• Follow us

Canada

The SNC-Lavalin scandal is proof our system of government is working. Seriously. - Macleans.ca

How can we tell if our system of government is working? In the past few weeks, we’ve learned that Canada’s Attorney General may have been inappropriately pressured by the Prime Minister’s Office and the Clerk of the Privy Council. This is a serious accusation. If true, the Prime Minister and his closest political and bureaucratic advisors would have violated the constitutional independence of the chief law officer of the Crown. For critics, this is proof that Canadian democracy is in serious trouble. The crisis shows that the Prime Minister’s Office is too strong, hell-bent on getting its way and willing to ride roughshod over ministers who dare to stand up for themselves. This wouldn’t have happened in a properly functioning democracy.

Does this assessment hold up? Only if you think that the test of a democracy is the absence of scandal, rather than how the system handles crises that inevitably arise.

Principled critics have implied that the health of our democracy should be judged on our ability to avoid problems in the first place. The suggestion appears to be that the system only works if it runs without error or malice. In a real democracy, they argue, no one would dare pressure the Attorney General. And if they did, they should be condemned by all, including their fellow partisans; a corrupted system must make a harsh example of wrongdoers to right itself. Anything less is a sign of complacency, or worse, rot.

PAUL WELLS: Justin Trudeau, imposter

Perfection or heads on pikes. Utopia or bust. These are the hallmarks of democratic vitality.

Forgive me for my cynicism, but that sets the bar fairly high, perhaps unattainably so. As much as we would like to be governed by the uniquely virtuous, the reality is that government is staffed with humans — fallen, fallible, factional creatures. While our democratic principles demand the best from our leaders, our constitutional constructs include checks and balances to deal with their naturally occurring slip-ups. As James Madison observed: “If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself.”

We know our system is working when the safeguards we’ve put in place to address government chicanery kick in and do their job. To use an analogy, a human body is healthy when its immune system successfully deals with infections. I don’t consider that infections are, in and of themselves, evidence that a body is deathly ill. I think it’s useful to see how the immune system deals with an illness before shopping for a coffin. Likewise, I wouldn’t recommend a blood-letting for every case of the flu.

Thus far in the SNC-Lavalin affair, a number of our system’s checks have been triggered. We’re not just talking about the resignation of the former Attorney General then Veterans’ Affairs minister here. We’re talking about the resignation of the prime minister’s principal secretary and the President of the Treasury Board; concern within the Liberal caucus; testimony before a Liberal-majority parliamentary committee that has put the government in the toughest spot it’s ever been; and sustained media and opposition critiques that are swaying public opinion. All this after, what, a month?

In fact, if anything, this whole saga has shown that common complaints about the hollowness of our democracy are too simplistic and don’t reflect how our system can rise to the occasion.

READ: The Philpott earthquake

Does the PMO have a lot of power in our system, perhaps too much? Yes. Does it have unconstrained authority and an ability to impose its will on Cabinet and the executive. Not necessarily. A PMO that dominated all of Cabinet wouldn’t have had to lean on a minister to get what it wanted. Strong ministers can push back, particularly when the law gives them unique responsibilities.

Ah, but didn’t PMO shuffle the minister out? Doesn’t that prove that PMO is all powerful? Well, no. If you have to shuffle a minister to get what you want, then you’re using raw prerogative power to compensate for a lack of authority. Also, the PMO still hasn’t gotten what it wanted in the SNC affair and it may never.

What about accountability? Doesn’t this whole thing show that the only way to hold the governing party to account is to defeat it during a general election? Quite the opposite. The events of the past month show us what accountability looks like between elections. Whether there are additional ministerial resignations or not, the prime minister will have to keeping answering tough charges and likely make course corrections if he hopes to assuage his caucus and win back voters.

READ: Resigning on principle? It (almost) never happens in politics

This controversy has also shown that parliamentary committees can perform a vital accountability function, even when there’s a majority government and governing party MPs hold the balance of power. The Liberal-dominated justice committee allowed the former Minister of Justice and Attorney General to testify for three hours. She detailed how and why she felt improperly pressured by the PMO and bullied by the Clerk. Although the Liberal committee members pushed her a bit here and there, she made her case, and it was a pretty devasting one for the government. Since parliamentary committees are usually portrayed as pointless partisan theatre, this is surprising. And yet the committee is doing a pretty admirable job thus far, all things considered. Parliament does what it’s supposed to do when it must.

Are our governments perfect? Far from it. But our constitution has mechanisms to hold governments to account. If there’s a silver lining to be found in the SNC affair, it’s that we’re witnessing a healthy democratic immune system at work.

Philippe Lagassé is an associate professor of international affairs at Carleton University. His research focuses on the Westminster system. He tweets @PhilippeLagasse and blogs at www.lagassep.com

MORE ABOUT SNC-LAVALIN: Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

Canada – Macleans.ca

SNC-Lavalin: From scandal to soap opera 2019-03-07 07:00:44Politics Insider for March 7: Butts testifies, Wilson-Raybould offers to offer more, and Wernick says no 'threats' were made The post SNC-Lavalin: F

For fentanyl importers, Canada Post is the shipping 2019-03-07 05:00:48Most fentanyl enters Canada via the mail, thanks to an antiquated law. Why hasn’t the government acted? The post For fentanyl importers, Canada

Gerry Butts just showed Canadians his two greatest 2019-03-06 17:27:29The PM's former right hand voiced respect and affection for Jody Wilson-Raybould. Then he contradicted her. The post Gerry Butts just showed Canadia

Trudeau tries to change the channel on SNC-Lavalin, 2019-03-06 07:00:50Politics Insider for March 6: Trudeau to show 'contrition' over SNC-Lavalin affair, Butts gets his turn at the mic and the Liberals pitch their nati

‘The other guys suck’ is not a campaign 2019-03-05 18:19:33The SNC-Lavalin affair has reduced the Liberals to a risky strategem: betting their opponents are a bigger turn-off than they are The post ‘The

Gerry Butts bingo 2019-03-05 17:20:41Anne Kingston: Wednesday's hearing will require that Trudeau's former principal secretary find a high road heretofore untravelled by the government

Trudeau’s ‘sunny ways’ were doomed to meet their 2019-03-05 14:01:14David Moscrop: It's an insanely hard country to govern. The Liberals were foolish to pretend otherwise. The post Trudeau’s ‘sunny ways&rs

The SNC-Lavalin scandal is proof our system of 2019-03-05 13:21:48Opinion: If there's a silver lining to be found in the SNC-Lavalin and Jody Wilson-Raybould affair, it's that we're witnessing a healthy democratic

The best and worst places to be a 2019-03-05 11:25:35The two cities at the top and bottom of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives ranking are only about a three-hour drive apart in southern Ontari

Jane Philpott’s vote of no confidence in Trudeau 2019-03-05 07:00:54Politics Insider for March 5: Philpott follows Wilson-Raybould out the cabinet door, Trudeau's full 'phoniness' on display and Doug Ford's banana

Saved, then lost once more 2019-03-04 18:37:54The Barhos dreamed of a family with lots of children and joy. When civil war broke out in Syria, they fled for the safety of Canada. They loved their

Resigning on principle? It (almost) never happens in 2019-03-04 18:35:32When Jane Philpott stepped down as Treasury Board president on Monday, she joined a small handful of historic examples The post Resigning on principle

CBC | Canada News

It's called 'The Cramper' and it could provide 2019-03-07 07:00:00A Toronto man is unveiling an invention Thursday that he hopes can be part of the solution to homelessness. It's called The Cramper - a small structu

Oil slick off Newfoundland last November was 21 2019-03-07 05:30:00Emails between Husky Energy and the C-NLOPB shed new light on the size the sheens spotted after the largest offshore oil spill in the province's hist

Trudeau to apologize for mistreatment of Inuit with 2019-03-07 04:00:24Prime Minister Justin Trudeau will today visit Iqaluit to deliver a long-awaited apology on behalf of the federal government for the widespread mistre

Some 'snitch-line' tips on teaching about same-sex marriage 2019-03-07 04:00:00The Ontario government flagged parent complaints as “allegations of professional misconduct” about educators teaching same sex marriage, s

Tuberculosis patients who were sent south among Inuit 2019-03-07 04:00:00Representatives from the four Inuit regions of Canada, which stretch across the Arctic to Labrador, will be in Iqaluit today to hear Prime Minister Ju

A cyber war has started and Canada isn't 2019-03-07 04:00:00A new report questions how well prepared the Canadian military and the federal government are to fight a cyber war that, for all intents and purposes,

Wilson-Raybould vs. Butts: Two versions of the SNC-Lavalin 2019-03-07 04:00:00Gerald Butts, the prime minister's former principal secretary, offered his version of events regarding the SNC-Lavalin affair on Wednesday, a narrati

Drivers say automakers are putting lives at risk 2019-03-06 19:54:56A Vancouver family is blaming a big car company after experiencing engine failure on a B.C. highway — a life-threatening emergency they say coul

Canadian government will stop paying for homeopaths to 2019-03-06 19:44:36A Quebec-based aid group offering controversial homeopathic therapies in Honduras will not receive funding from the federal government after the 2019-

Former Canadian chief justice hired to investigate B.C. 2019-03-06 19:24:22Former Supreme Court of Canada chief justice Beverley McLachlin has been called in to investigate allegations of misconduct against two suspended B.C.

Trudeau's offer of Indigenous Services to Wilson-Raybould like 2019-03-06 18:59:06The prime minister's attempt to move Jody Wilson-Raybould to the Indigenous Services portfolio was a 'deeply humiliating' proposal and shows a lack

Midweek podcast: The other side of the SNC-Lavalin 2019-03-06 18:00:39In the wake of testimony from the prime minister's former right hand man Gerald Butts and new information from Michael Wernick, clerk of the Privy Co

: Canada

Oilsands producer CNRL raises dividend, reports fourth quarter 2019-03-07 08:24:00Canadian Natural Resources lost $776 million in the fourth quarter, compared with a profit of $396 million a year earlier.

Nova Scotia judo athletes return from successful Canada 2019-03-07 08:05:56Nova Scotia sent nine youth athletes to Red Deer, Alta., to compete at the Canada Games.

Urban planner looks to change Kingston skyline 2019-03-07 08:00:32Kingston city council heard from an urban planner who has designed several communities' skylines in an attempt to revitalize the downtown area.

Dennis Oland expected to continue testifying in his 2019-03-07 07:59:23Oland began his testimony late on Wednesday, declaring his innocence in the bludgeoning death of his father, Richard Oland, on July 6, 2011.

SNC-Lavalin urged Liberals to ease penalty for corporate 2019-03-07 07:09:44The engineering and construction giant recommended the Liberals leave wiggle room for a "zero debarment" time period under the government's integri

Daylight Saving Time 2019 starts this weekend: What 2019-03-07 07:00:42Clocks move forward Sunday at 2 a.m. in most of Canada for Daylight Saving Time.

Trudeau admits an ‘erosion of trust’ during SNC-Lavalin 2019-03-07 06:40:30Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says there was an "erosion of trust" between his office and former justice minister Jody Wilson-Raybould over the SNC-

B.C. — most of it — is springing 2019-03-07 02:08:44The time to 'Spring Ahead' is just around the corner, despite winter's tight grip on most of the country.

3 arrested for firing live ammunition in Burnaby’s 2019-03-07 01:54:38When officers arrived at Burnaby's Confederation Park, they found two men and a woman firing shots at a homemade target and into the water.

Lethbridge runners working to help Afghan women and 2019-03-07 00:55:47Wednesday marked the kickoff of the second annual Secret Marathon — a three-kilometre race held during the week of International Women’s D

Nutrien CEO explains decision to move 2 executives 2019-02-21 18:38:47Under provincial legislation, Nutrien must have a head office, chief executive officer and chief financial officer in Saskatchewan.

National running back Kienan Lafrance returns to Saskatchewan 2019-02-21 18:27:34The Saskatchewan Roughriders have signed national running back Kienan Lafrance to a one-year deal.

Canada stories

LILLEY: Ford right to pass on Taverner for 2019-03-07 07:46:21It took him a bit but Doug Ford is doing the right thing and looking for a new OPP Commish. Ontario hasn’t had a full-time commissioner of the O

Leafs finally blow a third-period lead as Edler 2019-03-07 07:22:03VANCOUVER – Frederik Andersen’s concentration broke for a split second. That was all Alexander Edler required to send the Maple Leafs to a

What to do with winter-weary skin 2019-03-07 07:00:12Feeling like the walking dead? Well you’re likely looking like you could play the part — extreme freezing temperatures have done your skin

ASK AMY: Confessing feelings for ‘friend’ causes confusion 2019-03-07 06:00:02Dear Amy: I need some relationship advice. A girl I’ve known for two years now and have developed feelings for ended things with her boyfriend.

March 7, 2019 2019-03-07 02:00:08Tim Dolighan

Letters to the Editor, March 7 2019-03-07 00:30:03GOING TO SCHOOL Re Ontario education spending: Why can’t unions and the NDP have an adult conversation when a temporary hiring freeze is on. It&

Morales proud to return the father figure favour 2019-03-06 22:42:19DUNEDIN — Kendrys Morales will never forget when he first met the Guerrero family and the profound and lasting effect the encounter would have o

Alleged dealer faces 100 weapons and drug charges 2019-03-06 22:02:56An alleged high-level drug dealer and an arsenal of weapons have been taken off the streets. Toronto Police Insp. Joe Matthews, of the Integrated Gun

Police hunting alleged fake Uber driving rapist 2019-03-06 21:57:50An Etobicoke man accused of posing as an Uber driver and raping a female passenger is now wanted by Toronto Police after he allegedly absconded on Fam

Even at Arnie’s place, eyes are on the 2019-03-06 21:47:29ORLANDO, Fla. — The world’s best golfers pride themselves on their ability to stay in the moment, but a day before the start of Arnold Pal

EDITORIAL: Ford right to rein in SIU 2019-02-21 18:43:46We agree with Premier Doug Ford’s planned legislation to limit the mandate of Ontario’s Special Investigations Unit when it comes to

CFL doubles up, awarding 2020, ’21 Grey Cups 2019-02-21 18:40:03The Canadian Football League went for two on Thursday — awarding the 2020 Grey Cup to Regina and the 2021 game to Hamilton — and in so doi

Vancouver Sun

Q&A: Vancouver actress Mackenzie Davis talks new One 2019-03-07 08:00:13Tully, Blade Runner actress talks new ambassador role.

Big in B.C.: 10 of the province's record-breaking, 2019-03-07 01:15:33This province is capable of big things, especially as it pertains to roadside attractions.

Surrey man charged with attempted murder after shooting 2019-03-07 00:55:32Police say the shooting was a targeted incident between two parties who know each other but that the teen was not the intended victim.

Blue-and-white wave washes over Rogers Arena with Leafs 2019-03-07 00:48:43From moving the opening puck-drop up so TV viewers in Ontario don't have to stay up too late — never mind what inconvenience that creates for C

B.C. Liberal MPs react to Butts's rebuttal on 2019-03-07 00:23:48Former senior staffer offered different account than former justice minister.

Frenzy of interest descends on Meng Wanzhou's court 2019-03-07 00:17:20The appearance of Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou in court March 6 was short and procedural, but, with tensions escalating, there was also a frenzy of public

Daphne Bramham: Times Up! There is no 'business 2019-03-07 00:15:43The whole point of empowering women is to disrupt the status quo. So why are the Trudeau Liberals so stunned that it has happened?

Huawei's Meng Wanzhou extradition case sparks 'serious concerns,' 2019-03-06 23:15:34'There are issues about the political character, political motivation, comments by the U.S. president,' detained Chinese business executive's lawye

Vaughn Palmer: Jurist star search lands McLachlin to 2019-03-06 22:08:28Beverley McLachlin is free to interview anyone she deems appropriate, and review any documents in the possession or control of the legislature, other

Rental retention the priority in launch of Broadway 2019-03-06 21:10:25The city has started the process to come up with a plan for the Broadway corridor in advance of a SkyTrain extension through the area.

Douglas Todd: The trouble with Canada’s ‘friendly dictators’ 2019-02-21 18:51:05Canadians have come to think the whip system of party discipline is a near-sacred tradition. But it’s largely avoided in most countries.

Former associate of Jamie Bacon describes murder plot 2019-02-21 18:24:09The witness, who can only be identified as AB due to a publication ban, said he agreed to be part of the plot to kill Dennis Karbovanec on Dec. 31, 20

Montreal Gazette

Brownstein: Take a human lesson from TV doc 2019-03-07 06:30:25'What is the point of prolonging our lives if we don’t remain active? We could really learn from the animal kingdom.'

Festival offers a diversity of song and workshops 2019-03-07 06:11:27The West Island-based Festival de la Voix opens March 16 with an eclectic mix of styles from Swedish folk, sung a cappella, to song from West Africa a

Montreal weather: Wind chill is a factor again 2019-03-07 06:00:58A quick look at the day's weather, along with a traffic update, a #ThisMtl photo and a quote of the day.

Canadiens at Sharks: Five things you should know 2019-03-07 06:00:41The last time the Canadiens won in San Jose was on Nov. 23, 1999, when Saku Koivu scored in overtime to give Montreal a 3-2 win.

History Through Our Eyes: March 7, 1990, David 2019-03-07 06:00:05Montreal was the second stop on Bowie's Sound and Vision Tour, which had opened in Quebec City two days earlier.

What's happening in the West Island and Off-Island 2019-03-07 05:55:37What's happening in the West Island and Off-Island this week

Can the Canadiens finally win a game in 2019-03-06 22:37:22Team locked in a four-way battle playoff positions in the East is trying to find a way to earn points in a place it hasn't won in 20 years.

Tattered Quebec flag a sign of disrespect, Westmount 2019-03-06 21:18:10"It's representative, it’s a symbol. It’s a small thing, but some people don’t care. Some people walk by and don’t notice it

Quebec farmlands need protection, but China isn't the 2019-03-06 20:55:11Quebec farmers say Quebecers needn't worry about Chinese interests buying up farmland, because Quebec investment firms are the real threat.

#ICYMI: Butts testifies, SQ chief suspended, more news 2019-03-06 20:30:35In Case You Missed It (#ICYMI) highlights some of today's top news.

Major highway closures planned for Turcot Interchange this 2019-02-21 18:26:52Sections of Highways 15 and 20 will be shut from Friday night to Monday morning

Georges St-Pierre was hoping for one more UFC 2019-02-21 18:21:15Wanted to fight unbeaten lightweight champion Khabib Nurmagomedov, but UFC president Dana White wasn't interested in setting it up.

TORONTO STAR | NEWS | CANADA

Canadian residency match still a ‘numbers game’: association 2019-03-06 23:18:13More Canadian medical grads to be prioritized over international grads this year, but there still aren’t enough spots for everyone.

NDP says proposed Saskatchewan trespass law changes are 2019-03-06 20:17:09An Opposition member is accusing the Saskatchewan government of playing wedge politics and excluding Indigenous voices with its proposed changes to th

Woman in Markdale, Ont., calls 911 by accident 2019-03-06 17:13:04The woman who made the call was wanted by police in Barrie, Ont. for an unspecified offence and they also found a man who was allegedly violating paro

Police in Woodstock, Ont., probe thefts including trailer 2019-03-06 17:04:26Police say they’re investigating two connected thefts, including the disappearance of a trailer filled with $20,000 worth of milk.

Ottawa to end funding to aid group that 2019-03-06 17:03:03Terre Sans Frontieres, whose head office is located just south of Montreal, has received about $200,000 of federal funding for homeopathy programs in

Military special forces changes recruiting plans amid shifting 2019-03-06 16:39:06The idea comes as Canada’s special-forces units are looking for people with different ethnic and cultural backgrounds and language skills.

Saskatchewan man gets absolute discharge for setting off 2019-03-06 15:40:24Brent Holland pleaded guilty to one count of mischief for shooting a Roman candle into some trees last August near the camp called Justice for Our Sto

Kingston is latest Canadian city to declare climate 2019-03-06 15:26:55The move comes after similar motions were passed in Vancouver and Halifax in January.

Manitoba health minister says system changes will improve 2019-03-06 15:19:05Health Minister Cameron Friesen says the administrative changes to the province’s healthcare system are not aimed at cutting costs, but there co

Clerk of Privy Council addresses critics over SNC-Lavalin 2019-03-06 14:59:00“I am disappointed to be accused of partisanship by people who have never met me,” Wernick told the House of Commons justice committee Wed

Woman apologizes for theft of Saskatchewan telethon funds, 2019-03-06 14:22:52The Kinsmen Foundation said in a statement that they will not be pursuing criminal charges against a woman who was reportedly drunk last Saturday when

Former PM aide, head of privy council may 2019-03-06 14:13:52Lawyer Marie Henein said that she has been fighting since October for records from the Prime Minister’s Office and the Privy Council Office.

blogTO

St. Patrick's Day parade route and road closures 2019-03-07 06:00:00The St. Patrick's Day Parade is back in Toronto for 2019. As always, expect a heavy dose of Irish cheer, epic floats, and road closures.The

10 things to do in Toronto today 2019-03-07 05:00:00Welcome to Thursday where events in Toronto today include the return of Travis Scott and a big art show at the Mod Club. It's bring-your-own-tissue f

A Toronto balayage salon wants to start serving 2019-03-06 23:25:38Step aside, Her Majesty’s Pleasure and Rod, Gun & Barbers, there’s another salon trying to sling booze in town.Album Hair at 639

TTC streetcar goes backwards after parked car blocks 2019-03-06 17:01:23There's a special place in H-E-double-hockey-sticks for people who leave their vehicles on streetcar tracks.Unlike buses, streetcars can't manoeuvre

Toronto Wolfpack rugby team devastated after someone steals 2019-03-06 16:46:06Tragedy has struck Toronto's rugby team, the Toronto Wolfpack. The city's championship-winning team took to social media yesterday to announce

15 big ticket concerts in Toronto this summer 2019-03-06 16:42:12Big ticket concerts hitting Toronto summer 2019 are jam-packed with superstar talent ready to set the city on fire. Jennifer Lopez is ready to ce

The Best Brownies in Toronto 2019-03-06 15:54:44The best brownies in Toronto take a bake sale classic to the next level. Not only are these brownies chocolatey, dense, moist and rich, some are even

The TTC just got a new accessible subway 2019-03-06 15:47:29The Toronto Transit Commission continues to make good on its promise of building a barrier-free subway system by 2025 with the unveiling of new a

Toronto neighbourhood doesn't want popular cafe to serve 2019-03-06 15:33:00One of downtown Toronto's coolest concept cafes, Fix Coffee + Bikes—a legitimate coffee bar that also happens to be a legitimate bicycle repair

35 essential breweries in Toronto 2019-03-06 14:09:29Breweries in Toronto now make styles of beer found around the world. You may only need to travel a couple blocks to sample a brand new IPA, sour or po

Ontario Place could get heritage protection 2019-03-06 14:03:18It may have the province in its name, but Ontario Place is Toronto's backyard—and residents of the city want a say in what happe

Documentary about Toronto serial killer Bruce McArthur to 2019-03-06 13:04:56Bruce McArthur's crimes gripped the nation when it surfaced that he had murdered eight men in Toronto's Church-Wellesley Village. McArthur


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.