• Follow us


Canadians say country split between ordinary folks and elites. But what is an elite? | CBC News

This story is part of a series, called On Guard for Me: The Uneasy Canadian, digging into the results of a CBC News-commissioned online poll of 4,500 Canadians ahead of the October federal election.

Between bites of his free hamburger at last Saturday's Ford Fest celebration north of Toronto — an annual barbecue hosted by the family of Ontario Premier Doug Ford — 65-year-old Tony Laino provided a concise answer when asked who he considers the "elites" of society.

"Those that think they're better than me," he said. "Because I don't espouse their beliefs."

That's one definition, anyway.

The label "elites" seems to get flung around the political arena constantly these days. It's become one of the dirty words of politics.

It's also a term that resonates with many Canadians, particularly in an era when political populism seems to be gaining ground. A new CBC poll suggests nearly 80 per cent of Canadians either strongly or somewhat agree with the statement: "My country is divided between ordinary people and elites."

But what exactly does it mean? And why has it gained such traction as a political insult?

Tony Laino, a retired information management consultant, says elites can be defined as 'those that think they're better' than him. (Albert Leung/CBC)

"It's become such an elastic term, it's become useless as a classification," said Sean Speer, a sessional instructor and senior fellow in public policy at the University of Toronto's Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy.

As history professor Beverly Gage noted in a 2017 New York Times column, the word is still seen in a positive light when used as an adjective — an elite athlete, for example. But it takes on a nefarious meaning when used as a noun and "has become one of the nastiest epithets in American politics."

It's been used frequently by U.S. President Donald Trump, but it's also been a rallying cry for many Canadian politicians, including Ford and former prime minister Stephen Harper, who would often take shots at the "liberal elite."

Historically, the term "elite" seemed to have a connection to the rich. Politicians of all stripes have often tried to show off their working-class bona fides, regardless of their personal wealth.

In his initial foray onto the political stage, former prime minister Brian Mulroney was branded as the "Boy from Baie Comeau," Que., downplaying his role as president of the Iron Ore Company of Canada, said Tim Powers, vice-chairman of Summa Strategies, who served as the director of policy and research for the Progressive Conservative Party of Canada.

Mulroney's former Liberal rival, Jean Chrétien, who amassed great wealth in the private sector and would also go on to become prime minister, was promoted as the "little guy from Shawinigan."

"So it's always been there," Powers said. "I think the right really co-opted it with more vigour under Stephen Harper."

'We want to look average'

Powers said by 2006, when the Conservatives under Harper were trying to unseat Prime Minister Paul Martin, the party had done a lot of research looking at how people identified themselves. 

In an appeal to the middle class, he said, the Conservatives ran a series of what can be described as low-budget commercials.

"The whole plot point of those commercials, as I recall hearing the rationale behind the advertising, was, 'We want to look average. So, not elite. We want to contrast ourselves to Paul Martin, the shipping magnate."

The term, or concept anyway, would continue to be used to score political points. Another of Harper's Liberal opponents, Michael Ignatieff, was portrayed as an out-of-touch elitist in the 2011 federal election. 

Current Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has had to deflect barbs from the Tories about being a "trust fund baby." 

"It's been pretty commonplace because most people would prefer to self-identify as being with the 'us' as opposed to the 'them,' because the 'them' are the elites and the people who get an advantage," Powers said.

He suspects the increased potency of going against the so-called elite in recent years comes from the reaction of people who have "drank the populist elixir" for their concerns about globalism, economic inequality, and being left out of jobs and opportunity.

"I think it's become more and more politically valuable to talk about elitism," he said, "because it also now means you recognize there is an advantage afforded to elites that wasn't there before."

The same CBC poll suggests 52 per cent of Canadians either strongly or somewhat agree with the statement: "The government doesn't do anything for me."

During the 2011 federal election, the Conservatives tried to portray Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff as an out-of-touch elitist. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

Speer, who was the research assistant on Harper's book Right Here, Right Now: Politics and Leadership in the Age of Disruption, suggested one segment of the population feels particularly ignored by the political system — people without a post-secondary education.

And populist politicians like Trump have been able to tap into their frustrations and fuel the divide, he said.

Nothing to do with money

But Speer believes the results of the CBC survey may reflect a confusion about what's happening in this country.

"I think people would be shocked to discover where they fit in the broader Canadian society," he said. "A significant number of them, based on income status, would be quote, unquote elite."

However, that's where the subjectivity of the term comes into play. Would "elite" not apply to the same wealthy politicians like Ford and Trump who use it to disparage their opponents? 

Laino, the Ford Fest attendee and a retired information management consultant, says no. It doesn't have to do with money.

"Donald Trump is a super wealthy guy and he's not an elite by any means," he said. "It's attitude."

Ford made similar comments when asked to define the term while appearing on CBC's Metro Morning in March 2018. 

WATCH| Doug Ford provides his definition of the "elite"

Newly elected Ontario Progressive Conservative leader Doug Ford speaks with Metro Morning guest host David Common. 9:07

"People that look down on the common folk, the people that think they're smarter than other people ... they just think they're better, they're smarter, and they can tell the common folk how to live their lives," he said. "And they drink their little bottle or glass of champagne with their pinky up in the air. That's what an elite is."

Elitism has nothing to do with money, Ford said. "Half of them don't have two pennies to rub together. They think they're something that they aren't."

But Amanda Galbraith, a principal with the public strategy and communications firm Navigtor Ltd., said the word may actually be losing some of its political punch.

"I do think it's kind of reached the point now where it is sort of white noise, because who defines elites? Everybody's using the term."

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

: Politics

As Canada-China relations worsen, a Trudeau cabinet minister 2019-07-03 17:56:05The Trudeau Liberals are defending a cabinet minister's business promotion trip to China while China has two Canadians -- including a business operat

Trump administration eyeing new properties to house unaccompanied 2019-07-03 16:48:20Existing migrant detention facilities, especially those housing minors, have become a flashpoint in the 2020 presidential race.

‘We need to get a handle on the 2019-07-03 16:43:52"There seems to be numbers flying all over the place from the experts to other organizations. So we need to get a handle on the exact count," the pr

Here’s why critics call Trump’s 4th of July 2019-07-03 16:39:42"There's also this sense of, 'is this really want our money to go?'" says one former American diplomat.

Trump raised Canadian detainees with China in ‘clear 2019-07-03 15:53:47Canadian officials have received confirmation that U.S. President Donald Trump raised the matter, a government source says.

After China meat ban, Bibeau says ‘too early’ 2019-07-03 15:34:24"We are still at the early stage of this issue," said Agriculture Minister Marie-Claude Bibeau.

Nuclear arms treaty: How the U.S. and Russia 2019-07-03 15:31:46Since the Cold War, the INF Treaty has been a pivotal part of arms control and global security. Now, both the U.S. and Russia say they're out.

What Donald Trump is planning for 4th of 2019-07-03 14:55:54The president has been tweeting about the plans, and has promised "a show of a lifetime."

Trump suggests U.S. should start manipulating the dollar 2019-07-03 12:50:28On Wednesday, Trump accused China and Europe of playing a “big currency manipulation game.”

China scolds Canada for ‘mustering so-called allies’ on 2019-07-03 10:55:54A Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson said on Wednesday that "Canada knows exactly what the crux of the problem is."

As Russia broadens influence, here’s why Canada remains 2019-07-02 18:05:31"Russia's actions are not only a threat to Ukraine but to international law," Trudeau said.

‘The straw that broke the camel’s back’: Halifax 2019-07-02 17:34:10Michael de Adder, who has been drawing editorial cartoons for 20 years, was let go from N.B. newspapers after releasing a controversial depiction of D

CBC | Politics News

Ukraine's comedian-turned-president makes North American debut in Toronto 2019-07-02 07:32:52Ukraine's new president makes his North American debut in Toronto later today — more than a month before he is to visit the United States &mdas

Dominic LeBlanc's family, friends and neighbour win 5 2019-07-02 05:00:00Federal Liberals have been promising to appoint the "most meritorious jurists" to judicial vacancies, but most candidates winning judicial appointme

Indigenous and first-time voters split, new Canadians still 2019-07-02 04:00:00Liberal support has dropped among Indigenous voters and new Canadians since 2015, while they face stiff competition from the NDP among first-time vote

Former Thunder Bay-Rainy River MP John Rafferty dies 2019-07-01 15:27:46Former New Democrat MP John Rafferty, who represented the Thunder Bay-Rainy River riding on Parliament Hill for two terms, has died.

U.S. worried about condition of Canadian-American charged with 2019-07-01 14:00:24The condition of a Canadian-American man held on spying charges in Russia has worsened, according to the U.S. Embassy in Moscow.

First Nation grand chief on hunger strike over 2019-07-01 12:55:35The grand chief of the Algonquin Anishinabeg Nation Tribal Council began a hunger strike Monday at midnight, protesting a lack of significant con

Trudeau warns against amplifying fears as Canada celebrates 2019-07-01 05:50:28Prime Minister Justin Trudeau warned against anyone trying to "amplify" Canadians' fears as he arrived on Parliament Hill in Ottawa for Canada Day

Canadians say country split between ordinary folks and 2019-07-01 04:00:00The term 'elite' has increasingly become one of the dirty words of politics. But why has it gained such traction as a political insult? And what&nbs

Two-thirds of Indigenous people don't feel respected in 2019-07-01 04:00:00Two-thirds of Indigenous people surveyed feel that the federal government does not respect their community and identity. It's one of the many finding

Early release of party platforms a sign of 2019-06-30 16:00:00In this week’s Canada Votes newsletter: Why parties are pushing their platforms out early. Also: Which parties are losing supporters from 2015 -

Stephen Harper offers help on Brexit, but staying 2019-06-30 14:06:03Former Canadian prime minister Stephen Harper says he's willing to help the next British prime minister negotiate a divorce deal with the European Un

Trump-Xi trade talks at the G20: A look 2019-06-30 08:50:19Amid promises made at the close of the G20 summit that U.S.-China trade tensions can be healed, it remains to be seen whether there is a mismatch of e

Breitbart News

Democrat Congressman Joins Nike Boycott Over Betsy Ross 2019-07-03 19:39:21Rep. Dan Lipinski (D-IL) joined the burgeoning backlash against Nike on Tuesday over the shoemaker's decision to pull their America-themed 4th of Jul

Beto O'Rourke: White Nationalists Have 'Appropriated' the Betsy 2019-07-03 19:27:10Presidential candidate Beto O'Rourke (D) said Wednesday that he respects Nike's decision to pull its Betsy Ross flag sneakers and added that white n

Gun Maker Responds to Nike with AR-15 Parts 2019-07-03 19:03:34Palmetto State Armory responded to Nike's decision to pull its Betsy Ross Flag shoes by releasing gun parts with the flag etched on them.

Kamala Harris: 'We Have a Predator in the 2019-07-03 18:56:38Wednesday on CNN’s “The Lead,” host Jake Tapper played a clip of 2020 hopeful Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA) calling President Donald Tru

July 4: Feds Warn of Possible Terror Attacks 2019-07-03 18:53:43Federal authorities, in the days leading to Independence Day, warned of potential, not specific, attacks against revelers at the hands of “homeg

Islamic Teacher Who Sent Porn to 15-Year-Old Gets 2019-07-03 18:41:27An Islamic teacher who taught at a mosque in Washington, DC, has been sentenced to ten years in prison for sending pornographic videos and committing

Tom Holland Says Marvel Films Need 'Gay Spider-Man' 2019-07-03 18:41:16Tom Holland, who plays Peter Parker in Marvel's latest superhero movie, Spider-Man: Far from Home, says it is time for a "gay Spider-

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Unveils 4-Point Immigration Plan (Point #2: 2019-07-03 18:23:40Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) has released a four-point immigration plan for dealing with the crisis at the U.S.-Mexico border.

Pollak: Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Deliberately Distorted What She Saw 2019-07-03 18:05:50Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is a master at sensationalizing politics. But she is not a credible witness.

Rami Malek Demanded His James Bond Movie Villain 2019-07-03 18:05:27Hollywood star Rami Malek says he told the director of the next James Bond movie that he would not join the cast if the next villain was a terrorist d

Marianne Williamson Calls Trump's July 4th Event 'Heartbreaking,' 2019-07-03 17:48:57Williamson called President Trump's July 4th tribute to the military "heartbreaking" and "repugnant" in a tweet on Wednesday.

Iowa Poll: Warren and Harris Surging, Biden Loses 2019-07-03 17:29:24Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Sen. Kamala Harris (D-CA) have surged past former Vice President Joe Biden in Iowa after the first Democrat president

Politics – Macleans.ca

A new 338Canada/Maclean’s projection: Battleground Ontario is tightening 2019-06-30 16:06:23Philippe J. Fournier: The Conservative lead holds, but with rising fortunes in Ontario the Liberals' seat projection improves significantly The post

The meme-ification of Canadian politics 2019-06-28 12:12:40Matt Gurney: Just when it seemed our political discourse could not get worse, the parties have unleashed a new form of superficial messaging The post

Trudeau should try walking the walk on climate 2019-06-28 07:34:08Andrew MacDougall: Instead of jetting off to the G20 to be a fly on the wall in the Trump-Xi show, the PM could have made a real statement at home The

Ottawa and provinces pause carbon tax fight to 2019-06-28 07:00:11Politics Insider for July 28: Ford friends in high places, self-government agreements for Metis and China jets buzz Canadian ship The post Ottawa and

The Democrats in Miami, or half of them 2019-06-27 14:05:19Paul Wells: The field seeking to take on Donald Trump is overcrowded. The first debate on Wednesday made clear that's not such a bad thing. The post

What to watch for as Trudeau heads to 2019-06-27 07:00:26Politics Insider for June 27: Pork probe launched, the Legion boots bigots and the women running for Scheer The post What to watch for as Trudeau head

The missing outrage from Canada’s political leaders on 2019-06-26 17:51:29Anne Kingston: Maclean's contacted the Canadian government and political party leaders to request statements on the U.S. incarceration of children. A

Another swine mess we’ve gotten into with China 2019-06-26 07:00:34Politics Insider for June 26: Doug Ford nepotism scandal worsens, China bans Canadian meat and Kim Campbell disses Scheer climate plan The post Anothe

The compassion revolution hits Istanbul 2019-06-25 16:39:58Adnan R. Khan: The politics of division lost badly in Turkey's biggest city, hinting at a new way forward: "Everything will be beautiful" The post

The path to a Tory win: Quebec 2019-06-25 11:44:54Philippe J. Fournier: Are the Conservatives quietly making a breakthrough in Quebec? New polls show a glimpse of progress—and a big challenge. T

Whose side is Jean Chrétien on? 2019-06-25 11:25:42Terry Glavin: As China wages a political attack on Canada, the former PM's interventions give cover to Beijing—and to Meng Wanzhou's lawyers T

Everyone in Canada’s doing it 2019-06-25 07:00:35Politics Insider for June 25: A Ford fix, Meng's lawyers say 'let it go' and the Raptors not Washington-bound The post Everyone in Canada’s d

CTVNews.ca - Politics -

Algonquin Nation guaranteed space in Indigenous centre as 2019-07-03 13:29:04The Algonquin Nation will be guaranteed a space in a major Indigenous centre in Ottawa after an agreement with the federal government ended a grand ch

Governor General won't move into Rideau Hall until 2019-07-03 12:46:58The Governor General will not move into her official residence in Ottawa this summer and there is no date for when she might.

Coleman set for cross-examination today after judge clears 2019-07-03 11:26:50The sexual-assault trial of former Afghanistan hostage Joshua Boyle will proceed today after the judge decided evidence given earlier in the trial is

Parties' financial returns show Tories topped Liberals in 2019-07-03 11:06:00Newly released federal party financial figures show the Conservatives entered this election year having outpaced the Liberals in fundraising by more t

Indigenous-led group ready to bid on majority stake 2019-07-03 10:07:00An Indigenous-led group says that it will be ready to submit a bid for a majority stake in the Trans Mountain pipeline and the expansion project as ea

China warns 'naive' Canada not to count on 2019-07-03 02:35:00China warned Canada not to be 'naive' and believe that U.S. pressure could help resolve thorny issues plaguing relations between Ottawa and Beijing.

Senate ethics officer asks upper chamber to be 2019-07-02 16:55:59The Senate's ethics watchdog is telling the upper chamber to provide him documents more quickly to speed up investigations and strengthen his indepen

On Hold: Veterans Affairs struggling to answer former 2019-07-02 14:57:00New figures show many veterans have had a hard time getting anyone to pick up when they call Veterans Affairs Canada's toll-free line for information

New Supreme Court ruling on sexual-history evidence delays 2019-07-02 11:18:00The sexual-assault trial of former Afghanistan hostage Joshua Boyle is held up this morning while lawyers consider how a new Supreme Court ruling affe

Corruption in Ukraine hurts reform, U.S. envoy says 2019-07-02 04:13:00Ukraine's weak judicial system is hurting the country's prospects for reform, which is the only way it will ultimately overcome Russia's ongoing ag

Ukraine's comedian-turned-president makes North American debut in Toronto 2019-07-02 04:13:00Ukraine's new president makes his North American debut in Toronto later today -- more than a month before he is to visit the United States -- and the

Early electioneering? Where the party leaders are visiting 2019-07-01 15:13:54On the last Canada Day before the next election, the main federal party leaders are making campaign-style stops, and where they are visiting may offer

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.