• Follow us

Politics

Trump administration targets mental health institutions as answer to gun violence

When shots rang out last year at a high school in Parkland, Florida, leaving 17 people dead, President Donald Trump quickly turned his thoughts to creating more mental institutions.

When back-to-back mass shootings in Dayton, Ohio, and El Paso, Texas, jolted the nation earlier this month, Trump again spoke of “building new facilities” for the mentally ill as a way to reduce mass shootings.

“We don’t have those institutions anymore and people can’t get proper care,” Trump lamented at a New Hampshire campaign rally not long after the latest shootings.

WATCH: Parkland survivors reveal anti-gun violence plan

Story continues below

Now, in response to Trump’s concerns, White House staff members are looking for ways to incorporate the president’s desire for more institutions into a long list of other measures aimed at reducing gun violence.

It’s the latest example of White House policy aides scrambling to come up with concrete policies or proposals to fill out ideas tossed out by the president. And it’s an idea that mental health professionals say reflects outdated thinking on the treatment of mental illness.

Trump sometimes harks back to his earlier years in New York to explain his thinking on preventing future mass shootings. He recently recalled to reporters how mentally ill people ended up on the streets and in jails in New York after the state closed large psychiatric hospitals in the 1960s and 1970s.

“Even as a young guy, I said, ‘How does that work? That’s not a good thing,”’ Trump said.

WATCH: ‘We have work to do!’: Philadelphia politician expresses frustration with inaction on gun violence

As the White House looks for ways to fight gun violence, officials have looked at Indiana as one potential model in addressing mental illness.

The state opened a new 159-bed psychiatric hospital in March, Indiana’s first in more than 50 years. The hospital is focused on treating patients with the most challenging psychiatric illnesses and then moving them into treatment settings within the community or state mental health system.

Plans for the hospital were announced when Vice-President Mike Pence was the state’s governor.

“Our prisons have become the state’s largest mental health provider,” Pence said in 2015. “Today, that begins to change.”

READ MORE: Guns, gangs and drugs continue to drive increasing Regina crime stats

But Trump’s support for new “mental institutions” is drawing pushback from many in the mental health profession who say that approach would do little to reduce mass shootings in the United States and incorrectly associates mental illness with violence.

Paul Gionfriddo, president and chief executive of the advocacy group Mental Health America, said Trump is pursuing a 19th century solution to a 21st century problem.

“Anybody with any sense of history understands they were a complete failure. They were money down the drain,” said Gionfriddo.

The number of state hospital beds that serve the nation’s most seriously ill patients has fallen from more than 550,000 in the 1950s to fewer than 38,000 in the first half of 2016, according to a survey from the Treatment Advocacy Center, which seeks policies to overcome barriers to treatment.

John Snook, the group’s executive director, said Trump’s language “hasn’t been helpful to the broader conversation.” But he said the president has hit on an important problem — a shortage of beds for the serious mentally ill.

READ MORE: Province provides Toronto police $3M to double CCTV cameras to combat gun violence

“There are headlines every day in almost every newspaper talking about the consequences of not having enough hospital beds, huge numbers of people in jails, homelessness and ridiculously high treatment costs because we’re trying to help people in crisis care,” Snook said.

While Snook is not advocating a return to the 1950s, when there were 337 state hospital beds per 100,000 people in the U.S., he says states went too far in reducing facilities. He said the 2016 level of 11.7 beds per 100,000 people is inadequate.

Gionfriddo agreed more resources for the mentally ill are needed, but said any beds added should go to local, general hospitals, where patients would receive care for a full range of physical and mental illnesses.

That will require more federal money and loosening Medicaid’s restrictions on mental health funding, he said. The first part is highly unlikely in the current fiscal environment, with the federal government expected to run a $1 trillion deficit in the next fiscal year.

WATCH: Where Canada’s political party leaders stand on gun control changes

But the administration has taken steps on the second part of the equation. A longstanding federal law has barred Medicaid from paying for mental health treatment in facilities with more than 16 beds to prevent “warehousing” of the mentally ill at the expense of federal taxpayers.

The administration in recent months said it will allow states to seek waivers from that restriction, provided they can satisfy certain requirements. Such waivers often take years to wind their way through the regulatory process.

The National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors has a different suggestion. After the El Paso and Dayton shootings, it recommended that Congress add $35 million for a block grant program to help states provide more community-based care to people in a mental health crisis.

When he ran for president, Trump issued a position paper on his gun positions that was more in line with what many mental health experts say: “We need to expand treatment programs, because most people with mental health problems aren’t violent, they just need help,” the paper said. “But for those who are violent, a danger to themselves or others, we need to get them off the street before they can terrorize our communities.”

WATCH: Bulletproof backpacks latest U.S. back-to-school necessity

Marvin Swartz, a professor in psychiatry at Duke University, said research has shown that even if society were to cure serious mental illness, total violence would decline by only about 4 per cent. He said he’s seen no evidence that more psychiatric beds would reduce mass homicides or individual homicides.

“It would be a good thing to have more treatment resources, but the effect on gun violence would be minuscule,” Swartz said.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

: Politics

Senate incidents involving pro-oil and gas shirts highlight New! 2019-09-17 14:45:12Twice this month, visitors to parliament buildings were asked to remove items of clothing sporting the slogan "I love Canadian Oil and Gas."

NDP, Greens pledge to improve access to health New! 2019-09-17 12:58:51Meanwhile, the Liberal party said 'a lot of hard work still needs to be done — including in the realm of access to health care.'

Greens pledge to regulate tech giants to ensure New! 2019-09-17 12:14:51Is it possible for a government to enact this type of regulation, and would it actually address the problems the Greens have referenced? Global News a

Tories pledge to increase federal contribution to RESP New! 2019-09-17 10:48:00The increase would come on top of the existing federal grants for low and middle-income families.

Jagmeet Singh pledges to build 500,000 new affordable New! 2019-09-17 09:39:50Leader Jagmeet Singh didn't provide details on how he would achieve that goal, saying only that he will have more announcements about it.

Trudeau vows to boost Canada Child Benefit, make 2019-09-17 09:07:53Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau is promising to make maternity and parental benefits tax-free if his party is re-elected in October.

Election campaign Day 7: Leaders focus on childcare, 2019-09-17 08:06:42Some of the federal party leaders are getting early starts as Day 7 of the federal election campaign begins.

Liberal denial of ‘hidden’ capital gains tax hike 2019-09-17 07:30:07The Conservatives have seized on a ``policy proposal'' report written last November by Toronto Liberal MP Adam Vaughan for the Ontario Liberal caucu

ANALYSIS: Jagmeet Singh’s crucial Quebec launch lacks exposure 2019-09-17 07:00:18NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh is in the fight of his party's life in Quebec, yet he only attended four events as he launched a province-specific platform.

‘A really tight race’: Conservatives, Liberals locked in 2019-09-17 05:00:49Darrell Bricker, CEO of Ipsos, said no party really has any momentum, which is unusual given the campaign is well underway.

First days of election campaigns marked by candidate 2019-09-13 19:56:52Party leaders have had to contend with their candidates' past social media posts and lives.

Analysis: A Scheer victory does not guarantee carbon 2019-09-13 19:47:20In a Conservative led minority government, Andrew Scheer would likely face major roadblocks if he attempted to repeal the carbon tax.

CBC | Politics News

NDP's Singh seeks urban support with housing billions, New! 2019-09-17 14:14:15​​​​​​​Jagmeet Singh continued his push to win progressive votes on Tuesday by promising an NDP government w

Scheer vows to boost federal contributions to Registered New! 2019-09-17 11:59:35Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer said Tuesday a government led by him would contribute more money to Registered Education Savings Plans (RESPs) &mdas

RCMP head says allies concerned, but supportive in New! 2019-09-17 11:38:09RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucki said today the national police force is working to limit security risks among Canada's intelligence allies and as

Scheer's proposed tax cut isn't 'universal' — but New! 2019-09-17 10:54:19The Conservative Party's pitch to cut the rate on the lowest income tax bracket is a central promise of its campaign. The move ultimately would benef

In some battleground ridings, renters spend 50% or New! 2019-09-17 10:00:00Housing affordability is poised to be a major ballot box issue in the upcoming federal election, with a sizeable portion of renters in some of th

Liberals pledge to boost Canada Child Benefit, extend 2019-09-17 08:48:11The Liberals are promising a suite of family-friendly benefits, including a boost to the Canada Child Benefit for babies and a 15-week leave program f

Green leader gets stuck in the sands of 2019-09-17 04:00:18Elizabeth May likens the fight against climate change to the Dunkirk evacuations. But historians say she has many of her facts wrong.

Ortis case linked to Vancouver firm that supplied 2019-09-17 04:00:00The investigation into top RCMP official Cameron Ortis began with a shadowy Vancouver-based company and a multimillion-dollar business

Bernier's in — and the federal election debates 2019-09-17 04:00:00The stage is set for Maxime Bernier. His challenge now is to perform.

Where the party leaders are on Day 7 2019-09-17 04:00:00Here's what you need to know about where the federal leaders are on Day 7 of the campaign.

Here are the tools you need to follow 2019-09-17 04:00:00All the tools and resources you'll need to follow the campaign, from fact checks to spotting "fake news."

Canadian law can't punish some peacekeepers for sex 2019-09-16 19:00:00CBC obtained hundreds of pages of internal documents, memos and emails from Global Affairs Canada that confirm that six peacekeepers who were found to

Breitbart News

'President Swalwell': Corey Lewandowski Mocks Failed Presidential Candidate New! 2019-09-17 18:51:34Corey Lewandowski took a jab at failed presidential candidate Rep. Eric Swalwell (D-CA) Tuesday during his testimony before the House Judiciary Commit

WATCH--Corey Lewandowski While Being Questioned: 'I’m the Good New! 2019-09-17 18:36:04Corey Lewandowski packed several punches as he testified before the House Judiciary Committee on Tuesday, with one of which he called himself the "go

Obama on Climate Kid Greta Thunberg: 'One of New! 2019-09-17 18:18:25Former President Barack Obama praised 16-year-old climate activist Greta Thunberg as "one of our planet's greatest advocates" in a Tuesday afternoo

Orrin Hatch Contradicts Joe Biden's Claims About Believing New! 2019-09-17 18:14:57One of Joe Biden's longtime Senate colleagues is contradicting claims the former vice president recently made about having believed Anita Hill during

Speier: I'd Slap Lewandowski with an Inherent Contempt New! 2019-09-17 18:07:28On Tuesday’s broadcast of CNN’s “The Lead,” Representative Jackie Speier (D-CA) stated that if she was in charge of the House

NBC Poll: Biden, Warren Leading Democrat Field by New! 2019-09-17 18:06:07Joe Biden (D) and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) are separating themselves from the rest of the Democrat field by double digits, according to an NBC/WSJ

Explosion Starts Fire at Cold War-Era Lab Housing New! 2019-09-17 17:58:49An explosion occurred Monday night at a Russian biological research laboratory where samples of the smallpox virus are stored, reports said. 

Progressives Attack 'Remain in Mexico' Program for Migrants New! 2019-09-17 17:54:12DHS is showcasing the new border courtrooms created to handle asylum claims by more than 40,000 migrants who were sent back to Mexico, as pro-migratio

Behind the General Motors Autoworkers Strike: Economic Power New! 2019-09-17 17:18:13The strike by workers at General Motors plants across the country is the clearest demonstration of a shift in the U.S. economy that began nearly two y

Book: Sheryl Sandberg Helped Kavanaugh Accuser New! 2019-09-17 17:11:15The upcoming book on Brett Kavanaugh from Robin Pogrebin and Kate Kelly has more to offer than smears and fake news traps for the New Y

Chinese Media: American Democracy Is an ‘Outdated Fantasy’ New! 2019-09-17 17:10:46China’s state-run Global Times on Monday took the occasion of the International Day of Democracy to scoff at the image of the United States as a

Poll: Joe Biden Tops Democrat Presidential Field in New! 2019-09-17 16:48:56Former Vice President Joe Biden (D) is leading the field in New York's Democrat primary, according to a Siena College poll conducted days before

Politics – Macleans.ca

A black mark on the federal election campaign New! 2019-09-17 14:36:08Election Image of the Day: A Liberal in New Brunswick is one of three candidates whose signs are defaced with swastikas The post A black mark on the f

338Canada: The very long odds for the PPC New! 2019-09-17 10:17:35Philippe J. Fournier: The debate commission ruled Bernier's party has a legitimate shot at winning more than one seat. The 338Canada model suggests n

Official debates now at Max capacity 2019-09-17 07:00:00Politics Insider for Sept. 17: Bernier invited to debates, Trudeau 'supports' the CBC and the Liberals and Conservatives fight over who's got more

The case for (some) Max Bernier in the 2019-09-16 21:28:43Stephen Maher: By meeting the organizer's threshold, the PPC leader earned his ticket—but it shouldn't extend to equal air time on our TVs as

It says here that Andrew Scheer should try 2019-09-16 18:32:24Election Image of the Day: A comically contrived photo-op reflects the state of the campaign: reduced to scripted platitudes about the middle class Th

Let’s retire the ‘abortion debate’ in Election 43 2019-09-16 17:57:42Anne Kingston: Focus on a mythical debate has a serious consequence: it ignores the larger sweep of social conservative policies promoted by anti-abor

Are Canadians being left behind or benefiting from 2019-09-16 15:19:49For this election, it’s both. There is evidence that people's partisan identification changes the way they see changing economic conditions. Th

Is that a Conservative campaigner calling, or a 2019-09-16 13:54:16Stephen Maher: The party is using pre-recorded voice actors and a controversial technology that the Liberals abandoned at the last moment The post Is

Who lost the last election again? 2019-09-16 11:46:40As the 2019 campaign gets rolling, consider what made the 2015 election so unusual—results that were more than acceptable for all three major pa

Trudeau: No questions please, I’m campaigning 2019-09-16 07:00:45Politics Insider for Sept. 16: Foreign policy messes, apologizing Tories and Scheer's tax cut pledges cost big The post Trudeau: No questions please,

This week’s 338Canada projection: A look at where 2019-09-15 19:06:20Philippe J. Fournier: The poll average shows an incredibly close race at the top, but no consensus on where NDP support stands The post This week&rsqu

Maclean’s-Citytv National Leaders Debate 2019: Full transcript 2019-09-13 15:50:42Here's everything Elizabeth May, Jagmeet Singh and Andrew Scheer said during the Maclean's-Citytv #firstdebate The post Maclean’s-Citytv Natio

CTVNews.ca - Politics -

Scheer pressed on abortion debate on campaign trail 2019-09-12 11:54:00Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer’s first stop on the second day of the federal election campaign was preoccupied by the ongoing abortion debate

Two NDP candidates resign at start of federal 2019-09-12 11:31:00Two NDP candidates have resigned at the start of the federal election campaign, one because of domestic abuse allegations he denies and the other over

Liberals get new campaign plane after collision with 2019-09-12 01:33:00An unwrapped Air Transat plane will temporarily replace Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau’s election-branded aircraft, after a media bus hit and dam

338 ridings, 40 days, 1 vote: Election campaign 2019-09-11 08:24:00Justin Trudeau has set in motion the 2019 federal election campaign, setting up his re-election bid as a choice for forward progress, while his oppone

Greens clarify abortion stance after May says she 2019-09-09 20:50:00The Green Party says there is 'zero chance' that any of its members would attempt to reopen the abortion debate in the House of Commons, issuing the

'Friends of Science' thanks Elections Canada for warning 2019-09-09 17:52:00A Calgary organization that argues climate change is nothing close to a global emergency says Elections Canada is right to keep a close eye on campaig

Waiting for the election to be called: Pre-campaign 2019-09-09 17:32:00While it may seem that the election campaign has begun, with parties exchanging partisan attacks and unveiling their ads, slogans, and in some cases c

Quebec, Ontario first targets in launch of Conservative 2019-09-09 15:23:00The federal Conservatives will formally launch their federal election campaign Wednesday with two events in places where they aim to increase their su

Everything you need to know about the 2019 2019-09-09 12:00:00Here's how you can watch, listen, and engage with the two official leaders' debates in the 2019 election campaign.

AFN outlines 2019 federal election priorities 2019-09-09 10:35:00The Assembly of First Nations has outlined what it views as the key election 2019 priorities for federal parties and candidates. Among the top commitm

Trudeau and Vancouver's mayor talk housing, transit and 2019-08-30 14:17:18Prime Minister Justin Trudeau touted his government's record on some of the most sensitive issues facing Vancouver as he met with Mayor Kennedy Stewa

Lawyer for suspended public servant requests delay in 2019-08-30 11:42:08A lawyer for a federal public servant accused of leaking cabinet secrets about a $700-million shipbuilding project is asking for a delay in the case u


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.