit periods were unconstitutional. Those changes had meant women sometimes waited years for inequities to be acknowledged, then did not receive retroactive payments in compensation. The ruling was hailed by labour organizations and women’s activists.

Ontario Premier Doug Ford speaks during Question Period at the Ontario Legislature on Sept. 12, 2018. (Chris Young/CP)

But if Quebec appears to be moving forward, Ontario has backslid. In November 2017, the Liberal government passed the Fair Workplaces, Better Jobs Act, which mandated a one-dollar hike in the province’s $14 minimum wage, along with reforms of paid sick days and vacation entitlements, and an equal pay for equal work provision. A year later, the backswing: in the name of job growth, Premier Doug Ford’s Progressive Conservatives passed the Making Ontario Open for Business Act. While the PCs preserved the requirement for equal pay on the basis of sex, the province’s minimum wage will be frozen until October 2020—a massive blow to women, who make up 58.3 per cent of the province’s minimum-wage workforce.

The new legislation is “very distressing,” says Katherine Scott, a senior economist at the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA). “Minimum wage, labour standards and pay equity are all pieces of a puzzle. They aren’t, by themselves, going to guarantee an improvement to the lived experiences of women, but without them, you’ve got no hope in hell,” she says. The CCPA has been a vocal proponent for raising Ontario’s minimum wage, explaining in a recent report (called “Ontario Needs a Raise”) that of the 633,000 people who would have received wage raises in Toronto, 368,000 were women, and many were new immigrants. “From what I can read from Doug Ford’s actions, there is a lack of respect for low-wage or precarious workers,” Scott says. “Clearly these kinds of disparities don’t appear to be of concern to him, and I worry about whether other premiers will be emboldened to erode potential wage gains for women.”

RELATED: What it would really take to close the gender wage gap

Janet Borowy, co-chair of the Equal Pay Coalition, says the PCs’ reforms are “deeply concerning signals” that the Liberals’ efforts toward pay parity will be stalled—perhaps permanently. Her worries may be founded: in its fall economic statement, Ontario’s Ministry of Finance announced it would be postponing the implementation of the Liberals’ Pay Transparency Act. The legislation, set for a Jan. 1 rollout, would bar employers from asking job candidates about current or past compensation and require them to include salary ranges in advertised job postings. Employers would also need to report gender-related pay gaps to the province and post results in their own workplaces by 2021.

Meanwhile, over at the Ontario Pay Equity Commission, there’s more bad news. In a statement, Emanuela Heyninck (Ontario’s current pay equity commissioner) explained that her term expires at the end of November 2018. “To date,” she says, “a successor has not been announced.”

Borowy says these rollbacks are a “huge hit to women’s economic justice” on the provincial front. But as the federal government looks to implement its own proactive approaches, she anticipates a “very significant stride for pay equity in this country.” Yet the national legislation is not without its own flaws, one of which is timeliness: Hajdu has told reporters she does not want to “rush the process” of implementation, and that after the bill passes, employers will have up to three years to comply with the new regulations. (The expectations will differ for companies depending on their number of employees.) Labour and women’s groups are also lobbying on some of the finer details of the bill. “There are some pieces of the bill that demand further attention,” says Scott, “but the foundations are good.” Still, the success of the whole thing hinges on “having enough resources dedicated to enforcement.”

READ MORE: Glad you asked: Why your justification for the pay gap is bunk

Enforcement, she says, has historically been an issue in Ontario and Quebec. Alex Bell, a principal in Mercer Canada’s career consultancy, says that pay transparency, while progressive, can be a tough sell for non-unionized businesses and those outside the public sector. “From what I’ve seen, gender equality within the workplace is on the mind of lots of employers, regardless of legislation that demands they think about it,” he says. “But a lot of people were very concerned about some aspects of the transparency in Ontario—namely, the part about disclosing salary ranges in an external job posting. That shows your hand to your competition, which is not something most businesses want to do.”

If enforcement is key to the success of pay equity laws, public sentiment is an equally critical component of their inception. And, as Scott suggests, all this feminist progress has stirred up an unsurprising but still disheartening resistance: “I find it troubling that we’re on the cusp of some important gains in the labour movement and—whether it’s about #MeToo or something else—you can just feel the vitriol.” Too many people are asking, “ ‘What does it matter what women are paid?’ ” she says. “It’s this kind of thinking that continues to exploit people who are already very marginalized.” Even if the battle for pay equity in Canada is currently mired in reactive legislation and bureaucratic delays, Borowy suggests keeping watch on the activist community for clues to what will happen in the coming months and years. “If you want to know what the state of pay equity will be in 2019, keep an eye on the women’s march in January,” she says. “Women are done waiting—they’re taking to the streets, and I’m very heartened by the groundswell.” Adds Scott, “How are we going to break this logjam? Well, pay equity and transparency aren’t going to necessarily close the wage gap.” But without them? “We absolutely won’t.”


Leave A Comment

More News

Economy – Macleans.ca

Does the B.C. gas pipeline need approval from 2019-01-09 17:29:50An influential hereditary leader explains the dilemma arising from Unist'ot'en protest, and what it says about Ottawa's attitude toward First Natio

Why Canada’s MBA programs are beating American competition 2019-01-07 17:23:58Applications to American MBA programs are falling. In Canada, they’re skyrocketing. What’s behind the trends? (Hint: It’s not just a

This is how Canada’s housing correction begins 2019-01-03 17:45:31Canadians are finally getting a taste of what a world with rising interest rates will look like, and one thing is painfully clear: we’re not rea

When it comes to business schools, bigger isn’t 2019-01-02 13:31:30Many aspiring MBA students are hell-bent on getting a degree from a flashy, big-name school. But it pays to consider smaller options. The perfect scho

Can Vine, Winamp, Gawker and the Razr make 2018-12-31 07:00:51They all looked very, very dead, once. But these companies will try to resurrect themselves this year. The post Can Vine, Winamp, Gawker and the Razr

Canada Goose takes flight across the globe 2018-12-26 07:00:54The Canadian parka maker plots a major expansion—starting with China The post Canada Goose takes flight across the globe appeared first on Macle

In the pay equity fight, Canada’s biggest provinces 2018-12-21 07:00:282018 was a year of closing Canada’s gender wage gap. 2019 will be a year of painful delays. The post In the pay equity fight, Canada’s big

Canada, it’s time to pay off that debt 2018-12-20 17:02:26Angela Wright: Canada's combined household debt is over $2 trillion. As the era of cheap credit comes to an end, it’s time for Canadians to fac

Brexit’s worst case scenario: food rationing and drug 2018-12-20 16:56:37As Brexit negotiations drag on, the country faces dire consequences The post Brexit’s worst case scenario: food rationing and drug shortages app

The Canadian startups that could be billion-dollar breakouts 2018-12-19 17:06:38These 10 tech firms on the rise could hit a billion-dollar valuation—but will they? The post The Canadian startups that could be billion-dollar

The Trans Mountain expansion will struggle for years—even 2018-12-17 13:43:37It isn’t dead, but Ottawa’s purchase could be resting a long time as it navigates a maze of challenges The post The Trans Mountain expansi

On Huawei, Trudeau fails to assert the Canadian 2018-12-17 13:23:36Terry Glavin: Canada has been repeatedly warned that the telecom giant poses a security threat. Yet when he talks about China, the PM is all wishy-was

: Money

Bank of Canada keeps key rate at 1.75%, 2019-01-09 10:23:54Amid a clouding economy outlook, the bank is pushing the pause button.

Bank of Canada expected to decide on interest 2019-01-09 06:43:43Governor Stephen Poloz has raised the benchmark five times since the summer of 2017 and he's instructed Canadians to prepare for an eventual era of t

Husky Energy says it may sell 500 retail 2019-01-09 00:10:37Husky Energy Inc. says it is looking at getting out of retailing fuels to consumers after 80 years in the business.

Oil-price rout doubles Canada’s trade deficit to $2.1B 2019-01-08 10:17:28Plunging crude prices were the main reason for the widening deficit, but the bad news extends beyond the energy sector.

7 hacks to save more — without the 2019-01-05 06:00:41Saving and paying down debt is hard. But there are ways to make it easier for your brain.

Analysts say Canada’s 2 major railways well-poised for 2019-01-04 17:16:53Canada's two major railways are well-positioned to weather potential economic headwinds and the U.S.-China trade war, analysts say, as ongoing invest

Stellar U.S. jobs report prompts all-caps Trump Tweet 2019-01-04 09:58:42The U.S. economy created 312,000 jobs in December, 128,000 above economists' expectations.

Unemployment still at 43-year low in December, but 2019-01-04 09:13:26Workers' pay is still growing more slowly than inflation.

Stock markets slide after Apple reveals declining iPhone 2019-01-03 15:21:46The rare warning of disappointing results from Apple reinforced investors' fears that the world's second-biggest economy is losing steam and that tr

The TFSA limit has grown to $6K — 2019-01-03 13:38:59Canadians hoping to save money after the holiday spending now have an option to stash away more cash this year -- and tax-free.

Suncor warns forced oil cutbacks in Alberta pose 2018-12-15 12:19:06Forced Alberta government crude oil production cuts next year will result in "unintended consequences'' that could include increased safety hazards

4 year-end tax tips to make the most 2018-12-15 06:50:34Cleaning up your tax act before the end of the year could yield a bigger tax refund or give one last boost to your 2018 savings.

Canada Business - The

Ontario Cannabis Lottery Has Small Business Owners Holding 2019-01-09 14:53:00Christine Cohen's inbox was flooded after she said on live TV she was applying for a highly sought-after cannabis retail licence in Ontario's lotter

Legal Marijuana In Canada Much More Expensive Than 2019-01-09 14:35:00OTTAWA — Statistics Canada says that the average price of a legal gram of recreational pot last year was $9.70, nearly 50 per cent higher than t

Canada's Economic Outlook Gets Downgrade From Bank Of 2019-01-09 12:44:00OTTAWA — The Bank of Canada left its trend-setting interest rate unchanged at 1.75 per cent Wednesday as the sharp decline in oil prices tempora

What Is Canada's Target Inflation Rate And Why 2019-01-09 11:34:00

Canadian Luxury Home Sales Took A Deep Dive 2019-01-09 10:20:00TORONTO — Sales of luxury properties declined sharply in three of Canada's biggest cities last year as homebuyers retreated amid tightened mort

Trudeau’s Government Isn’t Truly Feminist Without Universal Daycare: 2019-01-09 10:17:00OTTAWA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's efforts to run a feminist government should take an extra step to create a universal daycare system, a

GM's Oshawa Plant Hit By Work Stoppage As 2019-01-09 10:04:00OSHAWA, Ont. — Unionized workers at the General Motors assembly plant in Oshawa, Ont., are holding another sit-down protest over the planned clo

Digital Privacy Concerns Arise As Bell Asks Customers 2019-01-08 11:57:00TORONTO — Canada's largest telecommunications group is getting mixed reviews for its plan to follow the lead of companies like Google and Faceb

Canadian Interest Rates: What Would It Take For 2019-01-08 11:28:00Like many other market observers, Central 1 expects the Bank of Canada will hike its influential key interest rate this year — but the credit un

'Renovictions' Set To Rise In Canada In 2019, 2019-01-08 09:47:00Amid predictions of rising rents in some of Canada's already-red-hot markets, a new report shows there could be bad things to come even for those who

Canadian Electric Car Adoption Rates Lag Behind World: 2019-01-08 09:22:00

Living Wages Are Good For Ontario's Businesses And 2019-01-07 12:52:00On New Year's Eve, Rocco Rossi, president and CEO of the Ontario Chamber of Commerce (OCC), chose to finish off 2018 with a crass attempt at humour h

CBC | Business News

Paul Godfrey steps down as Postmedia CEO as 2019-01-10 18:53:13Postmedia Network Canada Corp. announced Thursday that Paul Godfrey is stepping down as CEO and will be succeeded by president and chief operating off

Canada dusts off old message for new anti-tariff 2019-01-10 17:00:00The prime minister's inner circle is ramping up another lobbying push in Washington to terminate American tariffs on steel and aluminum.

As Bezos divorce unfurls, investors wonder — what 2019-01-10 15:42:26Amazon.com Inc. shares seesawed on Thursday as investors questioned how the impending divorce of company founder Jeff Bezos would affect his control o

Fiat Chrysler agrees to U.S. diesel-emissions settlement worth 2019-01-10 12:53:12Fiat Chrysler Automobiles NV has agreed to a settlement worth about $800 million US to resolve claims from the U.S. Justice Department and state of Ca

Fed will be patient with rate hikes, Jerome 2019-01-10 12:38:26Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell says the central bank has the ability to be "patient" in determining when to hike interest rates.

Ford to shake up European business, cut jobs 2019-01-10 10:44:51Ford Motor Co. says it is cutting jobs in Europe in a wide-ranging restructuring as it focuses on its most profitable models and shifts production tow

U.S., China leave next steps for trade talks 2019-01-10 04:38:13The United States says talks in Beijing on ending a bruising trade war focused on Chinese promises to buy more American goods, but gave no indication

Bank of Canada once again faces the dilemma 2019-01-10 04:00:00As oil weakens and the tech sector booms, it really is a tale of two economies for Canada's chief central banker — with no place to hide from g

Biggest trend in new car technology? Super-sized screens 2019-01-09 22:08:14An electric vehicle startup has unveiled a jaw-dropping, 48-inch screen inside one of its prototypes at the global technology conference in Las Vegas.

Canada's main stock index posts biggest gains in 2019-01-09 17:59:13Canada's main stock index posted its strongest four-day gain in three years Wednesday as it was propelled by a large increase in the price of crude o

Algoma Steel Inc. getting help from governments as 2019-01-09 17:52:57Federal and provincial ministers will arrive in Sault Ste. Marie Thursday afternoon to announce financing assistance for new investments at Algoma Ste

Former B.C. financial consultant who owes $195K in 2019-01-09 17:27:37A Surrey woman who was largely banned from the investment industry because of her involvement in a Ponzi scheme has been sent to jail for 30 days for

Christian Science Monitor |

Recession is a risk in 2019. But maybe 2019-01-10 15:07:44A number of key trends in the economy are positive, from wage growth to low interest rates. Some of the biggest wild cards are trade policy and centra

Stocks dive, again. Does Wall Street foresee a 2019-01-10 15:07:44After several strong years, stock markets look rattled as 2018 draws to a close. A mix of factors signal a heightened risk of a slowdown, but an outri

Where local residents help birth the businesses that 2019-01-10 15:07:44Often new businesses rely on financing from a top-down system where bankers call the shots. For places that feel left behind, often communities o

From hemp to organic foods, farm bill embraces 2019-01-10 15:07:44Passage of the farm bill is a rite of Congress that often borders on the arcane. But this year’s version signals how American farming is gradual

Post-layoffs, GM fights to keep tax credit for 2019-01-10 15:07:44A $7,500 tax incentive for buyers of electric vehicles is critical for General Motors as it ramps up production in the EV market. But some government

Qatar leaves OPEC, cementing distance with Saudi Arabia 2019-01-10 15:07:44Qatar will leave the world's largest consortium of oil producing countries in a bid to expand natural gas and oil drilling even as oil prices remain

Which fork in the road to take? Detroit 2019-01-10 15:07:44US carmakers appear poised to try two paths forward at once, building more SUVs and pickups, which the US market loves, to pay their way along a 

It’s a wide world of charity out there. 2019-01-10 15:07:44As ‘Giving Tuesday’ arrives, it’s a good time to think about charitable donations. Increasingly, average givers are focusi

Preparing for tech shift, GM cuts thousands of 2019-01-10 15:07:44The largest automaker in the US, General Motors, announced Nov. 26 that it would cut as many as 14,000 workers in North America. The cuts affect both

Instead of amplifying human biases, can algorithms help 2019-01-10 15:07:44The rising use of artificial intelligence has become one of the dominant trends in business. On the heels of that trend come questions about fairness

Ahead of Black Friday, market sees red 2019-01-10 15:07:44The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped 600 points on Nov. 20 as tech companies and retailers face losses and an oil surplus pushed barrel prices low

Hard times in farm country coincide with a 2019-01-10 15:07:44Farmers are resourceful by necessity. But many face a test as a US-China rift undercuts their exports – a challenge familiar to those who weathe

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.