• Follow us


Mike Duffy appeals ruling blocking him from suing Senate for suspension | CBC News

Sen. Mike Duffy is asking Ontario's Court of Appeal to overturn a decision blocking him from suing the Senate for millions of dollars over his dramatic and protracted suspension without pay more than five years ago.

Last month, Ontario Court Justice Sally Gomery ruled the Senate's decision to suspend Duffy is protected by parliamentary privilege — a centuries-old right designed to protect legislators from having to answer to judges for doing their jobs — meaning Duffy can't take the Senate to court over its actions.

The appeal Duffy's lawyers filed Thursday says the ruling erred in law on a number of fronts by extending the scope of that privilege, essentially equating privilege with immunity.

Duffy is asking the appeal court to set aside Gomery's ruling and order the Senate to cover his legal costs.

The decision to appeal is part of the P.E.I. senator's efforts to wrestle compensation from the Senate for the two years he was without pay, and also to send a statement to senators that privilege doesn't put them above the law, Duffy's lawyer said.

"The damages that were suffered by Sen. Duffy were as a result of the actions, in large part, because of the Senate," Lawrence Greenspon said in an interview.

"They basically acted, we say, in such a way that they should be subject to civil action and the immunity that they've claimed under this privilege is far too broad and, we say, needs to be judicially considered."

'Potentially illegal'

Duffy is seeking $7.8 million in damages from the Senate, RCMP and federal government in the wake of the high-profile investigation of his expense claims, which culminated in his acquittal on 31 criminal charges in 2016.

His claim against the Senate alleges "an unprecedented abuse of power" when a majority of senators voted to suspend him without pay in November 2013, before any criminal charges had been filed.

Charges arrived in July 2014, when the RCMP filed 31 counts of fraud, breach of trust and bribery against him.

In April 2016, Ontario Court Justice Charles Vaillancourt dismissed all the criminal charges in a lengthy and dramatic ruling that said Duffy was forced to take a $90,000 payment from Nigel Wright, Stephen Harper's then chief of staff, to pay off his politically problematic housing expenses, even though Duffy contended he had done nothing wrong.

Duffy's appeal argues the ruling shows his Senate suspension was "egregious, politically motivated, and potentially illegal" and shouldn't be protected by parliamentary privilege.

"To now turn around and say, whatever we did is covered by privilege, just I think is fundamentally wrong," Greenspon said. "You can't have any individual, or group, or government, or arm of government above the law."

The Senate said parliamentary privilege gives it the right to "control its own proceedings," including "disciplinary authority over its members, free from outside interference."

Gomery, in her ruling, said allowing a court to review the Senate's decisions on Duffy would damage the upper chamber's ability to function as an independent legislative body.

Michel Bedard, the Senate's parliamentary counsel, said in a statement, that Gomery's ruling "properly supports the Senate's position that all of its actions respecting Senator Duffy's suspension were protected by parliamentary privilege."

Duffy's lawsuit will be put on hold until the appeal is settled with a hearing likely later this year.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

: Politics

‘I am not a racist,’ says ousted Liberal 2019-01-17 19:11:25"Recently I have been labelled as a racist, which really, really makes me hurt," Wang, still wearing a Liberal Party pin, told reporters. "I a

Donald Trump cancels U.S. delegation to World Economic 2019-01-17 18:57:36The cancellation announcement comes just days after the White House announced the members of the delegation it intended to send to Davos, led by 

Chinese ambassador threatens ‘repercussions’ on Canada if Huawei 2019-01-17 16:03:43Chinese ambassador Lu Shaye also says Canada's arrest of a Huawei Technologies executive was an act of "backstabbing" by a friend.

Trump stalls Nancy Pelosi’s international trip as feud 2019-01-17 14:43:37It was not immediately clear what trip Trump was referring to. Lawmakers often do not publicize foreign trips before they occur for security reasons.

Thousands more migrant families likely split up than 2019-01-17 13:49:32A report found that family separations were occurring before the spring of last year, when the administration announced its “zero tolerance&rdqu

Former Liberal byelection candidate Karen Wang wants party 2019-01-17 13:24:17A day after stepping down as the Liberal candidate in Burnaby South, Karen Wang says she wants the party to bring her back into the fold.

Brewery sues U.S. government over sud-sidelining shutdown 2019-01-17 13:10:00The problem for thousands of craft breweries is that labels have to be approved by a government agency before new beers can be packaged and sold.

‘Prince of Pot’ Marc Emery denies allegations of 2019-01-17 12:45:32Marc Emery, the prominent marijuana advocate often described as the 'Prince of Pot,' is facing allegations of inappropriate sexual behaviour, groomi

StatCan delays trade data release due to U.S. 2019-01-17 11:49:48The agency says it uses U.S. import data to measure Canadian exports to the United States.

Former PQ minister Yves-François Blanchet named Bloc Québécois 2019-01-17 11:31:56He previously worked in the music world, where he managed Quebec singer Éric Lapointe.

‘ORRR-DUHH’: U.K. Parliament speaker seeks to calm debate 2019-01-16 18:05:31The speaker of the House of Commons is usually taken for granted, except for those rare moments when Britain is having a legislative meltdown and Parl

RCMP civilian advisory board to tackle bullying, harassment 2019-01-16 16:58:45Ralph Goodale claimed the new management advisory board will help modernize the way the RCMP functions.

CBC | Politics News

1 day after resigning, Karen Wang says she 2019-01-17 13:08:36Karen Wang, who resigned as the Liberal candidate in Burnaby South over comments she made about NDP rival Jagmeet Singh on social media, now says she

Ottawa, Quebec to discuss Legault's plan for immigration 2019-01-17 13:03:58Federal and Quebec officials will meet in two weeks to hammer out an immigration plan for the province that Premier François Legault says must

Top Russian news host takes aim at Ukrainian 2019-01-17 10:00:03Dmitry Kiselyov's Sunday-night TV program is one of the most influential sources of news in Russia. And last weekend, the Kremlin-friendly broadcaste

Family says Canadian found dead in Burkina Faso 2019-01-17 08:21:07A Canadian kidnapped in Burkina Faso has been found dead, says his family, two days after he was abducted by gunmen.

Defence chief admits slower-than-expected growth in female representation 2019-01-17 07:43:31Canada's top military officer admits there has been slower progress than expected to get more women into the Canadian Forces.

With spotlight back on Saudi women's rights, Loujain 2019-01-17 07:00:00As Rahaf Mohammed al-Qunun, the 18-year-old who burst into the public eye by fleeing Saudi Arabia, settles into what she hopes will be a normal life i

Yves-François Blanchet becomes Bloc Québécois leader 2019-01-17 05:49:54Blanchet succeeds Martine Ouellet, who resigned in June of last year following a split in the party and the departure of seven Bloc MPs.

Veterans Affairs $165M gaffe headed to Federal Court 2019-01-17 04:00:34A proposed class-action lawsuit has been filed against the federal government over the $165-million accounting blunder at Veterans Affairs Canada, CBC

Here's how a refugee claim gets fast tracked 2019-01-17 04:00:00The case of Saudi teen Rahaf Mohammed who was granted asylum in Canada after a fleeing her allegedly abusive family is shining a spotlight on a rarely

Trudeau's refreshed cabinet meets in Quebec amid economic 2019-01-17 04:00:00Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his revamped cabinet meet in Sherbrooke, Que., the start of a three-day retreat to deal with pressing economic, envi

Canadians held in China face up to 4 2019-01-16 23:58:58Two Canadian men detained in China face up to four hours of questioning each day and have no access to a lawyer, according to Canada's top diplomat i

Jagmeet Singh vows he'll lead NDP into 2019 2019-01-16 21:31:19NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh vows he will lead the NDP into the 2019 federal election as he heads into next month's crucial byelection for the vacant Bur

Politique canadienne

Justin Trudeau accueilli par des manifestants à Sherbrooke 2019-01-16 15:09:00Des dizaines de fonctionnaires fédéraux frustrés attendaient Justin Trudeau de pied ferme à Sherbrooke, mercredi, pour d&e

La candidate libérale contre Jagmeet Singh se retire 2019-01-16 14:40:00La candidate libérale qui devait affronter en février le chef néo-démocrate fédéral dans une élection

Troisième rencontre Trudeau-Legault en quatre mois 2019-01-16 00:00:00Alors qu'il a perdu certains de ses alliés provinciaux les plus fidèles au cours de la dernière année, notamment en Ontar

Le BST déplore les faibles normes de sécurité 2019-01-15 12:05:00La présidente du Bureau de la sécurité des transports déplore que le gouvernement fédéral n'ait pas encore

Visite reportée de Mélanie Joly en Chine: toujours 2019-01-15 09:58:00Le froid diplomatique entre le Canada et la Chine est tel qu'il a entraîné le report d'une visite en sol chinois de la ministre du Tour

La tension monte d'un cran entre Pékin et 2019-01-15 09:34:00La condamnation à mort en Chine d'un ressortissant canadien de 36 ans accusé de trafic de drogue a encore fait monter d'un cran l

Conflit diplomatique avec la Chine: Trudeau fait le 2019-01-15 07:57:00Justin Trudeau tente d'obtenir le maximum d'appuis à l'international dans le conflit diplomatique qui oppose le Canada à la Chine sur

Jeune saoudienne réfugiée au Canada: un cas exceptionnel 2019-01-14 18:50:00Le cas d'une adolescente saoudienne dont la fuite de l'emprise d'une famille prétendument violente a attiré l'attention internationa

Trudeau dénonce la condamnation à mort d'un Canadien 2019-01-14 07:47:00Le premier ministre du Canada, Justin Trudeau, s'est inquiété lundi de la décision de la Chine de condamner «arbitrairemen

Scheer propose un sommet national sur l'énergie 2019-01-14 05:00:00Alors que les tensions régionales liées aux projets de développement des ressources naturelles sont de plus en plus vives, le che

Montréal obtient un quatrième ministre dans le cabinet de 2019-01-13 08:18:00La région de Montréal obtient un nouveau représentant à la table du cabinet de Justin Trudeau : le déput&

Vidéo partisane: les libéraux rembourseront les Communes 2019-01-09 21:18:00Les libéraux rembourseront 500 dollars à la Chambre des communes pour avoir utilisé le bureau parlementaire du premier minis

Breitbart News

Mike Pence Surprises March for Life Crowd, Introduces 2019-01-18 14:04:31Vice President Mike Pence surprised the massive March for Life crowd in Washington, DC, Friday, supporting life and introducing a message from Preside

House Republicans Told Not to Promote March for 2019-01-18 13:46:20Friday, House Republican communication staffers were told not to use official U.S. House of Representatives accounts to promote the pro-life March for

Jesse Jackson Calls Trump's Fast Food Meal for 2019-01-18 13:41:42Jesse Jackson now claims he was "offended" by the fast food meal that President Trump arranged for the Clemson Tigers White House visit.

State Media: China Has World's 'Fastest Human Rights 2019-01-18 13:36:58China's ambassador to South Africa, Lin Songtian, published an opinion column in the official Communist Party newspaper People's Dail

Left-Wing Nation Author Talks to Breitbart: Russia Hysteria 2019-01-18 13:22:43Stephen Cohen said the "Russiagate fiction" may prevent Donald Trump from negotiating peaceful resolutions to conflicts with Russia.

Donald Trump Addresses March for Life: Vows to 2019-01-18 12:58:58"Today I have signed a letter to Congress to make clear that if they send any legislation to my desk that weakens the protection of human life, I wil

China Exploits U.S. Waivers for $3 Billion Oil 2019-01-18 12:18:34China is taking advantage of waivers from Iran sanctions granted by the United States to pitch a $3 billion oil field development to Iran, even as Eur

Nolte: Nine Reasons to Be Skeptical of BuzzFeed's 2019-01-18 12:12:04The media's latest anti-Trump "bombshell" … … … …  oh, sorry, I nodded off for a moment there -- was dropped Thurs

Democrat Floats Canceling Super Bowl: 'Would Definitely Lead 2019-01-18 11:38:34Democrats are floating canceling the Super Bowl in order to push to end what is now the longest government shutdown in history, according to a report

Facebook Refuses Ads for 'Roe v. Wade' Film 2019-01-18 11:37:57Social media giant Facebook has allegedly refused to allow the upcoming Roe v. Wade film to run advertisements on its platform under the new "is

Nancy Pelosi Accuses WH of Leaking Afghanistan Commercial 2019-01-18 11:31:04House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) on Friday canceled a visit to Afghanistan, accusing the White House of leaking commercial travel plans to the war zo

CNN's Mudd: AG Nominee Barr 'Is Going to 2019-01-18 11:18:47CNN analyst and former CIA official Philip Mudd on Friday predicted that if Attorney General nominee William Barr becomes the leader of the Depar

Politics – Macleans.ca

Ford government eliminates free tuition for low-income students 2019-01-17 12:34:30The province is cutting fees but says the OSAP grants had become unsustainable and it was time to refocus The post Ford government eliminates free tui

Racial vote pandering sinks Liberal candidate in Burnaby 2019-01-17 07:00:52Politics Insider for January 17: Turmoil in Burnaby-South byelection and America calls out China over arrests and death sentence, as China temporarily

It’s Day 26 of the shutdown and U.S. 2019-01-16 18:05:14Republicans and Dems both claim to sympathize, but the bureaucrats aren't hungry enough for either side to stand down The post It’s Day 26 of t

Mayday! Mayday! Mayday! Theresa May faces no confidence 2019-01-16 07:00:58Politics Insider for January 16: Svend Robinson seeks end to political purgatory, the war of the travel advisories, and Theresa May's government face

Indigenous leaders are less than thrilled with Trudeau’s 2019-01-15 16:47:12Jane Philpott won respect as Indigenous services minister. Can Seamus O'Regan—a pal of the PM who has yet to distinguish himself in cabinet&mda

The real world effects of Donald Trump’s cluelessness 2019-01-15 13:42:06Adnan R. Khan: If the president's wildly uninformed decision about Syria is the new norm for U.S. foreign policy, the world is in for a rough ride T

Ottawa warns: travel to China at your own 2019-01-15 07:00:27Politics Insider for January 15: Trudeau's cabinet shuffle leaves some observers puzzled, China sentences a Canadian to death, and the real irony in

In the Trudeau government, what’s a cabinet shuffle 2019-01-14 16:56:06Paul Wells: Like the shuffle before it, today's won't change anything about a government that's chronically stage-managed by a tiny cadre of staffe

Jody Wilson-Raybould on her exit as justice minister 2019-01-14 13:26:34The newly sworn-in minister of veterans affairs spoke to reporters about why her new job isn't a demotion—and why she's 'incredibly proud' o

Trudeau on the cabinet shuffle, including today’s big 2019-01-14 12:53:58On a day of surprising new postings—including an unexpected new justice minister—here's what the PM had to say to reporters in Ottawa The

Someone get Jagmeet Singh a newspaper subscription 2019-01-14 07:00:59Politics Insider for January 14: Trudeau shuffles his cabinet, Canadians are suddenly anxious about the state of the economy and Singh needs to brush

In an election year, Canadians are suddenly very 2019-01-13 07:00:15More than half of Canadians feel the economy is in recession (it's not) as the optimism of a year ago fades, according to Pollara's annual economy s

CTVNews.ca - Politics -

Person considered 'national security concern' gets permanent residency 2019-01-16 18:36:06A person considered a "national security concern" was granted permanent residency in Canada in error, a move the federal public safety minister has

Global trade disruptions don't dampen Morneau's optimism about 2019-01-16 18:27:46Finance Minister Bill Morneau is offering a rosy assessment of Canada's economy in an election year, despite upheavals around the world that could di

Minister meets with committee to develop national approach 2019-01-16 18:05:18The minister for women and gender equality says an advisory committee is developing a national framework to hold universities and colleges responsible

Liberal candidate in Burnaby South steps down, apologizes 2019-01-16 13:10:00The federal Liberal candidate running in the Burnaby South byelection against NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh has stepped aside, and apologized for comments

U.S. backs Canada as China questions motivations in 2019-01-16 11:42:00The United States has backed Canada’s claim that the death sentence awarded to Robert Schellenberg is “politically motivated” as Chi

Lametti appointment raises hope for less restrictive assisted 2019-01-16 04:54:05The appointment of David Lametti as Canada's new justice minister has given new hope to those who believe the Trudeau government's law on medically

New advisory board to help RCMP modernize amid 2019-01-15 23:16:00The federal government is creating an external board of civilian advisers to help the RCMP modernize after years of grappling with internal bullying a

Trudeau fields range of questions on immigration and 2019-01-15 22:53:00Prime Minister Justin Trudeau on Tuesday slammed what he called the dictatorship of Venezuela as he tackled audience questions ranging from Canada's

Global pressure might help Canadian sentenced to death 2019-01-15 20:39:00Former Canadian ambassador to China Guy Saint-Jacques says gathering more international support could be an effective strategy in saving the life of a

Trudeau to move fewest possible ministers in shuffle: 2019-01-11 19:05:42Monday's cabinet shuffle is expected to be very small, involving the fewest possible number of changes needed to fill the void left by veteran Nova S

Ottawa, Saskatchewan reach equivalency agreement to phase out 2019-01-11 16:20:40Ottawa and Saskatchewan have reached an equivalency agreement which would see the province's coal fleets mostly phased out by 2030.

Federal watchdog says victims rights regime falling short 2019-01-11 14:43:41The new federal watchdog for victims of crime says rules meant to give victims and their families louder voices in the justice system have fallen shor

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.