• Follow us


Andrew Scheer’s Careful Word Choices Irk Anti-Abortion Activist

Federal Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer arrives for a news conference in Toronto, on Aug. 29,

Chris Young/CPFederal Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer arrives for a news conference in Toronto, on Aug. 29, 2019.

OTTAWA — Andrew Scheer’s careful word choices on the abortion question are leading some in the anti-abortion movement to question the Conservative leader’s commitment to their cause.

“If he is going to coerce backbench MPs to not bring forward pro-life bills, then it is a betrayal,” Jack Fonseca of Campaign Life Coalition told HuffPost Canada Thursday.

Scheer sought the support of anti-abortion activists during his 2017 leadership run, saying he wasn’t afraid of debate and that backbenchers would be free to table bills of interest to themselves and their constituents. He promised his caucus free votes on matters of conscience and courted anti-abortion supporters with his positions.

Those voters helped propel Scheer to the leadership.

Watch: Scheer says Conservative government would not reopen debates on abortion, same-sex marriage

On Thursday, however, Scheer told reporters a Conservative government under his leadership would “oppose” measures to reopen the abortion debate. 

“I will not reopen this debate. I will oppose measures or attempts to reopen this debate, and Canadians can have confidence of that,” Scheer said.

Fonseca, who says his group represents 200,000 Canadians, said Scheer “made a statement that he hopes is ambiguous enough that pro-abortion and pro-life people can interpret it as they want.” 

Calling the move “obviously deliberate,” the anti-abortion advocate said the Conservative leader’s comments show “some dishonesty” and “a lack of forthrightness.”

“It is obviously so that socially liberal people can read it that he’s going to come down as a hammer on these backbench MPs, and for the people who want to believe that he is still pro-life, they can read into it that he didn’t say he’s going to block backbench MPs explicitly, so then he’s not going to.

“He is trying to send a different message to both sides,” Fonseca said.

Scheer told reporters Thursday that backbenchers will be free to introduce bills on matters they care about. But his spokesman, Brock Harrison, said the “government’s position on such a vote would be to oppose any attempt to reopen the issue.”

Though “matters of conscience will be free votes,” Harrison said, “Mr. Scheer would certainly expect cabinet to support the government position.”

“Nothing has changed for our party. Our party’s position has always been the same,” Scheer said, referring to the decade of Conservative governments under former prime minister Stephen Harper.

“I, as prime minister, will oppose measures that reopen this issue. That is something that Canadians can be sure of,” he said.

“That statement is deeply troubling to me, Fonseca said, “because it suggests that he will bring the hammer down, or may bring the hammer down, on these backbench MPs to take away their democratic rights by threatening them, by intimidating them and coercing them, or shaming them or having others do it for him, if not he himself, then people from his office or other peers. We’ve seen all these things happen under Stephen Harper.”

Former Conservative MP Stephen Woodworth holds a press conference in Ottawa on April 8, 2014. Woodworth...

Adrian Wyld/CPFormer Conservative MP Stephen Woodworth holds a press conference in Ottawa on April 8, 2014. Woodworth tabled a controversial motion in 2012 to study when life begins.

Under Harper, Tory backbench MPs were technically free to introduce anti-abortion measures and speak out on the issues they cared about, but they were strongly discouraged from doing so.

Harper’s office threatened his MPs — those who brought measures forward and those who voted in favour — with the end of advancement in their careers, Fonseca told HuffPost, information corroborated by former MPs and a PMO staffer.

Cabinet positions, parliamentary secretary posts, committee chairs, “anything that gives them perks or special privileges or salary bumps. That is what Stephen Harper did on Mark Warawa’s sex-selective abortion motion and on Stephen Woodworth’s M-312,” Fonseca said, referring to Woodworth’s motion to study the legal definition of when life begins. (Warawa’s motion, M-408, was deemed non-votable by his peers but was later abandoned because of the backlash.)

“It speaks to the desire for power, that he is willing to be so ambiguous and to send mixed signals and if he is so willing to do that now, it may mean that he is willing to stifle the democratic rights of backbench MPs later on.” 

Anti-abortion bills, motions tabled during Harper years

Under Harper, the Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada says, six anti-abortion bills or motions were tabled in Parliament. Although none became law, Bill C-484, the Unborn Victims of Crime Act — legislation to amend the Criminal Code to open the door to recognizing fetal rights — passed second reading in 2008, with Harper, Scheer, and a majority of the Tory bench voting in favour. It was sent to committee for further study but died a few months later when Parliament was suspended and Canadians sent to the polls. 

In 2010, Conservative MP Rod Bruinooge introduced Bill C-510, legislation that made it a criminal offence to coerce or attempt to coerce a pregnant woman into having an abortion. That bill was defeated in the minority parliament, although a majority of the Conservative caucus supported it, with 87 Tories, including Scheer, voting in favour, and 49, including most members of Harper’s cabinet, voting against. 

In 2012, when Scheer was Speaker of the House of Commons, Conservative MP Stephen Woodworth introduced a private motion, M-312, to form a special committee to study the rights of a fetus and when life officially begins, with an eye to  changing the Criminal Code’s definition of a human being. That motion was also defeated 203-91, with 86 Tories, a slight majority, voting in favour and 74 voting against.

Although Harper may have tried to block measures to reopen the abortion debate, perhaps most famously by preventing Warawa from speaking in the Commons, his government stopped providing aid to groups that fund abortions overseas. 

Alissa Golob, co-founder of the anti-abortion group Right Now, said her group believes in incremental change and supporting candidates who can move the needle towards ending abortion. She believes criticizing a party leader who can move the agenda forward, as Fonseca is doing, is counterproductive.

Watch: Conservative party can’t ‘shut out’ anti-abortion supporters: activist

“Well, we don’t know what he means when he says ‘oppose,’” she told HuffPost. “Even though Harper maybe disagreed with some types of legislation, he voted in favour of some pro-life bills, and there were multiple pro-life bills that were put forward under Harper so, as Scheer said at the press conference, it’s a big-tent party and politicians have that right to put forward issues that are important to them.”

Scheer is only one voting member of caucus, she said, and there are 338 MPs. “As long as he upholds that promise [to allow backbenchers to introduce legislation], then we are totally OK with that and we will continue on with our work,” she said.

Right Now is actively working to elect Conservative candidates who support anti-abortion policies. Golob said her non-partisan group is not working with People’s Party of Canada, whose leader, Maxime Bernier, has promised free votes on abortion matters, because Right Now is focused on candidates who are “electable.” 

On Thursday, Scheer blamed the Liberals for dredging up the abortion issue and his past comments on same-sex marriage as a distraction from the Grits’ four-year record. Though some of the wounds this week on the abortion issue have been self-inflicted, the Liberals and abortion rights activists have voiced concerns at every election since the Conservative Party of Canada was formed in 2003 that a Tory majority might enact abortion restrictions in Canada. So far, no laws have been passed.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

Top Travel stories

CRIME HUNTER: Horror show on the Hippie Trail 2019-09-14 13:59:56The breathtaking setting was a vista of love in the heady 1970s. She met him in trippy, hash-fuelled Kashmir in 1975. It was a golden time. A small ar

WHO? WHAT? WOW! The week in WEIRD 2019-09-14 13:49:45SHE MASTURBATES 400 TIMES A DAY! A 19-year-old American woman had to turn to sex-packed webcam performances to curb her 400 times a day masturbation f

FOUL BALLS: When MLB cancelled ’94 World Series 2019-09-14 13:47:21The sound was not a slab of ash violently colliding with horsehide. It was heartache. In the dustbin, all that was left of the 1994 baseball season wa

GOLDSTEIN: Trudeau’s immigration policies alarm many Canadians 2019-09-14 13:33:50Thus far in the federal election campaign, the issue of immigration has been debated mainly by not talking about it. Two of the biggest “media&r

EDITORIAL: Noise control bylaws need to be enforced 2019-09-14 13:10:52Toronto can have all the noise abatement laws it wants, but if they’re not effectively enforced they’re not worth the paper they’re

Spicing things up in Grenada 2019-09-14 12:57:47Grenada may call itself the “Spice Isle,” but this lush, mountainous tri-island state in the southernmost edge of the Caribbean turns up t

THE WAY WE WERE: Murdoch Mysteries a reflection 2019-09-14 12:48:56“What have you, George” — Detective William Murdoch In all the years I’ve been contributing this column to the Toronto Sun (th

TRAIKOS: Leafs’ salary imbalance a problem if cap 2019-09-14 12:35:05Here’s a stat for you. Now that Mitch Marner has finally agreed to a six-year contract worth $65.358-million, there are now 13 players in the Na

TIFF 19: The biggest winners and losers at 2019-09-14 12:17:38The Toronto International Film Festival wraps Sunday with one film taking home the coveted Grolsch People’s Choice Award. Winners of the prize h

Kaillie Humphries sues Bobsleigh Canada for $15 million, 2019-09-14 11:59:44Veteran driver Kaillie Humphries is suing Bobsleigh Canada Skeleton for $15 million, claiming she can no longer compete for her country because her wo

Dolighan Sept. 14, 2019 2019-09-14 02:00:52Tim Dolighan

Bo Bichette hits walkoff homer as Jays top 2019-09-14 00:46:24There was a big (young) man on campus on Friday, with one of Toronto’s top prospects on hand to watch the Blue Jays top the New York Yankees in

Canada Travel - The

What’s The Difference Between A Sovereignist and Separatist 2019-09-13 19:29:42A star Green candidate’s comments about his unabashed support for Quebec sovereignty, and Green Party Leader Elizabeth May’s response, has

Ontario Dental Hygienist Who Treated His Wife Stripped 2019-09-13 19:13:58TORONTO — A dental hygienist branded as a sexual abuser and stripped of his licence because he treated his wife has lost his bid to have the pun

More Canadian Expats Registered To Vote Than Ever 2019-09-13 17:29:39OTTAWA — More expatriate Canadians than ever before have registered to vote in this federal election, HuffPost Canada has learned.Nearly 20,000

Cory Booker Invokes Justin Trudeau's Hair To Make 2019-09-13 17:20:05Justin Trudeau was mentioned briefly during a U.S. Democratic presidential debate Thursday — or more specifically his hair was. The Democra

Scheer’s 'Tax Free' Maternity Leave Election Promise Is 2019-09-13 13:59:05TORONTO — Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer’s campaign promise that he will make maternity and parental leave benefits “tax free&rdq

Scheer Promises To Bring Back Public Transit Tax 2019-09-13 13:48:57MISSISSAUGA, Ont. — Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer is promising to bring back the public transit tax credit, which the party says is part of

Brad Blair Sues Doug Ford, Staff For Wrongful 2019-09-13 13:34:51TORONTO — A former deputy commissioner of the Ontario Provincial Police is suing Premier Doug Ford and top staff for wrongful termination, abuse

RCMP Charges Staffer Under Official Secrets Law 2019-09-13 13:26:26OTTAWA — The RCMP has charged one of its own with several offences under Canada’s official-secrets law.The national police force says Came

Canadian Bobsledder Kaillie Humphries Wants To Compete For 2019-09-13 11:58:09Kaillie Humphries, a two-time Olympic bobsled gold medallist for Canada and one of the top drivers in her sport’s history, is planning to race f

Ontario Jaywalker Goes Headfirst Into Pole Right After 2019-09-13 11:20:42Why did the jaywalker cross the road? To get hit with some karma on the other side. A new compilation clip posted on a YouTube channel dedicated

Outdoor Play Is Essential For Kids' Health, Even 2019-09-13 10:59:24Parents just want their children to be safe — to make it out of childhood, and all the scary things that threaten it, unscathed and in one

Spending 'Stress' Test Could Help Canada's Millennials Rein 2019-09-13 10:55:18Millennials are doing most of the borrowing as Canadian consumer debt rapidly heads towards the $2-trillion mark. But what if you had to pass a test p

Breaking Travel News

News: Etihad re-launches website to meet needs of 2019-09-13 03:01:54Etihad Airways has re-launched etihad.com, with the refreshed website now live globally in 16 languages. Redesigned from scratch, guests visiting etih

News: Higgins Hotel & Conference Centre to open 2019-09-13 02:42:47The National WWII Museum in New Orleans has announced the upcoming opening of its signature Hotel, the Higgins Hotel & Conference Centre, Curio Co

News: New senior leadership team for Cendyn 2019-09-13 02:28:47Cendyn is the leading innovative cloud software and services provider for the hospitality industry. With a focus on integrated hotel CRM, hotel sales,

News: JetBlue unveils plans for new Guyana service 2019-09-13 02:16:50JetBlue has announced it is expanding its large Latin America and Caribbean network with a new non-stop service between New York’s John F. Kenne

News: Quinn to join Uniworld Boutique River Cruise 2019-09-12 07:44:06Uniworld Boutique River Cruise Collection and U River Cruises have appointed Dawn Quinn as their latest key account manager in the UK. She will join a

News: Bin Hussein to lead Andaz Dubai the 2019-09-12 07:32:10No stranger to the Hyatt family, Kifah Bin Hussein brings 22 years’ experience working with the hotel group, having held roles in multiple mana

Focus: Where to visit when traveling in Philadelphia? 2019-09-12 06:56:13Philadelphia is the 5th largest city in the United States. The place is considered an important cultural, educational and historical center of the nat

Focus: Useful Tips For Travelers Visiting Indonesia 2019-09-12 05:13:33Indonesia is an incredibly beautiful country made up of over 17,000 breathtaking islands. The enchanting landscaping is most of the reason thousands o

News: easyJet prepares for busiest ever day 2019-09-12 05:11:31easyJet is set to welcome over 332,000 passengers on Friday – making it the busiest day in the airline’s history. More than 1,972 flights

News: Moxy NYC East Village opens to first 2019-09-12 05:08:37Moxy NYC East Village opens today in the heart of the iconic East Village where rock ‘n’ roll, renegade art, LGBTQ+ activism, and generati

News: YTL Hotels signs with Marriott to bring 2019-09-12 05:03:04YTL Hotels and Marriott International have signed a master development agreement to bring the AC Hotels by Marriott brand to Malaysia for the first ti

News: Vodaphone brings 5G technology to Gatwick Airport 2019-09-12 05:00:42Passengers at Gatwick Airport can now experience the faster speeds and greater reliability of 5G thanks to Vodafone. This means they can enjoy gaming


Bird watchers, nature lovers find sanctuary at oasis 2019-09-12 23:15:26The Swan Lake Christmas Hill Nature Sanctuary, located in the heart of Greater Victoria’s urban landscape, is home to up to four dozen native fl

Wide-eyed in Zambia: Great Migration offers the greatest 2019-09-12 12:47:00Exhilarated. Over the moon. And cautious. A safari lodge is a thousand times better than any zoo, but you — not the animals — are the ones

Fishing for a more genuine experience in Portugal? 2019-09-12 12:21:17Not only is Setubal more affordable than Lisbon, its mix of seafood delights and sightseeing is ‘more authentic and close to nature’.

Vestlandet, Norway, is ‘oh, my god’ country 2019-09-12 11:05:15Norway is a solo traveller’s playground: with no one to appease, make decisions on the fly and savour the revelatory moments.

Alberta wilderness park making comeback from 2017 Kenow 2019-09-11 23:36:08The Waterton fires wiped out 38,000 hectares of land, but the park on the Alberta-Montana border is now healing.

Ontario museum offers 3D tour of large Indigenous 2019-09-05 12:31:23Visitors to the museum in Whitchurch-Stouffville can experience a virtual reality tour of the archeological site that’s described as a significa

‘Unpretentious’ Philadelphia offers history, food, culture and Rocky 2019-09-05 11:51:22The city, founded in 1682 by William Penn, a Quaker from England, remains a beacon for history and art buffs wanting to look into the past.

Virgin Galactic gives inside look to new spaceport 2019-09-04 22:11:07On display were two floors dedicated to space flight operations but also customer spaces. The company said the facility is now operational.

Dirty little secrets of doing hand laundry on 2019-09-04 22:00:07Too cheap to send out my laundry, too time-strapped to sit in a self-service laundry, I resorted to the sink, cool water and a Tide detergent pod.

Five tips for scoring housesitting gigs that will 2019-09-04 21:53:07If you’re looking for an inexpensive way to travel, and don’t mind picking up a few responsibilities in exchange, here’s advice from

For Nordic charm across the Baltic Sea, try 2019-09-04 21:47:06Tallinn, the capital of Estonia, which regained its independence from the Soviet Union in 1991, is as Nordic as it gets without being a Scandinavian c

Seven Florida boat tours: The classic way to 2019-09-04 21:19:06On a floating getaway, you can reach places where there are no roads and catch views you can’t see any other way. Some of the boats themselves a

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.