• Follow us


The big question about democracy lurking behind Quebec's secularism bill | CBC News

There were a couple of Islamophobic outbursts, a bit of verbal jousting between the minister and his critics, and a visit from the two wise men of religious accommodation.

But amid the theatrics of the first week of hearings into the Quebec government's secularism bill, the stakes of the whole exercise became clear in one dramatic — but little-noticed — exchange.

That conversation, between an even-tempered law professor and the bill's sponsor, exposed a big question behind the legislation: just how supreme is the will of the people? 

The Coalition Avenir Québec government is, of course, using the hearings to muster a variety of views on its proposal to ban some civil-service workers from wearing religious symbols.

It's a necessary step in any bill's passage. The CAQ, though, has given the distinct impression it would like to dispatch with the whole process as quickly as possible.

Only six days of hearings, after all, have been set aside to discuss Bill 21's 3,600-word draft. Premier François Legault wants the whole thing sorted within the next month.

'This bill will allow us to turn the page,' Immigration Minister Simon Jolin-Barrette, the bill's sponsor, said as he opened the hearings last week. (Jonathan Montpetit/CBC)

Never mind that governments have been wrestling with the issue of religious symbols for more than 10 years. "This bill will allow us to turn the page," Immigration Minister Simon Jolin-Barrette, the bill's sponsor, said as he opened the hearings last week.

But in the way they've worded the bill the government has, perhaps inadvertently, also opened up a debate about the very nature of modern democracy.

Will of the majority or minority rights?

The terms of this other debate are a little different from the question of whether Bill 21 is the right way to protect the secular nature of the Quebec government.

This other debate is about who gets to rule in a democracy, and about whether that power can be checked by people who are not elected.

Bill 21, like the Parti Québécois's ill-fated Charter of Values, seeks to impose limits on what religious symbols civil servants can wear while at work — limits that do not currently exist.

So, for example, women who wear the hijab are currently able to teach in public schools. They will lose that freedom if the bill passes. (The bill does contain a narrow grandfather clause.)

The bill has drawn widespread criticism in Quebec, especially from minority groups. (Graham Hughes/Canadian Press)

But unlike the Charter of Values, or any of the other previous attempts to legislate secularism in Quebec, the government has inserted a notwithstanding clause in the bill.

Doing so, the government believes, will prevent the eventual law from being challenged on grounds that it violates fundamental rights listed in either the Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms or the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Let's stop here to get an initial glimpse of the battle lines.

On the one hand, you have a majority government trying to execute what it believes to be the will of its voters.

On the other hand, you have charters designed to protect the rights of the minority. And with them, unelected judges tasked with ensuring the charters are respected.

In the case of Bill 21, the desires of an elected majority could potentially be checked by unelected judges.

To prevent that from happening, to ensure the supremacy of elected officials, the CAQ is invoking the notwithstanding clause.

The minister and the professor

This debate played itself out on Wednesday, when Louis-Philippe Lampron, a law professor at l'Université Laval, testified at the hearings.

He appeared just after the sociologist Gérard Bouchard. Bouchard's co-author of the landmark 2008 study on reasonable accommodations, Charles Taylor, made his appearance the day before.

While Bill 21 does not target one religion specifically, Charles Taylor argues it must be understood in the context of a society "full of Islamophobia." 0:59

So the committee room was relatively empty when Lampron showed up. That's too bad. He and Jolin-Barrette, as if playing roles scripted for them, proceeded to embody the tension between majority rule and minority rights.

The exchange began with Jolin-Barrette asking Lampron about his views on the nothwithstanding clause.

Lampron replied that there is nothing wrong with the clause per se. His issue is with it being used preemptively, before a law could even be challenged in court.

"We are at the heart here of what is supposed to be protected by human rights and freedoms, that is to say, the protection of minority groups against potential abuses by the majority," Lampron said of Bill 21.

That seems to take Jolin-Barrette aback. The minister gets defensive. Bill 21 doesn't single out any particular religion, he says; its measures apply equally to Christians, Muslims, Jews and Sikhs.

"Why are you mentioning the impact on minorities, when it affects the majority as much as the minority," Jolin-Barrette asks the law professor.

Lampron, unfazed, argues there is a difference between direct and indirect discrimination.

'Whether it is the Quebec charter or the Canadian charter, you can't avoid the obligation of having rights and freedoms examined by an independent third party,' law professor Louis-Philippe Lampron said during his appearance before the committee. (Alice Chiche/Radio-Canada)

Sure, he says, the law may make no mention of a particular religion and so appears to apply evenly to everyone across the board. But look at the "net effect" of the ban:

"There is a category of the population that … won't have to do anything to respect [the legislation] — the majority of the Quebec population, which is Christian, atheist or agnostic," Lampron said.

The burden of the law falls on minority groups, Lampron added, they are the ones who will be disadvantaged. "And that's enough to demonstrate the existence of a charter right violation."

Their exchange sidetracks momentarily, but Jolin-Barrette eventually circles back to the question of charter rights.

He suggests to Lampron the problem is the Canadian charter, and the multicultural values it conveys.

(The backstory here is the belief — widespread in Quebec, not just within the CAQ — that federal multiculturalism policies water down the province's ability to preserve its distinct francophone identity.)

What about, Jolin-Barrette says, giving more power to the Quebec Charter of Human Rights?

The question is not about which charter is better for Quebec, Lampron replies. The question is whether we are a society that respects human rights, or only pays lip service to them.

If it's the former, then it shouldn't be up the government to decide when it has struck the right balance between the desires of the majority and the rights of the minority.

"Whether it is the Quebec charter or the Canadian charter, you can't avoid the obligation of having rights and freedoms examined by an independent third party," Lampron said.

Gérard Bouchard, co-author of the Bouchard-Taylor report, appeared before the committee on Wednesday. (Jonathan Montpetit/CBC)

To the law professor, the minister of the majority replies:

"Yes, in fact, it is a choice. We consider that Quebec society has to, through its elected representatives, decide on the relationship between religions and the state."

This, of course, isn't the only pressing question being addressed at the hearings. But it does suggest one reason why Quebecers may want to pay attention when they resume Tuesday.

The majority government they elected is in the process of outlining just how far it thinks its power reaches.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

Canada – Macleans.ca

Why Lake Erie has the same rights as 2019-05-20 07:00:37Most Canadians seem unaware of the lake’s newfound legal rights. But it begs the question of whether Ontario farmers bear responsibility for the

‘We were five votes away from a majority:’ 2019-05-17 18:21:37The Liberal premier says his party has heard voters' plea for politicians to 'work together.' Also, he denies his leadership is in jeopardy The pos

Conviction is inevitable for Canadians charged with espionage 2019-05-17 07:00:06Politics Insider for May 17: China's 'unacceptable' espionage charges, Alabama abortion fallout and Scheer's economic plan The post Conviction is

In Newfoundland, a razor-close election that nobody really 2019-05-16 20:34:03A province in dire need of stable government instead gets a minority, and a likely return to the polls in the near future The post In Newfoundland, a

Newfoundland and Labrador election 2019: Live results 2019-05-16 13:45:40Voters in Newfoundland and Labrador cast their ballots Thursday in what pollsters predicted would be a neck-and-neck contest between the incumbent Lib

Think your election choice is tough? Try being 2019-05-15 15:17:24With debt piling up and the economy in shambles, the parties seem unable to distinguish themselves for Thursday's election. No wonder it's too close

Liberals and NDP race to out-green each other 2019-05-15 07:00:32Politics Insider for May 15: An apology for Norman, what Ontario Liberal MPs want, and steel tariff talks resume The post Liberals and NDP race to ou

Hi sports fans, remember me? It’s the Stanley 2019-05-14 16:03:51With no Canadian teams left and light on star power, a cooking show in Canada is drawing bigger numbers than this year's NHL playoffs The post Hi spo

What’s to like about Instagram ditching ‘likes’ in 2019-05-14 11:23:48Social-media 'influencers' have much to lose from the headline-grabbing experiment. But they like it. They really like it. The post What’s to

Jagmeet Singh scrambles to boost his climate cred 2019-05-14 07:00:08Politics Insider for May 14: Singh goes for Green, the provincial carbon fight continues and Canada gets a Trump admin ally The post Jagmeet Singh scr

Barry and Honey Sherman: Court to unseal estate 2019-05-13 15:58:58More clues may surface in the unsolved murders of the billionaire couple when estate documents are unsealed The post Barry and Honey Sherman: Court to

‘How we treat women’ 2019-05-13 13:35:51Worker camps make it possible to build infrastructure in remote locations. Is it worth the human cost? The post ‘How we treat women’ app

CBC | Canada News

'Price-conscious' pot consumers find backyard planting way cheaper 2019-05-22 04:00:00For the first time, Canadians can legally grow cannabis in their gardens or outdoor planters this spring in every province except Quebec and Manitoba.

Risks vs. rights: Why some experts say it's 2019-05-22 04:00:00As measles cases continue to rise in Canada and the U.S., experts are calling on social media platforms to ban anti-vaccination posts, saying the

Mike Pence is coming to Ottawa — but 2019-05-22 04:00:00U.S. Vice President Mike Pence is coming to Canada next week to meet Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to discuss what the U.S. embassy calls the "s

'An insult': Families of dead soldiers offended at 2019-05-22 04:00:00A number of families who lost loved ones in Afghanistan say they feel betrayed by a decision made by bureaucrats at the Department of National De

Are life-sized murals, MVP chants, free meals (and 2019-05-22 00:17:34The #HeStay movement has been gaining momentum – since day one, Raptors fans have been doing everything they can to keep Kawhi Leonard in the ci

RCMP recover body of Samuel Boucher from water, 2019-05-21 19:26:05The body of Samuel Boucher, one of the three missing travellers in the Northwest Territories, was retrieved from a large area of open water on Mo

Doug Ford met with chorus of boos at 2019-05-21 18:29:01Ontario Premier Doug Ford was met with a chorus of boos and sparse applause as he took the stage at the Collision tech conference on Tuesday &mda

After 6 months of mystery pain, Toronto man 2019-05-21 17:49:00For six long months, John Wright found himself in and out of the emergency room, with confusing, debilitating pain. He was starting to lose hope when

Canada a leader among G20 for plan to 2019-05-21 17:31:35Canada is among the leaders in the world when it comes to phasing out the use of coal for power generation, according to a recent report that shows th

Old Crow, Yukon, declares climate change state of 2019-05-21 17:30:08Officials in the Yukon's most northern community have declared a state of emergency, saying the traditional way of life in Old Crow is under thr

Is access to vegan food a human right? 2019-05-21 15:15:10An Ontario firefighter alleges his human rights were violated when he wasn't provided sufficient vegan food while battling a massive blaze in British

IMF urges Canada not to change policy despite 2019-05-21 14:22:31The International Monetary Fund says household debt in Canada is still too high to pursue policy changes to encourage more activity in housing markets

: Canada

37% in Ipsos poll say immigration is a 2019-05-22 05:00:40Several recent polls show that Canadians themselves are increasingly critical of the country's immigration policies.

An exclusive look at the RCMP’s alleged campaign 2019-05-22 05:00:39"The hallmarks are the same in every case," says lawyer Sebastien Anderson, "the end result is the same: people being forced into this medical disc

Meet the Mounties who allege the RCMP used 2019-05-22 05:00:24Five years ago, the RCMP employment requirements were changed to allow dismissals on the basis of disability.

English Montreal School Board votes to move Galileo 2019-05-21 23:02:05The board voted eight to four in favour of the move in order to make room for the overcrowded French system.

Feds expected to announce plans to buy 2 2019-05-21 22:27:37According to the source, the move is intended to address the Canadian Coast Guard's desperate need for new ships as its current fleet is extremely ol

‘This is what we’ve been missing’: TsuuT’ina Nation 2019-05-21 21:51:42TsuuT'ina Council would like to see the 7 Chiefs Sportsplex host the National Aboriginal Hockey Championship down the road.

Western Canadian First Nations groups making progress in 2019-05-21 21:41:55Indigenous groups from across western Canada say they are nearly ready to put forward an offer to buy the Trans Mountain pipeline expansion project.&n

Cyclist in hospital after being struck by vehicle 2019-05-21 21:35:51The collision happened at around 5:30 p.m. near the intersection of Jarry Street and Joseph-Guibord Avenue. 

City of Montreal honours businessman, philanthropist Charles Bronfman 2019-05-21 21:05:50"Your family and yourself have contributed so much to Montreal that, today, it is now our turn to say thank you,"  said Mayor Valérie Pl

The show must go on: vandalism doesn’t stop 2019-05-21 21:01:34Tommy Douglas Collegiate’s theatre production has been relocated to Centennial Collegiate after an act of vandalism.

Teens allegedly shoot fireworks at each other, into 2019-05-21 20:33:43Toronto police say shooting fireworks into a moving car is assault with a weapon, and also could have caused a serious crash.

Victim who died in suspected carbon monoxide poisoning 2019-05-21 20:10:57The BC Coroners Service is investigating, but police do not believe the death is suspicious.

Canada stories

Dewar May 22, 2019 2019-05-22 02:00:08Sue Dewar

WOLSTAT: Green blocks shots like few other shooting 2019-05-22 00:19:43Danny Green has not shot the ball at his usual level in these playoffs, but still managed the best net rating on the Raptors ahead of Tuesday’s

SIMMONS: Raptors step up for Kawhi in enormous 2019-05-22 00:11:14There will be at least one more game in Toronto — maybe more — for the remarkable Kawhi Leonard as a Raptor. And no one is ready for any o

STINSON: Kawhi gets a little help from his 2019-05-22 00:10:37The Toronto Raptors saved their season on Sunday night. On Tuesday night, they saved it again, and in the most unlikely way imaginable. With Kawhi Leo

Raptors coach explains why Serge Ibaka’s minutes were 2019-05-22 00:00:43For a guy who has stood out rather obviously in just about every playoff win on this run, Serge Ibaka was awfully quiet in the Raptors’ Game 3 w

Raptors’ bench comes up big in Game 4 2019-05-21 23:59:58Remember Toronto’s bench? Yeah, that group that was celebrated, even had their own nickname? Well, it has been a while since anyone did much cel

Stroman finally gets some run support as Blue 2019-05-21 23:22:29Ah, run support. It’s a fickle thing. One game, you have it, then the next 10 you don’t. Welcome to Marcus Stroman’s world. Through

Powerless Marlies fall to Checkers in Game 3, 2019-05-21 23:16:18Chris Mueller and the Toronto Marlies, finally, are staring some post-season adversity in the face. The Marlies, after winning their first eight games

Willy’s worlds leave Leafs fans wondering 2019-05-21 22:24:05William Nylander is playing his most engaged hockey of the season, though it will leave part of Leafs Nation enraged. After a two-month contract dispu

Blue Jays GM Atkins on sitting Vladdy: ‘It’s 2019-05-21 22:22:29It wasn’t me. It’s on the manager. We’ll do better next time, maybe. Those were the takeaways from Blue Jays general manager Ross At

LILLEY: Trudeau’s gun ban idea misses the mark 2019-05-21 20:02:44Are the Trudeau Liberals ready to spend more than $100 million to seize the guns of law abiding gun owners? Certainly sounds like it. This past weeken

Toronto plays host to fast-growing world tech conference 2019-05-21 19:59:26A high-profile technology conference is expected to bring 25,000 people from around the world to Toronto. Taking place in Toronto for the first time,

Vancouver Sun

More than 200 B.C. firefighters sent to Alberta 2019-05-21 20:27:06One out-of-control blaze near High Level, a town located seven and a half hours north of Edmonton, has more forced more than 4,000 residents to flee t

The Higher Brothers make Chinese trap with a 2019-05-21 20:21:59Trap artists The Higher Brothers are at the vanguard of a burgeoning Chinese hip hop scene.

Gridlock, frayed tempers common as people flock to 2019-05-21 19:58:36Politicians calling for more parks and better transit to ease congestion around Metro Vancouver's recreational hot spots

Ian Mulgrew: Jail time for indigent man caught 2019-05-21 19:33:29OPINION: "He was impecunious at the time of the offence and was then relying on ‘social assistance and the food bank.'”

Kelowna toddler seriously hurt in early morning fall 2019-05-21 19:23:37Ministry of Child and Family Development has been notified.

Oil companies may be called to testify under 2019-05-21 19:10:32Independent energy regulator will have the power to call oil company officials as witnesses.

Vancouver hopeful about outcome from moderate-income rental experiment 2019-05-21 18:35:43The program is geared to create some below-market rentals, the catch is the City is allowing big increases in density to get them.

Privacy commissioner says he can't investigate alleged Sims 2019-05-21 18:27:20'Because it’s about the behaviour of a cabinet minister, John Horgan needs to be answering some questions.'

Want to invest in Vancouver commercial property? Here 2019-05-21 18:21:00You don't need to be wealthy to own commercial real estate, and there are more opportunities with the downturns in the Vancouver and Toronto markets.

North Vancouver man has been missing since April 2019-05-21 18:19:28Timothy Marc Delahaye, 29, was last seen on April 29 in Cultus Lake Park

Horse-drawn carriage industry supporters in Victoria plan rally 2019-05-21 14:18:04Supporters of Victoria’s horse-drawn carriages plan a rally after learning city councillors have asked staff to examine phasing them out.

Vancouver two-bedroom apartments now cost close to $3,000: 2019-05-21 14:14:58The average monthly cost of a two-bedroom listing in Vancouver is $2,915, while the average monthly cost of a one-bedroom is $1,828, according to the

Montreal Gazette

C2 Montréal reboots to spark a new wave 2019-05-21 20:27:26The commerce and creativity playground moves to Grandé Studios in Point-St-Charles for its eighth edition, running from May 22 to 24.

41% of our roads are in great shape, 2019-05-21 20:23:03Want to see for yourself? The city’s street-by-street inventory is available online.

Watch: Quebec zoo owner facing animal neglect, cruelty 2019-05-21 19:43:49Animal welfare officials are seizing more than 100 animals from a small zoo in St-Édouard after an investigation found alleged abuse and neglec

For Guy Laliberté, the PY1 pyramid is his 2019-05-21 19:28:18The PY1 Pyramid is the first major public project of Guy Laliberté since he sold his controlling stake in the Cirque du Soleil in 2015.

St-Édouard zookeeper charged with animal cruelty 2019-05-21 18:23:27The zoo's website indicates monkeys, lions and tigers were being kept at the compound.

Quebec transport minister rides the métro, says 'I 2019-05-21 18:05:28After accepting Montreal Mayor Valérie Plante’s invitation to take the Orange Line at rush hour, the minister stands by the CAQ’s t

Canadiens home games to start at 7 p.m. 2019-05-21 17:50:38Starting with the 2019-20 season, all games — except for rare matinees — will be scheduled for 7 p.m. instead of 7:30 p.m.

Allison Hanes: If not the Pink Line, then 2019-05-21 17:16:43After a rush-hour trip on the overcrowded Orange Line, it seems Quebec's transport minister is still not ready to think Pink.

Watch: Trudeau at technology conference in Toronto 2019-05-21 17:16:00Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told spoke to hundreds of attendees at a conference in Toronto on Monday.

What's happening this week 2019-05-21 17:11:13What's happening this week in the West Island and Off-Island.

Watch: Drilling holes in your skull to treat 2019-05-20 14:57:05Scientists in China have developed a new way to battle drug addiction

Old Brewery Mission event raises $307,000 for homeless 2019-05-20 14:44:18"Women who experience homelessness are invisible. They’re rarely spoken about and, unfortunately, the number of homeless women is increasing."


Surrey man charged after allegedly posing as a 2019-05-21 17:18:03Forty-two-year-old Harmit Johal has been charged with one count of personating a peace officer and two counts of fraud.

McMaster University researchers invent way to store vaccines 2019-05-21 16:36:02The research team uses cheap technology that involves the use of a sugary gel that allows for easier, longer shipments of vaccines that typically need

Canada hopeful for Ukraine’s actor-turned-president 2019-05-21 16:35:02Canadian officials say Volodymyr Zelenskiy’s rise to power is more like Newfoundland satirist Rick Mercer getting elected prime minister.

Regulator investigating high gas prices in B.C. has 2019-05-21 15:20:15Gas prices hovering around $1.70 per litre in the Metro Vancouver area have been the highest in Canada for several months.

Search underway off coast of P.E.I. for fisherman 2019-05-21 15:17:15A spokesman with the Joint Rescue Coordination Centre in Halifax said it was notified shortly before 5:30 a.m. that a 22-year-old man was in the water

4-year-old boy drowns in northern Manitoba community 2019-05-21 15:09:00Police say a ground search found the child around 11:30 p.m. Sunday in a bay on St. Theresa Point First Nation.

Witness who lived with Winnipeg man accused in 2019-05-21 15:02:00Holley Sullivan told a jury there were “jealousy issues” among the several women who shared a home with Perez Cleveland, who is accused of

New Brunswick fishermen get $2M to test gear 2019-05-21 14:59:00Crab fishermen in New Brunswick are getting more than $2 million to test technologies aimed at reducing the risks of endangered North Atlantic right w

Feds launch Canadian tourism strategy designed to boost 2019-05-21 14:45:00The plan, which includes $58.5 million in funding, is supposed to back experiences that show off Canada’s strengths — and break visitors&r

Is the right to vegan food a human 2019-05-21 12:27:58Adam Knauff has filed a complaint against his employer, the Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry, over his treatment and subsequent suspension w

Animal welfare advocates move to seize exotic animals 2019-05-21 11:51:57The Montreal branch of the SPCA said Tuesday that St-Edouard zoo owner Normand Trahan faces two charges under the Criminal Code.

Food insecurity grew in Nunavut after federal program 2019-05-21 07:42:55Survey responses showed that the ability of northerners to dependably put food on the table declined significantly during the years Nutrition North wa


Toronto is getting a vegetarian restaurant serving modern 2019-05-21 17:38:03King and Portland has seen a lot of changes recently, and now the restaurant group responsible for Mira and Byblos is opening a new restaurant at 77 P

Toronto restaurants escape global collapse of Jamie Oliver 2019-05-21 17:32:40The Naked Chef might need a new gimmick in the U.K., but thankfully the bottom falling out of Jamie Oliver's restaurant empire won't impact any

Toronto is getting an alternative Pride festival 2019-05-21 17:18:05When it comes to reveling in all things queer, the be all and end all of events has long been Pride Toronto.But a monumental new festival is emer

Rats have completely taken over an alley in 2019-05-21 17:06:02Be it resolved that rats, as individual creatures, are pretty cute. Like raccoons, they're clever, they're furry and they possess preciously dextero

Thousands stranded as TTC shuts down subway service 2019-05-21 15:33:36TTC officials have been holding train service along a major portion of Toronto's Bloor-Danforth subway line for more than an hour now following

Toronto's original lawn games bar is closing 2019-05-21 14:35:56Five years ago, the thought of playing games at a bar other than billiards, darts, or board games was pretty much unheard of. Track & Field in Tor

Win a Budweiser Stage Season's Pass 2019-05-21 14:30:00It's Budweiser Stage's 25th anniversary! To celebrate, we've teamed up with AIR MILES Stage Pass to give one lucky reader a chance t

Toronto teens captured on camera shooting fireworks into 2019-05-21 14:29:12It wouldn't be a Victoria Day weekend in Toronto without at least one ridiculous, firework-related scuffle, and 2019's was no exception.Video footag

Ontario government cuts funding for artificial intelligence research 2019-05-21 12:32:55Another week, another multimillion-dollar funding cut to one of Ontario's most celebrated scientific institutions.Doug Ford's provincial government

Toronto is getting a Las Vegas style magic 2019-05-21 11:47:41Prepare to get razzle dazzled this summer with a new magic series that'll definitely warrant some oohs and aahs. One of Toronto's most popular

It's going to feel like 28 C in 2019-05-21 11:18:58The warm weather seems like it wants to stay, hopefully for good this time. If all goes according to forecast, temperatures are going to sit in t

This Week on DineSafe: Robo Sushi, La Carnita, 2019-05-21 10:56:28This week on DineSafe,we learn that one of Toronto's best Ethiopian restaurants landed a conditional pass upon inspection. When Toronto hea

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.