• Follow us

Politics

Scheer tried to douse a debate on abortion, same-sex marriage — and muddied the waters even more | CBC News

Conservative leader Andrew Scheer's appearance at a hotel near the Toronto airport on Thursday afternoon was his first interaction with reporters in more than a week — a gap that coincided with the Liberal Party's decision to resurface video of Scheer talking about same-sex marriage in 2005.

By the time he finally stepped forward, the Liberals had posted another clip — this time raising questions about what Scheer has been telling anti-abortion activists.

In response, Scheer accused the Liberals of "dredging up divisive issues" to distract Canadians.

But if Canadians are distracted, it's in no small part because Scheer is still struggling to explain himself.

Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer says that every Canadian, including LGTB Canadians, have the same equality rights under the law and that he will defend those rights both here and abroad. 1:15

On abortion, Scheer first said that "individual MPs have the right to express themselves on matters of conscience, but a Conservative government will not reopen these divisive social issues." This, he said, was in keeping with the approach of the previous Conservative government led by Stephen Harper.

But Harper's position actually seemed to change over time.

At first, Harper was willing to let backbench Conservative MPs bring forward bills and motions related to abortion. A few MPs did so. But in 2013, Harper seemed to adopt a new attitude — provoked by a motion about sex-selective abortion, he apparently decided that he would do everything in his power to ensure that no Conservative proposal on abortion reached the floor of the House of Commons.

According to a HuffPost Canada article earlier this week, Scheer's own Quebec lieutenant apparently believed that such a ban on backbench activity was still in place. But Scheer's office subsequently was unwilling to clarify how much freedom Conservative MPs would have under a government led by him.

"It's really just the Liberals" pushing these questions, Scheer protested on Thursday.

Scheer in 2017 vs. Scheer today

But the Conservative leader is no doubt well aware that it's not just Liberals who are interested in his stance.

In 2017, when Scheer was seeking the Conservative leadership, he was asked by an anti-abortion organization to explain how he would handle the issue. He insisted then that both backbench MPs and cabinet ministers would be able to vote freely on matters related to abortion and that he would support the "right" of MPs to "speak out and introduce matters that are important to them."

It was an account of that interview that the Liberals unearthed and posted to Twitter on Thursday morning.

Women’s rights are human rights &amp; we need to send a message that no one - including Andrew Scheer or any member of his Conservative caucus -has the authority to dictate to women what they can &amp; cannot do with their bodies. It’s time for him to be honest &amp; come out of hiding. <a href="https://t.co/BO2rOC5JGv">https://t.co/BO2rOC5JGv</a>

&mdash;@JonathanWNV

On Thursday afternoon, Scheer was asked whether Conservative backbenchers would be punished by the party whip if they tried to bring forward an initiative related to abortion. Scheer dismissed the question as hypothetical and proceeded to argue that his party was the only major party "that allows people to hold a deeply held personal view on these types of issues" — but then he seemed to suggest that he did not expect a Conservative MP would ever try to table such a bill.

Conservatives, he said, "recognize that we will ... oppose measures to open this. I am confident that my party, my caucus understands that."

"We welcome people with different perspectives on any number of issues," he added later. "But when we come together, we work as a team."

So, yes or no — could a Conservative MP freely table a bill on abortion?

It's not at all clear.

Scheer in 2005 vs. Scheer today

On same-sex marriage — the other issue on which the Liberals have hit Scheer simply by quoting his own words back at him — the Conservative leader was equally reluctant to dwell on details.

The issue, he said, was "settled." As prime minister, he would uphold the law and the equality rights of all Canadians.

To be a leader for all Canadians, the Conservative Party leader should now end his lifelong boycott of Pride events and explain whether he would still deny same-sex couples the right to marry, as he said in Parliament. <a href="https://t.co/5WEyja6Ov5">pic.twitter.com/5WEyja6Ov5</a>

&mdash;@RalphGoodale

But he was unwilling to say whether his own opinion has changed. He passed on the chance to revisit or reflect upon what he said in 2005, when he told the House of Commons that same-sex marriage was a contradiction in terms because same-sex couples could not be equally entitled to an institution intended for "natural procreation."

"These were arguments that were being put forward by many people who held views on this issue," he said.

Some of those people might be willing now to march in a Pride parade. But Scheer continues to decline the opportunity.

"There are many ways to support the community," he said Thursday, citing his support for protecting LGBT refugees fleeing persecution in other countries. He didn't mention his vote against a bill to expand protections for transgender Canadians.

Scheer's situation is no doubt complicated by disagreements within the Conservative movement. But it's the task of every leader to manage differing opinions, and to rise to the occasion when difficult moments emerge.

In addition to accusing the Liberals of needlessly raising divisive social issues, Scheer tried to mount an offensive on the basis that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has so far only committed to participate in two election debates, instead of the four to which Scheer has committed.

"I urge Justin Trudeau to show some courage, show up, to defend his record and his decisions over the last four years," Scheer said.

It was an odd argument to make after seven days of self-imposed silence.

But if the last week is a sign of things to come, Trudeau and the Liberals might soon be very eager to give Andrew Scheer every possible opportunity to explain himself again, and in public.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

: Politics

First days of election campaigns marked by candidate 2019-09-13 19:56:52Party leaders have had to contend with their candidates' past social media posts and lives.

Analysis: A Scheer victory does not guarantee carbon 2019-09-13 19:47:20In a Conservative led minority government, Andrew Scheer would likely face major roadblocks if he attempted to repeal the carbon tax.

Federal Conservatives focus on boosting party’s message to 2019-09-13 18:35:24When asked by a reporter during a campaign stop on Friday what Ontario residents are supposed to make of the fact he doesn’t seem to want Ford n

Snowden reveals why he leaked and scale of 2019-09-13 18:34:55The book, "Permanent Record," is scheduled to be released Tuesday.

By the numbers: What to know about the 2019-09-13 18:07:08The proposed new incentive is more attractive for buyers in expensive cities, but critics still see plenty they don't like.

B.C. candidate expelled from PPC asks Maxime Bernier 2019-09-13 17:54:29Brian Misera's name no longer appears on the party's website, which no longer links to his Twitter and Facebook profiles.

Activist Greta Thunberg joins climate protest in Washington 2019-09-13 17:41:02Thunberg and about 1,500 protesters, many of them schoolchildren, marched and chanted near the White House on Friday.

Liberal ridings received 75% of government largesse funding 2019-09-13 17:07:19Liberal ridings gained about 75 per cent of the total government largesse, while roughly equal proportions of the spending was aimed at NDP and Conser

Reality check: Scheer’s claim about refugees ‘jumping the 2019-09-13 16:15:01Conservative Party Leader Andrew Scheer says asylum seekers who make claims at the border are "jumping the queue." This is false, and experts say th

Trump calls for ban on flavoured e-cigarettes — 2019-09-13 16:09:45Canada's political party leaders were not nearly as blunt on the subject while asked on the campaign trail.

Photo of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez set ablaze in attack 2019-09-13 12:14:37The congresswoman's face burns away to reveal a black-and-white image of skulls in the ad.

RCMP intel director charged in major case was 2019-09-13 12:11:04Sources with knowledge of national security investigations described Ortis as former RCMP Comm. Bob Paulson’s most elite advisor on national sec

CBC | Politics News

Middle-class mystery: Did their taxes go up or 2019-09-14 04:00:00The Liberals say they've put more money in the pockets of Canada's middle class. The Tories say they've raised taxes. Who's telling the truth?

How the prime minister can seal — or 2019-09-14 04:00:00Since the day the election campaign kicked off, Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau has been dogged by questions about why he won’t waive cabinet conf

An introduction to the new Quebec nationalism and 2019-09-14 04:00:00The new nationalism in Quebec is a political mindset that has displaced sovereignty as the main alternative to federalism and, as the first week of th

Where the party leaders are on Day 4 2019-09-14 04:00:00Here's what you need to know about where the federal leaders are on Day 4 of the campaign. Watch streaming video of available live events throug

Liberals target NDP seats in opening phase of 2019-09-14 04:00:00Justin Trudeau is campaigning against a return to the Stephen Harper era - but he knows the path to victory goes through NDP ridings, and that's wher

Professor 'shocked' at former student's arrest on security 2019-09-13 20:33:19A university professor who supervised the PhD studies of a senior Canadian security official arrested under the Security of Information Act says he is

Scheer's costly tax credit could boost public transit 2019-09-13 19:35:31The proposed Green Public Transit Tax Credit could benefit wealthy Canadians the most and do little to boost ridership, experts say.

Renata Ford, Maxime Bernier pin hopes on 'Ford 2019-09-13 19:03:14A federal election campaign launch in the Liberal Toronto riding of Etobicoke North would normally gather little media interest — exce

Elizabeth May says Green party is 're-vetting' candidates 2019-09-13 16:03:42Green Party Leader Elizabeth May says her party is in the process of "re-vetting" some candidates previously approved to run for the party in t

Strongly worded posts by Regina Green candidate decried 2019-09-13 11:42:40On Thursday, the Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center for Holocaust Studies called for the Green party to dismiss Dale Dewar, candidate in the Sask

Intelligence community reeling after RCMP director accused of 2019-09-13 11:40:58A senior official working with an RCMP intelligence team has been charged under the Security of Information Act — an event that is expected

Scheer, Singh talk transit, cellphone fees in GTA 2019-09-13 10:21:38Andrew Scheer and Jagmeet Singh are pitching pocketbook issues today, with the Conservatives promising to give money back to public transit users and

Breitbart News

Michelle Obama Selling Tickets as High as $4,200 2019-09-14 23:43:52Michelle Obama is charging as much as $4,200 for tickets to her upcoming event dubbed, "A Moderated Conversation with Michelle Obama," according to

Bernie Sanders: 'We Are Going to Impose a 2019-09-14 23:36:03Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) told a group that he backs a moratorium on all deportations from the U.S., a video surfaced on Saturday revealed.

Omar Compares Migrant Shelters to Dungeons Used in 2019-09-14 21:43:57Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) compared migrant shelters in the U.S. to dungeons used during the African slave trade, according to a video that surfaced Satur

Watch--Michelle Malkin Confronts Sanctuary County Official: 'Don't You 2019-09-14 19:08:12Michelle Malkin confronted a Maryland sanctuary city official, asking him "Don't you care about women?" following a series of alleged rapes and sex

Pinkerton: Democrat Strategist Visits Trump Country to Find 2019-09-14 19:03:43The headline in The New York Times is nothing if not declarative: “The Republican Party Is Doomed.”  And the first lines of the opini

Trump Celebrates ‘Historic Milestone’ of 150th Judge Confirmed: 2019-09-14 18:34:24President Trump celebrated the Senate confirmation of his 150th judicial nominee in a tweet Saturday, calling it "amazing!"

Biden Promises to Release Medical Records amid Mounting 2019-09-14 17:59:57Former Vice President Joe Biden (D) vowed to release his medical records during a conversation with reporters Friday amid mounting concerns over his g

Poll: Majority of Hispanics Support Ending Welfare-Dependent Immigration 2019-09-14 17:18:06A majority of Hispanic Americans support President Trump's seeking to prevent welfare-dependent legal immigrants from permanently resettling in the U

Sanders Addresses Emotional Veteran Who Threatened Suicide over 2019-09-14 17:00:22A veteran battling Huntington's disease told Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) – who held a town hall in Carson City, Nevada, on Friday – that h

Pennsylvania Democrat Under House Arrest After Driving Drunk 2019-09-14 16:15:42A Pennsylvania Democrat is serving a month of house arrest after pleading guilty to driving drunk, reports said. 

Felicity Huffman 14 Day Jail Sentence Sparks Outrage: 2019-09-14 16:14:21Actress and Desperate Housewives star Felicity Huffman is coming under intense fire after being sentenced to just 14 days in jail after she

Biden: It's Fair to Play the Age Card 2019-09-14 16:14:07While speaking to reporters on Friday, 2020 Democratic presidential candidate former Vice President Joe Biden stated that it’s fair for his riva

Politics – Macleans.ca

What Elizabeth May had to do at the 2019-09-13 01:36:43Anne Kingston: After faux-shaking Justin Trudeau's hand, May needed to establish that a Green vote was a credible alternative The post What Elizabeth

9 must-see moments from the 2019 National Leaders 2019-09-13 01:36:03Andrew Scheer, Elizabeth May and Jagmeet Singh challenged each other on big, powerful issues—and, of course, directed fire at the prime minister

Federal leaders bow to Francois Legault on Bill 2019-09-13 01:28:17Legault asked them to stay out of legal challenges 'forever.' For now, none of them will get in his way The post Federal leaders bow to Francois Leg

Jagmeet Singh’s moment to shine—and get a little 2019-09-13 00:49:33The NDP leader was at his most compelling when he was mad, and standing up for a cause. It helped him emerge from the first debate looking like the wi

Andrew Scheer glowers at the Man Who Wasn’t 2019-09-13 00:46:37It should be easy to look prime ministerial when the Prime Minister isn't at the debate. But Scheer couldn't quite pull it off. The post Andrew Sche

Starting at the end: the closing statements tell 2019-09-13 00:29:13Scheer aimed to highlight trust-plus-affordabilty, while May declared the status quo obsolete. But Singh hit his marks most consistently with his focu

The U.S. democratic primary debate versus the Canadian 2019-09-12 23:51:40Jaime J. Weinman: The U.S. debate was like Saturday Night Live, while the Canadian debate, appropriately enough, was more like SCTV The post The U.S.

The Elizabeth May show and the first leaders 2019-09-12 23:46:17Stephen Maher: While Scheer hit a wall with his climate plan and Singh came up short on policy detail, the Green leader, an experienced debater, took

National Leaders Debate 2019: Behind-the-scenes photos 2019-09-12 20:25:50An inside look at the first debate of the 2019 federal election through photos The post National Leaders Debate 2019: Behind-the-scenes photos appeare

National Leaders Debate 2019: Full replay | Maclean’s 2019-09-12 15:13:54Paul Wells moderated the first debate of the election calendar. Watch a full replay here The post National Leaders Debate 2019: Full replay | Maclean&

Election 2019: Let the games begin—and may the 2019-09-12 13:40:43Tabatha Southey: Between the Greens' 'own-goaling,' the NDP being short of good enough, the Conservatives wanting to erase Andrew Scheer's 2005, a

Trouble on Air Trudeau, where the media is 2019-09-12 13:34:05Election Image of the Day: No one knows better than the Liberals that people in the news business are just scraping by The post Trouble on Air Trudeau

CTVNews.ca - Politics -

Scheer pressed on abortion debate on campaign trail 2019-09-12 11:54:00Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer’s first stop on the second day of the federal election campaign was preoccupied by the ongoing abortion debate

Two NDP candidates resign at start of federal 2019-09-12 11:31:00Two NDP candidates have resigned at the start of the federal election campaign, one because of domestic abuse allegations he denies and the other over

Liberals get new campaign plane after collision with 2019-09-12 01:33:00An unwrapped Air Transat plane will temporarily replace Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau’s election-branded aircraft, after a media bus hit and dam

338 ridings, 40 days, 1 vote: Election campaign 2019-09-11 08:24:00Justin Trudeau has set in motion the 2019 federal election campaign, setting up his re-election bid as a choice for forward progress, while his oppone

Greens clarify abortion stance after May says she 2019-09-09 20:50:00The Green Party says there is 'zero chance' that any of its members would attempt to reopen the abortion debate in the House of Commons, issuing the

'Friends of Science' thanks Elections Canada for warning 2019-09-09 17:52:00A Calgary organization that argues climate change is nothing close to a global emergency says Elections Canada is right to keep a close eye on campaig

Waiting for the election to be called: Pre-campaign 2019-09-09 17:32:00While it may seem that the election campaign has begun, with parties exchanging partisan attacks and unveiling their ads, slogans, and in some cases c

Quebec, Ontario first targets in launch of Conservative 2019-09-09 15:23:00The federal Conservatives will formally launch their federal election campaign Wednesday with two events in places where they aim to increase their su

Everything you need to know about the 2019 2019-09-09 12:00:00Here's how you can watch, listen, and engage with the two official leaders' debates in the 2019 election campaign.

AFN outlines 2019 federal election priorities 2019-09-09 10:35:00The Assembly of First Nations has outlined what it views as the key election 2019 priorities for federal parties and candidates. Among the top commitm

Trudeau and Vancouver's mayor talk housing, transit and 2019-08-30 14:17:18Prime Minister Justin Trudeau touted his government's record on some of the most sensitive issues facing Vancouver as he met with Mayor Kennedy Stewa

Lawyer for suspended public servant requests delay in 2019-08-30 11:42:08A lawyer for a federal public servant accused of leaking cabinet secrets about a $700-million shipbuilding project is asking for a delay in the case u


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.