• Follow us


Officials take look at zones for EI rules, hoping to avoid political pitfalls | CBC News

A federal department is reconsidering the boundaries that determine how workers in different areas qualify for employment insurance.

Changes to the 64 EI regions, as they're known, would send political ripples through the country as some workers benefit while others find themselves with tougher hurdles to clear to get benefits.

Documents obtained by The Canadian Press under the access-to-information law show how fraught the process can be, noting complaints that haven't subsided after the last change five years ago.

Employment and Social Development Canada is working on a fast-tracked review of the current boundaries that help decide the number of hours workers need to put in to qualify for EI benefits and how much they can receive depending on where they live.

System based on where you live, not where jobs are

In general, the idea is to make benefits more generous in parts of the country where it's harder to get work, though a quirk of the system is that it's based on residency, not where jobs are. Two people who get laid off from the same company at the same time could have different benefit entitlements because they live on opposite sides of an EI-region boundary.

How the department determines where to draw the lines separating EI zones will be different from previous reviews, with the internal documents detailing a plan to emphasize some factors over others, including putting less reliance on unemployment rates.

Jean-Yves Duclos is Minister of Families, Children and Social Development and oversees the Employment Insurance system. (The Canadian Press/Sean Kilpatrick)

If all goes according to plan, the department anticipates making recommendations by September 2020 — one year after this fall's federal election.

"Changes in boundaries need to be made in a very thoughtful manner because any change in boundaries will involve losers and winners," Social Development Minister Jean-Yves Duclos, who oversees the EI system, said in a recent interview.

Duclos said the objective needs to be making the EI system better and not about picking "who wins and who loses. That would be a political objective."

Some residents of Alberta, P.E.I. have complained

Where the lines go can make a big difference in local politics. Alberta has zones centred on Edmonton and Calgary that include some suburban and surrounding rural areas but not others. After oil prices crashed, the Edmonton region was at first excluded from a 2016 boost to EI benefits, leading to complaints from people who worked in the oilpatch but had permanent addresses in the city.

The 2014 review split P.E.I. into two EI zones with boundary lines drawn in a way that benefited the lone Conservative riding in the province: The entirety of the riding of Egmont, covering the western end of the Island, fell into an EI zone where workers needed fewer hours of work to qualify for benefits.

Tory cabinet minister Gail Shea nevertheless fell to a Liberal challenger the next year. Changing the boundaries so P.E.I. is again one region — as the Liberals once pledged to do — could be problematic for rookie Liberal MP Bobby Morrissey, who holds the Egmont seat, where residents would suddenly lose their advantage.

"It's extremely unfair, but the dilemma — and I can understand this from my colleague Bobby Morrissey's point of view — is if you go to one system, then there will be a loss to P.E.I.," said Wayne Easter, a long-time Island Liberal MP. His riding of Malpeque is partly in the EI zone with more generous benefits, partly in the zone centred on Charlottetown that has less generous benefits.

Wayne Easter is a Liberal MP for Malpeque on Prince Edward Island. (Steve Bruce/CBC)

Any time he goes to an event, people in his own party like to point out the Liberals committed to reverse the changes and tell him that if "it isn't changed, I'm not going to be able to support you."

Federal officials, Easter said, must ensure there is a "better understanding of how and why" any changes are made.

No requirement to actually make changes

The last two-year review wrapped in 2018 without any changes, and provided a set of lessons the department plans to apply this time around. A presentation to the department's top official noted the unemployment rate should be considered separately from other factors when deciding the borders of an EI region.

The documents say that other labour-market factors — such as the kinds of industries, local demographics and the number of seasonal jobs — would provide a better understanding of the differences between neighbouring regions with similar unemployment rates.

Officials discussed using unemployment rates in the review by looking at long-term trends rather than at a single point in time.

The department said the current review started in October 2018, but there is no requirement at the end for the Canada Employment Insurance Commission, which is responsible for the boundary review, to make any changes.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

: Politics

Trump sent Kim Jong Un an ‘excellent’ letter: 2019-06-22 21:56:22Kim "said with satisfaction that the letter is of excellent content," the Korean Central News Agency reported.

U.S. unveils $50B boost for Palestinians as part 2019-06-22 14:16:41Palestinian leaders have rejected the Trump administration's approach to peace in the Middle East, saying the U.S. is biased toward Israel.

Chase, B.C. man launching constitutional challenge against federal 2019-06-21 21:41:23The federal government is facing growing pressure over impaired driving rules brought into effect December 2018. 

Canada sanctions members of Nicaragua government for human 2019-06-21 19:53:42The measures include asset freezes and dealings prohibitions with nine members of the Nicaraguan government, including Gustavo Eduardo Porras Cortes,

Premier Doug Ford’s chief of staff Dean French 2019-06-21 19:38:12"Earlier this afternoon Premier Ford accepted the resignation of his Chief of Staff, Dean French," the premier's office said in a statement.

Trump accused of sexual assault by writer E. 2019-06-21 17:53:05E. Jean Carroll, an advice columnist for Elle magazine, detailed an incident she said took place in either late 1995 or early 1996.

NEB seeks opinions on Trans Mountain pipeline process 2019-06-21 17:37:32The National Energy Board has issued a certificate for the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion after it was approved by Ottawa on Tuesday but is seeking

Kenney says bills C-48, C-69 ‘prejudicial attack on 2019-06-21 17:04:08Alberta Premier Jason Kenney said Friday he was "profoundly disappointed" that the Senate passed bills C-48 and C-69 Thursday.

Exec who worked on Moscow Trump Tower to 2019-06-21 16:55:28House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff said the committee will subpoena Sater after he “agreed to appear this morning and he did not

Why critics fear Bill C-69 will be a 2019-06-21 15:50:47Critics worry the new process will make Canada less attractive to energy-industry investors, but experts say those concerns are overblown.

Reality check: Declaring a climate emergency sends a 2019-06-18 13:59:09The symbolic vote came just hours before the government is set to announce its decision on whether to let the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion procee

Trump says Patrick Shanahan out of running for 2019-06-18 13:22:59Trump said the secretary of the Army will be named the new acting defense secretary.

CBC | Politics News

Canadian soldier killed in overseas training exercise remembered 2019-06-22 10:48:57The family of a Canadian soldier who died in a parachute accident in Bulgaria is remembering him as a "ray of sunshine" who had wante

TMX approval was already factored in to Paris 2019-06-22 09:00:00This week on The House we discuss the federal cabinet's decision to approve the Trans Mountain pipeline, again.

How much will Canada's new frigates really cost? 2019-06-22 04:00:00This week, the navy begins 'requirements reconciliation' on its frigate program - a dull but necessary exercise to review the design in detail, push

Canadians can soon get quick, free pot pardons 2019-06-22 04:00:00Canadians saddled with criminal records for possessing cannabis can soon apply for fast, free pardons, but professionals working in the fiel

Steven Guilbeault opposes pipelines. So why is he 2019-06-22 04:00:00This was a particularly interesting week for Steven Guilbeault — one of Canada's most prominent environmentalists — to announce 

Small, medium-sized financial firms vulnerable to cyberattacks, says 2019-06-21 18:19:57Canada's small and medium-sized financial firms could be vulnerable to the constant barrage of cyberattacks aimed at Canadian businesses, says the Ho

Jason Kenney to hold elections for Alberta Senate 2019-06-21 18:03:06After the Senate last night passed the Liberal government's controversial overhaul of the environmental assessment regime and the oil tanker ban bill

CBSA won't be getting independent oversight as bill 2019-06-21 17:38:32The Liberal government's promise to set up an outside review body to keep tabs on misbehaving border agents isn't going through. Bill C-98 did not c

PBO pushes up cost estimate for Canada's frigate 2019-06-21 13:27:46Canada’s Parliamentary Budget Office has compiled a revised cost estimate for the navy’s new frigates, and predicts the program

NEB issues certificate for Trans Mountain Pipeline 2019-06-21 12:44:02The National Energy Board has issued a certificate for the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion after it was approved by Ottawa on Tuesday but is seeking

Bill to support jurors with PTSD dies in 2019-06-21 12:34:46Former jurors plan to pressure political parties to revive a bill that would allow them to get adequate mental health treatment after doing

Senate passes environmental assessment bill 2019-06-21 07:44:18A pair of controversial environmental bills, including the environmental assessment bill, scaled their final hurdle in the Senate on Thursday&nbs

Politique canadienne

Canola : Bibeau a parlé à son homologue chinois 2019-05-13 21:56:00La ministre de l'Agriculture, Marie-Claude Bibeau, a rencontré brièvement son homologue chinois, avec qui elle a discuté de la s

Ottawa se joint à une coalition franco-allemande 2019-04-15 20:11:00Le Canada s'est officiellement joint à une coalition franco-allemande visant à préserver l'ordre mondial international de la de

Le retrait canadien du Mali aura des répercussions 2019-04-08 18:21:00Un député libéral a reproché au gouvernement fédéral de ne pas apporter sa juste contribution aux opé

Affaire SNC-Lavalin: la grogne monte envers Wilson-Raybould 2019-04-02 05:00:00La grogne s'installe dans les rangs libéraux. La décision de l'ancienne ministre de la Justice Jody Wilson-Raybould d'enregistrer le

SNC-Lavalin: le commissaire à l'éthique pourrait déposer son rapport 2019-03-27 05:00:00Le commissaire à l'éthique et aux conflits d'intérêts, Mario Dion, est libre de déposer quand il le jugera opportu

SNC-Lavalin: Scheer exhorte Trudeau à «coopérer» 2019-03-26 00:00:00Alors que le comité de l'éthique de la Chambre des communes doit décider aujourd'hui s'il entreprend à son tour une &ea

Trudeau exploite l'attentat en Nouvelle-Zélande, accuse Bernier 2019-03-25 11:22:00Maxime Bernier accuse Justin Trudeau «d'exploiter» la tuerie du 15 mars dans deux mosquées de la Nouvelle-Zélande.

Trudeau livre un discours à saveur électorale à 2019-03-25 06:33:00Justin Trudeau a livré dimanche soir à Vancouver un discours énergique à forte saveur électorale en attaquant le ch

Une élection partielle déclenchée à Nanaimo-Ladysmith 2019-03-24 17:18:00Le premier ministre fédéral Justin Trudeau a annoncé dimanche le déclenchement d'une élection partielle dans la ci

Karl Rove s'adresse aux conservateurs à Ottawa 2019-03-22 22:01:00Le célèbre stratège républicain Karl Rove a lancé un message aux conservateurs canadiens : les slogans simplis

L'ONU demande au Canada de prolonger sa mission 2019-03-22 20:43:00Les Nations unies ont officiellement demandé au Canada de prolonger sa mission au Mali dans ce qui semble être un ultime effort pour &eac

Radio-Canada | Politique

« Bébés du printemps » : le ministre 2018-01-13 13:49:00Le ministre de la Famille, Luc Fortin, a finalement maintenu entièrement une politique administrative concernant les garderies qui permet aux e

Le nombre de vétérans attendant une réponse à 2017-12-10 16:32:00De nouvelles données montrent que le nombre de vétérans qui attendent une réponse à leur demande de prestation d'i

Option nationale appuie la fusion avec Québec solidaire 2017-12-10 09:47:00Les membres d'Option nationale se sont prononcés dimanche pour la fusion avec Québec solidaire.

Entente Netflix : prise de bec entre Mélanie 2017-11-02 19:19:00De vigoureux échanges ont opposé Mélanie Joly et le député Pierre Nantel pendant la réunion du comité

Justin Trudeau hausse le ton contre Boeing 2017-09-18 15:51:00Le premier ministre Justin Trudeau hausse le ton contre Boeing, affirmant que le Canada ne ferait pas affaire avec une compagnie qui s'attaque &agrav

Fournier nie les allégations de Francœur, mais réfléchit 2017-09-18 07:58:00Visé par des allégations du chef syndical Yves Francoeur, le leader parlementaire du gouvernement Couillard, Jean-Marc Fournier, admet a

Les coûts des médicaments génériques réduits de plus 2017-07-16 10:48:00Après plusieurs semaines de négociations, le ministre de la Santé Gaétan Barrette a annoncé dimanche une entente en

Roméo Saganash s'excuse d'avoir plagié des portions de 2017-07-05 01:44:00Le porte-parole néo-démocrate en matière d'affaires autochtones, Roméo Saganash, s'est excusé mardi d'avoir plag

Violence fondée sur le sexe : les refuges 2017-07-04 01:08:00Le Nord du Canada est désavantagé lorsque vient le temps de distribuer du financement fédéral pour réduire la viole

Une campagne pour recruter les jeunes dans l'armée 2017-06-21 06:59:00Une nouvelle campagne de recrutement intitulée Osez vous surpasser sera lancée sur les médias sociaux et au cinéma d&egrav

Mélanie Joly nomme un comité de sélection des 2017-06-20 15:15:00La ministre du Patrimoine Mélanie Joly a annoncé mardi la création d'un comité indépendant qui recommandera des ca

Deux lois « antisyndicales » du gouvernement Harper 2017-06-19 19:20:00Après un véritable jeu de ping-pong, le projet de loi C-4, qui abolit deux lois antisyndicales du gouvernement Harper, a finalement &e

Breitbart News

CNN: Pelosi Asked Trump Friday Night to Cancel 2019-06-22 21:30:40House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) telephoned President Donald Trump on Friday evening with a request that he cancel the Immigration and Customs Enforc

Gillibrand: Hillary Clinton 'Most Qualified Person Ever to 2019-06-22 21:17:45In an interview with "GirlBoss Radio" released Wednesday, longshot 2020 White House candidate Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) declared

Rob Reiner Dreads 'Ineffectual' Democrats Won't Ever Impeach 2019-06-22 20:51:05Hollywood filmmaker and left-wing activist Rob Reiner melted down on Saturday, fearing that "ineffectual" Democrats in Congress won't ever pull the

George Conway: Latest Rape Claim Against Trump More 2019-06-22 20:42:11Attorney George Conway, the husband of White House counselor Kellyanne Conway, declared Saturday that the latest rape allegation against Presiden

Biden: Trump's Account of Iran Strike Decision 'Simply 2019-06-22 19:50:15On Saturday’s broadcast of MSNBC’s “PoliticsNation,” 2020 Democratic presidential candidate former Vice President Joe Biden qu

Warren: GOP Has 'Hacked Away' Bits of Roe 2019-06-22 18:46:00Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) said the GOP has "hacked away" too many pieces of Roe v. Wade, so she called for a bill to make it the law of the land

Biden References Another Former Segregationist While Campaigning 2019-06-22 18:24:43Former Vice President Joe Biden referenced another former segregationist, the late-Sen. Fritz Hollings (D-SC), while campaigning in South Carolina on

Family Sues Ontario School Over Gender Indoctrination 2019-06-22 18:03:57An Ontario family has filed a formal complaint with the provincial Human Rights Tribunal after a public-school teacher tried to convince their 6-year-

Ocasio-Cortez: Trump Administration 'Fighting to Not Give Children 2019-06-22 18:02:35Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) is doubling down on her claims that the Trump administration is running concentration camps on the southern borde

Illinois Governor Bans Private Detention Centers Ahead of 2019-06-22 17:48:24Illinois Governor JB Pritzker, a Democrat, signed a bill on Friday that bans privately run migrant detention centers in the state.

Eric Swalwell Encourages Hispanics to Take Fight Against 2019-06-22 16:54:04Hispanic voters should take their fight against President Trump to the "streets," Rep. Eric Swalwell suggested in a tweet Saturday.

Donald Trump Backs Down on Deportation Threat 2019-06-22 16:34:28"At the request of Democrats, I have delayed the Illegal Immigration Removal Process (Deportation) for two weeks to see if the Democrats and Republic

Politics – Macleans.ca

What is Jason Kenney’s ‘energy war room’ good 2019-06-21 14:29:07Chris Turner: The crack unit tasked with pushing back 'lies' about the oil sands is so far trading in shop-worn spin and conspiracy theories The pos

Donald Trump promises to do Justin Trudeau a 2019-06-21 07:00:14Politics Insider for June 21: Elections Canada cancels influencer campaign, back in Trump's good books and Scheer's low bar climate plan The post Do

The strange reality of Donald Trump’s White House 2019-06-20 21:02:08Step inside the famous building and things seem, in places, smaller and shabbier. But there's no mistaking the lure of the man in the middle of it.

What a nice little airplane you have, Mr. 2019-06-20 16:33:29Image of the Week: Trump forced Justin Trudeau to look upon a toy-sized model of Air Force One as the two discussed world affairs. No one said the mee

An environmental plan that takes people at their 2019-06-20 13:29:02Andrew MacDougall: The Conservatives have offered up a cynical climate plan—will doing even less than Trudeau be enough? The post An environment

Scheer climate plan big on red tape, shy 2019-06-20 07:00:49Politics Insider for June 20: Scheer's 'real' climate plan, what Chretien's done to Canada and the fix for a broken world The post Scheer climate

The Scheer climate plan: whatever 2019-06-20 06:31:34Paul Wells: I assume the Conservatives will win the votes of only the most woefully confused environmentalists in Canada, if even those. Their target

What Jean Chrétien has done to Canada on 2019-06-19 16:12:12Terry Glavin: Why does Beijing think the Trudeau government can simply shuck off the U.S. and free the Huawei exec? Because a certain former PM keeps

Trudeau’s Trans Mountain approval draws cautious praise and 2019-06-19 07:00:15Politics Insider for June 19: Trudeau gives Trans Mountain a thumbs up, what people said about TMX, and Scheer's climate plan reveal The post Trudeau

Is that my plastic bag in the Mariana 2019-06-19 05:30:32Trash discovered at the ocean's deepest point sadly illustrates the depth of the plastic pollution problem The post Is that my plastic bag in the Mar

The Liberals review Andrew Scheer’s climate plan. Spoiler: 2019-06-18 17:56:54Paul Wells: Ministers have been eagerly pre-butting Scheer's credibility. Not that their own party has much to brag about. The post The Liberals revi

Trudeau’s looming Trans Mountain decision 2019-06-18 07:00:45Politics Insider for June 18: Pipeline's future, Ottawa declares a climate emergency and politicians rubbing shoulders with Raptors The post Trudeau&

CTVNews.ca - Politics -

Singh can't say when an NDP government would 2019-06-22 07:00:00In an interview on CTV's Question Period Singh vowed to be responsible with the budget if elected, but stated his intention is to follow through on t

Canada imposes sanctions on four high-ranking Nicaraguan officials 2019-06-21 19:31:28The Canadian government imposed sanctions against four high-ranking Nicaraguan government officials Friday, citing 'gross and systemic' human rights

Truth Tracker: No, Justin Trudeau isn’t converting from 2019-06-21 17:49:39An old story from a “satirical” website has been making the rounds on social media claiming that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has convert

Security committee 'questions wisdom' of using Chinese technology 2019-06-21 15:00:40The House of Commons' national-security committee "questions the wisdom" of using technology produced in China in the electronic devices and softwa

Indigenous stat holiday bill destined to die in 2019-06-21 13:20:00A new bill designating September 30 as a statutory holiday known as ‘National Day for Truth and Reconciliation’ is expected to die in Sena

PBO sets budget baseline for campaign vows with 2019-06-21 13:12:00Parliament's spending watchdog is predicting years of deficits deeper than the government has laid out.

Rob Ford's widow Renata Ford to run for 2019-06-21 11:56:00Renata Ford, the wife of late Toronto mayor Rob Ford, is planning to run for a seat in the upcoming federal election for Maxime Bernier’s People

Analysis: Trudeau-Trump Washington meeting helps end Canada's global 2019-06-21 06:35:00Canada suddenly became a little less lonely in the world after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's meeting in Washington with President Donald Trump this

The Liberal in charge of legislation on the 2019-06-20 17:58:11On Thursday the House of Commons adjourned for potentially the last time before the fall federal election, pending a parliamentary recall to ratify NA

House of Commons rises but MPs could still 2019-06-20 09:26:00The House of Commons has adjourned, wrapping potentially the last sitting day for MPs before the fall federal election is called, and the end of the L

Deadline for cabinet to decide future of Trans 2019-06-18 04:17:00The federal government is widely expected to green light the Trans Mountain expansion project a second time today but, even with a Yes vote, construct

Dominic LeBlanc says he'll hit campaign trail after 2019-06-17 21:07:00Longtime Liberal MP Dominic LeBlanc is sharing “good news” regarding his health. In a video message posted online Monday, LeBlanc said tha

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.