• Follow us


Housing affordability: What has the Trudeau government done for you?

In 1980 the average price of a house in Canada was five times the average income. Today, it’s around 10 times.

Renters aren’t faring much better. According to a recent report, the minimum wage it takes to afford a two-bedroom unit has risen from just over $17 per hour in the 1990s to $20 an hour after adjusting for inflation — and that’s excluding the private, and much pricier, condominium rental market.

WATCH: By the numbers — renting compared to owning

Housing affordability was part of the Liberal Party’s 2015 campaign pitch to the middle class.

“Today, one in four Canadian households is paying more than it can afford for housing, and one in eight cannot find affordable housing that is safe, suitable, and well maintained,” reads the Liberals’ platform from the last federal election.

Justin Trudeau promised a series of measures to help turn that ship around, including more public funding to build affordable housing units, refurbish existing ones and a “review” of skyrocketing home prices in markets like Toronto and Vancouver.

*Note: Home prices and incomes in the chart below are in 2017 dollars.

Story continues below

After nearly four years of Liberal government, here’s a look at some of the government’s major initiatives and how they’ve fared:

For homebuyers:The mortgage stress test

What it is: 

The mortgage stress test is arguably the best-known housing measure of the Trudeau government. The news rules, which were implemented in two phases between 2016 and 2018, established stricter standards for federally-regulated lenders to vet Canadians applying for a mortgage.

The regulations are an attempt to rein in household debt loads by vetting borrowers against interest rates higher than the mortgage rate offered by their bank. This effectively imposes a lower cap on the maximum mortgage amount a given borrower can obtain, which has forced some prospective buyers to settle for less expensive homes or to postpone purchases in order to save for a bigger down payment.

The first iteration of the stress test came into effect in October 2016 and applied only to Canadians seeking a mortgage with a down payment smaller than 20 per cent of the home value, which requires government-backed housing insurance. The test checks whether a borrower would be able to keep up with mortgage payments based on the greater of their contractual rate or a benchmark interest rate set by the Bank of Canada, which is usually far higher than the rates offered by many lenders.

In January 2018, the government rolled out similar rules for buyers with down payment of 20 per cent or more, covering so-called uninsured mortgages. The bar for these borrowers is either the Bank of Canada’s benchmark rate or their contractual rate plus two percentage points, whichever is greater.

READ MORE: With fixed rates below variable ones, mortgage market is in the Upside Down

Did the stress test calm the housing market?

Buying a house still looks like a pipe dream for Canadians with middling incomes in Vancouver and Toronto and has become more of a stretch in places like Montreal. But since around 2017, the national home price growth has slowed down considerably, with property values falling in many of B.C.’s priciest markets.

In other words, things aren’t great, but they’re definitely less bad than if homes had kept appreciating at the rate did were in 2016.

Did the mortgage stress test do that?

The answer is tricky because the implementation of the federal rules overlapped with provincial and local measures that also aimed at taming runaway prices in B.C. and Ontario. Beijing’s imposition of tougher checks on money moving abroad likely also played a role, by making it harder for wealthy Chinese investors to buy property in places like Vancouver.

Still, the tighter federal mortgage regulations were “100-per cent a factor” in pulling the brakes on a real estate market, according to Toronto mortgage broker Robert McLister.

“When you have an engine that runs too hot, it blows up,” said McLister, who is also the founder of mortgage rates comparisons site RateSpy.com.

The mortgage stress test “was appropriate, it did its job. It wasn’t too much tightening,” McLister said.

READ MORE: Most boomers likely won’t downsize for another 20 years — too late for millennials

But Thomas Davidoff, professor and housing expert at UBC’s Sauder School of Business, won’t go as far as to say the stress test was the main factor that turned things around.

Both in Vancouver and Toronto, it was the most expensive section of the real estate markets — detached homes worth upwards of $1 million — that saw the biggest impact on prices, suggesting that provincial and local measures targeting real estate investors may played a bigger role, Davidoff said.

WATCH: Is too much of your wealth tied up in real estate?

The First-Time Home Buyer’s Incentive

What it is: After tightening the screws on the mortgage market, the Trudeau government introduced the First-Time Home Buyer Incentive in the 2019 budget, billing it as an effort to help cash-strapped buyers afford their first home.

The program, which launches on Sept. 2, allows homebuyers to take out a smaller mortgages with lower monthly payments thanks to a government-funded down payment top-up of up to 10 per cent of the price of a new home. The incentive comes in the form of a second mortgage with no interest and no regular payments. Homeowners can repay the loan at any time with no pre-payment penalty, but the loan becomes due after 25 years or when you sell the home.

The amount to pay back is based on the value of the home at repayment.  For example, say you buy a new home for $200,000 with a 10 per cent incentive from the government of 20,000 dollars. After a few years, you sell the house for 220,000 dollars. You now have to repay the incentive as 10 per cent of the current home value, or $22,000. On the other hand, if your home price went down, and you sold the house for, say, $180,000, the government would take a loss. You’d have to repay just 18,000 dollars.

Still, Global News calculations suggest that, over a 25-year period, you may have to pay back to the government more than you’d save in mortgage payments through the program, even assuming modest home price appreciation.

In order to qualify for the incentive, you must have an annual income of no more than $120,000, while the maximum mortgage amount is capped at four times your income plus the incentive amount. That means the most expensive home you can hope to buy under the plan would be worth somewhere around $500,000, depending on the size of your down payment.

READ MORE: Is the First-Time Home Buyer Incentive a good deal for homebuyers?

Will this help homebuyers?

James Laird, a Toronto mortgage broker at CanWise Financial and co-founder of Ratehub Inc., doesn’t see any upsides for buyers.

“I can’t really think of a single buyer for whom this offer would be attractive,” Laird told Global News when details of the incentive were revealed in June.

Laird also pointed out the program imposes a mortgage cap that is even lower than that built into the mortgage stress test. But homebuyers who don’t want to borrow the maximum the would qualify for under the current federal rules can simply opt for a smaller property, without taking out a complicated loan from the government, Laird said.

But Heather Tremain, CEO of the Toronto housing non-profit Options for Homes, has a different take.

“I think it’s a good program,” she told Global News. “It is designed to have an impact but not to undermine the work that was done bringing in the stress test.”

The incentive, she added, is meant for buyers who wouldn’t otherwise be able to purchase a home.

“If someone can get into ownership at the same cost as their rental then there’s the advantage that they’re building equity over time,” she said.

And that, she added, can open all kinds of opportunities: “You’re building a nest egg for your retirement, you [can] refinance against it for something like your children’s education or other things, you can use a home as collateral for your business.”

At the same time, the program’s implicit low price cap means it won’t  stimulate demand in already pricey real estate markets like Toronto and Vancouver, she said. Instead, the incentive will likely appeal to prospective homebuyers in smaller urban centres, she added.

WATCH: The First-Time Home Buyer Incentive explained

For renters:Affordable housing

When it comes to renters, the Liberal government has been focusing on adding affordable housing. Public spending on social housing fell off a cliff in the early 1990s, with the number of new rental units with committed financing dropping from around 20,000 a year through the 1980s to less than 5,000 a year by the mid-1990s, according to data published in a recent report by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA).

READ MORE: $22/hr is average wage needed to afford a two-bedroom apartment in Canada, says report

Since 2017, the Liberals have announced a $55-billion, 10-year National Housing Strategy (NHS) to be spearheaded by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC), which administers most federal programs related to affordable housing. The strategy aims to remove more than half a million families from housing need, create up to 125,000 new housing units, and refurbish more than 300,000 public housing units, while cutting chronic homelessness in half.

READ MORE: There’s a lifestyle penalty for renting in Canada — it doesn’t have to be so

When it comes to building rental housing, not all of the federal programs that have coalesced into the NHS have been equally successful so far, but the money “is making it out the door,” said David Macdonald, who authored the CCPA report.

The number of new affordable units that received public financial commitments in 2018 was 16,600 compared to just 5,900 in 2015, Macdonald said.

Still, while that’s a significant improvement, it remains lower than the average number of new units the government was financing annually in the 1980s.

“We are not back to where we were,” Macdonald said, “and we have 10 million more people today.”

There is also the question of whether the NHS is as ambitious as its $55-billion price tag would suggest. A recent study by the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) found that the strategy amounts to just $16.1 billion in new federal planned spending. The rest of the money represents pre-existing spending commitment, government loans and provincial and territorial cost-matching.

READ MORE: Parents aren’t just helping their kids buy homes — they’re helping pay rent

The NHS boosts the CMHC’s annual spending on assisted housing by just 15 per cent compared to the average of the past 10 years, according to the PBO report.

“It is not clear that the National Housing Strategy will reduce the prevalence of housing need relative to 2017 levels,” the PBO said.

Still, without the NHS, CMHC funding to assisted housing would have dropped by more than 70 per cent by 2027-28 due to the expiry of previous time-limited investments.

Macdonald said Ottawa’s renewed commitment to those sunsetting government programs was not a matter of course.

“The experience of the 1990s is that no, they would not automatically have been renewed,” he said. “It is certainly possible for the federal government to completely get out of the affordable housing business.”

WATCH: How rent-to-own works

The Canada Housing Benefit

Building more affordable rental housing isn’t the only way to help Canadians who have a landlord instead of a mortgage. The Liberals’ proposed Canada Housing Benefit (CHB) would take a different route, by giving Canadians money to help pay rent.

The CHB, which was announced as part of the NHS, would provide cash transfers averaging $2,500 a year to some 300,000 families in need starting in 2020.

While the size of the benefit is large enough to make a significant difference for recipients, the number of renters who will receive it is small, Macdonald said.

In 2020, half of the 4.8 million families who will rent their homes that will be either unaffordable, unsuitable or inadequate according to CMHC standards, according to Macdonald’s report.

While the CHB represents “the other piece” of the Liberals’ housing strategy, “it’s not nearly as large in terms of aggregate impact,” he said.

Besides, the CHB, like much of the new funding for the Liberals housing strategy, is booked for “beyond this government’s mandate, and in many cases, beyond the next government’s mandate,” Macdonald said.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

: Politics

Cattle farming in the Amazon has likely caused 2019-08-23 14:42:47Fires in the Amazon have surged by 83 per cent compared to the same period a year earlier, government figures show, and environmentalists blamed the s

Trudeau, Trump expected to discuss China at G7 2019-08-23 14:30:05White House officials say the wide range of issues to be discussed include the ongoing tensions in Hong Kong.

ANALYSIS: Trump tries to juice the economy by 2019-08-23 14:19:23The President of the United States has just branded the Chairman of the U.S. Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, as an “enemy,”

Security tightens in Kashmir following calls for a 2019-08-23 13:20:54Schools were scheduled to reopen in Kashmir and some constraints on movement and assembly were lifted this week.

‘I take it as a compliment’: Doug Ford 2019-08-23 12:28:37"I'm too busy governing and he's too busy campaigning and that's fine," Ford said during a press conference Friday.

China turns up heat with tariff hikes on 2019-08-23 11:50:31As part of the retaliation, China also will increase import duties on U.S.-made autos and auto parts.

Trump trades barbs with Federal Reserve chair amid 2019-08-23 11:33:18Powell said President Donald Trump's trade wars have complicated the Fed's ability to set interest rates and have contributed to a global economic s

David Koch, a billionaire conservative backer, dead at 2019-08-23 09:03:58Koch, a billionaire industrialist, was a major backer of conservative causes and political candidates.

G7 summit: Key things to know as world 2019-08-23 07:40:03Despite ups and downs, the Group of Seven remains a key forum for tackling issues that cross borders.

G7 leaders take in dim economic outlook as 2019-08-23 06:54:14Factories are slumping, many businesses are paralyzed, global growth is sputtering and the world's two mightiest economies are in the grip of a dange

Brazil says it is target of smear campaign 2019-08-22 19:40:14Onyx Lorenzoni, the Brazilian president’s chief of staff, accused European countries of exaggerating environmental problems in Brazil in order t

The U.S. isn’t the only country interested in 2019-08-22 17:59:27Several countries, including China and Russia, have a vested interest in Greenland.

CBC | Politics News

EU set to halt imports of Canadian cherries, 2019-08-22 19:06:47The European Union will halt imports of Canadian cherries and other fresh fruits starting Sept. 1 as it enforces new import requirements related to pe

Singh says NDP wouldn't prop up Scheer minority 2019-08-22 17:35:58NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said today that Andrew Scheer's past statements on same-sex marriage rule out the prospect of his party supporting the Conse

It's 'imperative' that Canada repatriate its detained ISIS 2019-08-22 16:45:59U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said his administration has been clear with the Canadian government that the U.S. wants Canada to bring home its o

60 days out from a federal election, lawn 2019-08-22 16:04:25Voters will soon notice a proliferation of federal campaign signs over the coming days as parties begin planting them on the front lawns of

Freeland heading to Cuba next week to talk 2019-08-22 15:40:01Foreign Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland will head to Cuba next week for talks with her counterpart there on the situation in Venezuela.

Editor of Your Ward News gets 1 year 2019-08-22 15:10:16The editor of a hate-filled, Toronto-based publication has been jailed for one year. A judge sentenced James Sears after denying his bid to reopen the

Top general says military started dealing with suspected 2019-08-22 12:37:23Defence chief Gen. Jonathan Vance says the military first became aware of a Manitoba reservist's alleged links to a neo-Nazi group in the spring and

During Ottawa visit, Pompeo attacks China for detaining 2019-08-22 10:18:04Canada will have the support of the United States until the two Canadians detained in China "are returned to their families," U.S. Secretary of Stat

U.K.'s Boris Johnson expected to press Trudeau on 2019-08-22 04:00:00As it hurtles toward what could be a messy exit from the European Union, Britain is hoping to hear some fresh trade reassurances from Canada at the up

Trudeau and Pompeo urged to speak with one 2019-08-22 04:00:00As U.S Secretary of State Mike Pompeo sits down with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau today, geopolitical watchers and at least one Hong Kong n

'Jihadi Jack' has a constitutional right to come 2019-08-22 04:00:00Jack Letts has every right as a Canadian citizen to come to Canada, legal analysts say, but the man dubbed "Jihadi Jack" by the media and accus

The Pollcast: Your election questions answered 2019-08-22 04:00:00On the latest episode of The Pollcast, we try to answer some of your questions ahead of the October federal election.

Breitbart News

Ruth Bader Ginsburg Treated for Cancer on Pancreas 2019-08-23 14:40:11U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg recently underwent three weeks of radiation treatment following the discovery of a cancerous

Trump Orders U.S. Companies to Look for Alternatives 2019-08-23 12:17:31Trump signals a big escalation in the trade war after China announces retaliatory tariffs.

Donald Trump: 'Who Is Our Bigger Enemy, Jay 2019-08-23 11:29:16President Donald Trump continued his criticism of the Federal Reserve on Friday after Chairman Jerome Powell spoke about monetary policy in Jackson Ho

Pete Buttigieg Warns of Spike in 'Unplanned Parenthood' 2019-08-23 11:11:26"These people who are attacking Planned Parenthood, I wonder if they've thought about how much unplanned parenthood they're going to create if we l

Sanders Calls for Nationalization of Energy Production -- 2019-08-23 10:58:10On Thursday’s “All In” on MSNBC, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) outright admitted to host Chris Hayes a federal government takeover of e

Washington State Law Ends Campus Firearm Storage Program 2019-08-23 10:38:27A recently passed law in the state of Washington will effectively end a campus firearm storage program at Washington State University.

New Jersey Awarded $3.8 Million in Financial Aid 2019-08-23 10:29:12A local news report revealed that the state of New Jersey awarded $3.8 million in financial aid to illegal immigrants during the 2018-2019 school year

Report: Lori Loughlin Thought All Rich People Bribed 2019-08-23 10:22:53A new report suggests that Hollywood actress Lori Loughlin refused to plead guilty for her alleged role in the "Varsity Blues" college admissions br

Ken Cuccinelli: Detaining Immigrant Families Longer to Act 2019-08-23 10:05:02Acting U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Director Ken Cuccinelli in a contentious Friday appearance on CNN’s “New Day” defen

Donald Trump Urges Federal Reserve to Act After 2019-08-23 09:58:22President Donald Trump again urged the Federal Reserve to act on Friday after China announced new tariffs on $75 billion of United States products.

'Angel Has Fallen' Review: Exciting and Glorious Mockery 2019-08-23 09:55:56The best news, though, is that Angel Has Fallen is a solid genre movie, a B-movie once again working its butt off to be an A-movie

Mexican Border State Offers Cash for New Gulf 2019-08-23 09:54:41MATAMOROS, Tamaulipas – Mexican border state police placed a bounty on one of the regional leaders of the Gulf Cartel who is linked to escalatin

Politics – Macleans.ca

SNC-Lavalin may not be a ballot box winner 2019-08-22 14:34:16Philippe J. Fournier: Three new polls conducted after the ethics commissioner's report was released show the race still deadlocked The post SNC-Laval

America’s demolition politics smashes the world 2019-08-22 13:26:22Adnan R. Khan: Donald Trump's winner-take-all world view has decimated the international order that was built to help avoid chaos The post America&rs

Jerry Dias wants to make an enemy out 2019-08-22 13:20:17The head of Canada's largest private-sector union says he's not blindly loyal to any party, but he'll spend as much money as possible to beat Andre

Canada likely won’t hear more on the SNC 2019-08-22 06:30:05Politics Insider for Aug. 22: Polling on Trudeau's ethics, analysis of Scheer's climate policy, plus some news—we're hosting a leaders debate

How ‘Jihadi Jack’ became Canada’s problem 2019-08-21 16:20:45Audrey Macklin: The world is not made safer from terrorism when the U.K. disposes of their unwanted citizens in Canada The post How ‘Jihadi Jack

The Maclean’s / Citytv National Leaders Debate 2019 2019-08-20 16:00:13On Thursday, Sept. 12, Maclean's and Citytv are hosting the first leaders debate of the election calendar, moderated by Paul Wells The post The Macle

Boris Johnson and the peculiar British art of 2019-08-20 15:32:23Leah McLaren: The British PM’s strength lies not in a calculating lust for power but in how few tosses he gives. Here's why voters find it irre

The McLellan report would have ended the SNC 2019-08-19 18:41:47Paul Wells: Under the proposed 'McLellan protocol' the incessant piling-on the attorney general by staffers would not have been possible The post Th

Gas station owners pitched an alternative to Ford’s 2019-08-19 16:56:52But the provincial Tories rejected the suggested pie charts that would've shown everything that goes into the cost of filling up The post Gas station

A new 338Canada/Maclean’s projection: Could SNC-Lavalin hurt the 2019-08-19 14:07:28Philippe J. Fournier: Pollsters are likely in the field on the heels of the latest developments in the SNC-Lavalin affair. Right now, Liberals and Tor

#TrudeauMustResign vs. #IStandWithTrudeau 2019-08-16 15:32:03Everyone was yelling on Twitter after the ethics commissioner report. Who yelled the the loudest? Negative Trudeau hashtags received more mentions tha

Justin Trudeau’s ‘Just watch me!’ moment 2019-08-16 14:53:11Anne Kingston: The PM reframed his ethics violation as a civic virtue—this government will protect jobs, even if lines need to be crossed. The

CTVNews.ca - Politics -

Kenney takes aim at Trudeau directly ahead of 2019-08-06 04:36:31Alberta Premier Jason Kenney is taking aim at Prime Minister Justin Trudeau ahead of this fall's federal election.

Trudeau kept 'back pocket' G7 summit statement to 2019-08-05 04:12:00The top Canadian organizer at last year's stormy G7 summit says Prime Minister Justin Trudeau kept a "back pocket" closing statement ready in case

Veteran Liberal MP Denis Paradis won't seek re-election 2019-08-04 14:39:22Veteran Liberal MP Denis Paradis says he won't seek re-election in this fall's federal election.

Conservative MP Deepak Obhrai dies of cancer 2019-08-03 12:26:00Calgary MP Deepak Obhrai, the scarf-sporting, fun-loving elder statesman of the Conservative caucus and a beloved character on Parliament Hill who cha

Infrastructure bank looks to avoid distraction from election 2019-08-03 08:44:00The chief executive of the federal infrastructure financing agency says the pitched political debate about the future of the Crown corporation doesn'

Ottawa opposes Saskatchewan's move to delay carbon tax 2019-08-02 18:38:00Ottawa is pushing back against Saskatchewan's request to have the Supreme Court of Canada delay hearing its challenge of the federal carbon tax.

'Beer and hockey:' Government-hosted webpage outlines Canadian culture 2019-08-02 16:57:40What do you do when you meet a Canadian? According to a page on the government's website, you might want to ask about the weather.

Freeland lands meeting with Chinese counterpart to talk 2019-08-02 10:38:00Foreign Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland says a face-to-face meeting she had with her Chinese counterpart this week was a positive step in what has

Trudeau unveils agreement to build housing in Nunavut 2019-08-02 09:32:00Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says the federal government has reached a new housing agreement with Nunavut to help address the housing crisis across t

Conservatives, if elected, would work to restore ties 2019-08-02 04:39:00A Conservative government, if elected this fall, would work to fix Canada's relationship with Saudi Arabia by trying to build back rapport with the k

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.