• Follow us


Can Psychiatry Heal Itself?

My summer reading has been grim lately, focused on medicine’s failings. I recently reviewed Medical Nihilism, in which philosopher Jacob Stegenga mounts a scathing critique of medicine, arguing that many common treatments don’t work very well, if at all.

In this post, I look at Mind Fixers: Psychiatry’s Troubled Search for the Biology of Mental Illness by historian Anne Harrington, which corroborates and complements Medical Nihilism. Mind-Fixers is more measured than most critiques of psychiatry. Harrington seems almost pained to deliver bad news, making her indictment all the more damning.

Upbeat accounts of modern psychiatry, like A History of Psychiatry by Edward Shorter, present it as a story of good science triumphing over bad. Biological theories of and treatments for the brain, notably drugs like Thorazine, lithium, Valium and Prozac, displaced Freudian psychobabble and transformed psychiatry into a truly scientific discipline.

This story is false, Harrington asserts. She writes: “Today one is hard-pressed to find anyone knowledgeable who believes that the so-called biological revolution of the 1980s made good on most or even any of its therapeutic and scientific promises.” Bio-psychiatry “overreached, overpromised, overdiagnosed, overmedicated and compromised its principles.”

Mind Fixers starts in the 19th century, when the insane were housed in asylums. As inmate populations rose, Emil Kraepelin and other European scientists sought to trace insanity to its biological roots. They were encouraged by the discovery that madness was often caused by syphilis, an infectious disease that later turned out to be curable by antibiotics. Researchers hoped other mental disorders might also have relatively simple causes and cures. 

Harrington’s book chronicles the largely futile efforts of scientists to find such causes and cures. She goes through the sordid history of insulin-coma therapy, electroconvulsive therapy, the lobotomy and the fever cure. The latter, which assumed that high fever could purge madness from patients, called for infecting them with malaria. Some patients served as “malaria reservoirs,” whose blood supplied pathogens for infecting others.

The media hailed these alleged advances, exaggerating benefits and downplaying risks. In 1942 an article in the popular magazine Saturday Evening Post gushed that lobotomies transform the mentally ill from “ineffectives” into “useful members of society. A world that once seemed an abode of misery, cruelty and hate is now radiant with sunshine and kindness toward them.” In fact, lobotomies often caused severe disability or death. Of the four treatments mentioned above, only electroconvulsive therapy continues to be practiced. It can provide short-term relief from severe depression, but relapse rates are high.

The eugenics movement, which assumed mental illness is hereditary, sought to eradicate it by preventing the mentally “unfit” from reproducing. Early in the 20thcentury California and other states passed laws legalizing sterilization of mental-hospital inmates. In 1942, Harrington notes, the American Journal of Psychiatry urged killing mentally disabled children (although that recommendation was never carried out). In 1933 Nazi Germany cited U.S. policies as justification for its lethal eugenics program.

The practical and ethical flaws of these biological methods allowed psychological approaches to mental illness to flourish. By the mid-20thcentury psychoanalysis, the theory/therapy invented by Freud, was dominating American psychiatry. Psychoanalysts insisted that mental illnesses had psychological causes and were best treated by psychological remedies, namely talk therapy. The influence of psychoanalysis waned in the 1950s with the advent of drugs for treating schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, depression and anxiety.

Harrington is hard on the Freudians, accusing them of arrogance, dogmatism and cruelty, especially toward women. Psychoanalysts blamed mothers for causing schizophrenia, autism and other disorders in their children by being too cold—or, conversely, too protective. A 1945 magazine article on this trend asked, “Are American Moms a Menace?”

But modern bio-psychiatrists are Harrington’s main target. She details how in the past few decades, as prescriptions for psychiatric medications soared, their limitations have become increasingly apparent. Many are scarcely more effective than placebos, and they have severe adverse effects, including weight gain, tremors, addiction and suicide. Meanwhile, researchers have failed to trace mental illnesses to genetic mutations, neural anomalies, viruses or other physiological factors that would justify physiological treatments. No clear-cut biological markers for any mental illnesses have been found.

Psychiatry’s biological “revolution,” which Harrington calls a “False Dawn,” now appears to have been motivated as much by greed as compassion. By the late 1980s, she notes, “a critical mass of clinicians and researchers had aligned their professional interests with the commercial interests of the pharmaceutical industry.” Speakers at the 2008 meeting of the American Psychiatric Association disclosed more than 1,300 consulting or speaking contracts with drug firms. Companies viewed psychiatrists as “salespeople,” who were compensated based on their ability to boost prescriptions.

Psychiatrists did their job well. Sales of medications for mental illness increased by a factor of six between 1987 and 2001. Psychiatrists and drug companies aggressively promoted drugs for mild anxiety and depression, which had not previously been considered illnesses. (This is the practice that Stegenga calls “disease-mongering.”) Manufacturers of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) promoted the “chemical imbalance” theory of depression in advertising, even as research was discrediting that theory. Meanwhile, Harrington notes, many pharmaceutical companies, frustrated by the slow pace of research on the biology of mental illness, have “abandoned the field of psychiatry altogether.”

Some of the bleakest assessments of bio-psychiatry come from insiders, including two former directors of the National Institute of Mental Health, the world’s largest funder of mental-health research. Steven Hyman (director from 1996 to 2001) said recently that psychiatry has had “no good ideas about molecular targets for diagnoses and treatments since the 1950s.” [Harrington’s paraphrase, and her italics.] Thomas Insel (2002-2015) said after stepping down, “I don’t think we moved the needle in reducing suicide, reducing hospitalizations, improving recovery for the tens of millions of people who have mental illness.”

Harrington concludes her book with a call to action. She says psychiatry’s current “crisis” is also an opportunity for reform, and she urges the profession to take various steps to break out of its “stalemate”:

*Psychiatry should admit its mistakes and ethical lapses, especially “the willingness of so many of its practitioners in recent decades to follow the money instead of the suffering.”

*It should stop hyping new treatments and issuing “premature declarations of victory” over mental illness and “make a virtue of modesty.”

*It should “overcome its persistent reductionist habits and commit to an ongoing dialogue with the scholarly world of the social sciences and even the humanities.”

*It should listen more carefully to self-described “survivors” of mental-health treatment.

*It should focus on severe mental illness, as it did in the past, and allow psychologists, social workers and other non-physicians to treat the “worried well.”

This final step, Harrington acknowledges, would require “great professional and ethical courage,” because it would slash psychiatry’s market share and make it less lucrative. Harrington’s prescription sounds like what Jacob Stegenga calls “gentle medicine” and what others call “medical conservatism.” I hope psychiatrists take heed. Mind-fixers, fix yourselves.

Postscript: Anne Harrington will talk about Mind Fixers at Stevens Institute of Technology, Hoboken, N.J., on Wednesday, September 25, at 4 p.m. The lecture is free and open to the public.Further Reading:

“The Meaning of Madness,” a chapter in my free online book Mind-Body Problems

Is Medicine Overrated?

Meta-Post: Posts on Mental Illness

Meta-Post: Posts on Brain Implants

Why We're Still Fighting over Freud

Why Freud Should Be Dead

Is Science Hitting a Wall? Part 1

Responses from Readers:

Randolph Nesse MD: I appreciated your review of Anne Harrington's book. I loved the book. The field of psychiatry really is in a swamp. I fear, however, that pleas to spend more time with patients and less time with drug reps won't have an impact. A book like hers is published every year, and the field just goes on. I wonder if you have seen my new book Good Reasons for Bad Feelings: Insights from the Frontier of Evolutionary Psychiatry.  It argues that an evolutionary foundation can make psychiatry more like the rest of medicine, not by reductionist investigations, but by distinguishing symptoms from diseases and looking at how selection shaped capacities for anxiety, depression and all the rest. I think you would like it. It offers a genuinely new way forward.

Karl Dahlke: Forgive me if I am a bit arrogant on this, but I think you, and everyone you interview, are rather missing the point - perhaps deliberately, since the truth is a bitter pill to swallow. The vast majority of mental illness in America is situational, not clinical. We live in constant fear and anxiety because we have no health insurance, and could die, or become permanently disabled, or at least bankrupt, at the slightest illness or injury. Minorities are terrified of the police, the first responders of mass incarceration, who currently house 1.5 million innocent slaves. Unless you can hide in your basement like a Jew in 1940 Germany, there is almost no way to avoid the slave catchers. Hard working aliens who have never committed a crime in their life are terrified of ICE. Even some privileged white people scrape and crawl and work 12 hour days for $9 an hour and still can't feed their families. Mental illness is endemic because of social policy, and if we fixed the ills of our nation, millions of Americans would start to feel better right away, and could put their SSRIs back on the shelf.

Keith Riggle: I've added "Mind Fixers" to my reading list, since I agree with Harrington's diagnosis and prescription for psychiatry. Much of it applies to the medical profession as a whole, especially disease mongering and following the money. No doubt the book will be criticized because Harrington is a historian, not a psychiatrist. I see that she has also authored or edited several related books, including "The Cure Within: A History of Mind-Body Medicine," "Visions of Compassion: Western Scientists and Tibetan Buddhists Examine Human Nature," and "So Human a Brain: Knowledge and Values in the Neurosciences." The blurb for "The Cure Within" states, "Can mind-body practices from the East help us become well? When it comes to healing, we believe we must look beyond doctors and drugs; we must look within ourselves. Faith, relationships, and attitude matter." Undoubtedly Harrington's views about mind-body medicine, Buddhism, and values colored her views in "Mind Fixers," which may also be a source of criticism.

They don't disturb me, however, as they resonate with my views about the mind and body, and I think the values of patients have gotten lost in the dry talk about the evidence of benefits versus risks. I recently read an op-ed in JAMA that I also agree with, "Evidence vs Consensus in Clinical Practice Guidelines." The point of the authors, Benjamin Djulbegovic, MD, and Gordon Guyatt, MD, is that there's currently a false dichotomy between evidence-and consensus-based clinical guidelines because all evidence requires interpretation, so all guidelines should be both evidence- and consensus based. No evidence speaks for itself, even if it comes from high quality randomized clinical trials. Another important reason they say this is because of "the third principle of evidence-based medicine: evidence can never dictate the optimal course of action, it should always be considered in the context of values and preferences." I think that is an important principle of medical nihilism, as well.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

Scientific American: Health

Fans May Be Okay for Muggy Days--but Avoid 2019-08-05 17:00:00New research contradicts conventional wisdom on fan use during heat waves -- Read more on ScientificAmerican.com

Cancer Research in a Nutshell 2019-08-05 12:00:00A website called OncoBites offers short, easy-to-understand reports on what’s new in the field -- Read more on ScientificAmerican.com

Darwin's Ideas on Evolution Drive a Radical New 2019-08-05 08:00:00Principles of evolution and natural selection drive a radical new approach to drugs and prevention strategies -- Read more on ScientificAmerican.com

Cancer Medicine Is Failing Us 2019-08-04 15:00:00Our aggressive, expensive approach to cancer is doing more harm than good -- Read more on ScientificAmerican.com

London Is Crawling with Drug-Resistant Microbes 2019-08-03 17:45:00Nearly half of bacteria gathered in public settings around the city were resistant to two or more commonly used antibiotics, such as penicillin and er

Can Psychiatry Heal Itself? 2019-08-03 15:00:00A Harvard historian urges psychiatrists to focus less on making money and more on helping patients -- Read more on ScientificAmerican.com

Do Amino Acids Build Bigger Muscles? 2019-08-03 09:00:00Amino acids enhance workout performance, promote recovery, and help build muscle. But do we need to buy supplements to keep on hand during workouts? -

A Year In, the Second-Largest Ebola Outbreak Continues 2019-08-02 09:30:00Despite vaccination and treatment efforts, the epidemic in Central Africa has resulted in 1,700 deaths and counting -- Read more on ScientificAmerican

Is a Vegetarian Diet Bad for Your Brain? 2019-08-02 09:30:00If creatine is important for brain functioning and vegetarians have lower creatine levels, could a vegetarian or vegan diet have a negative impact on

We're Starting to Harness the Microbiome to Treat 2019-08-01 19:30:00But strong regulation is a must to protect patient safety -- Read more on ScientificAmerican.com

Mind the Staph: London Is Crawling with Antibiotic-Resistant 2019-08-01 09:00:00The bacteria are not a major threat, but they could transfer their resistance to more dangerous pathogens -- Read more on ScientificAmerican.com

AI Can Predict Kidney Failure Days in Advance 2019-07-31 15:00:00A new program could save lives in hospitals, where kidney injury is one of the most common causes of death -- Read more on ScientificAmerican.com

MedicineNet Daily News

Researchers 'Spin' Clinical Trial Findings in Top Psych 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Researchers 'Spin' Clinical Trial Findings in Top Psych Journals: StudyCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Revie

Health Tip: Managing Arthritis of the Hands 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Health Tip: Managing Arthritis of the HandsCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AM

AHA News: Common Prostate Cancer Treatment May Increase 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: AHA News: Common Prostate Cancer Treatment May Increase Risk of Fatal Heart ConditionCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/5/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Edi

Some Transgender Women May Be Able to Make 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Some Transgender Women May Be Able to Make SpermCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/5/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AM

Drug Approved to Treat Tenosynovial Giant Cell Tumor 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Drug Approved to Treat Tenosynovial Giant Cell TumorCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/5/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12:00:00

In Heat Waves, Fans May Do More Harm 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: In Heat Waves, Fans May Do More Harm Than GoodCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AM

Explaining, Easing the Horror of Mass Shootings for 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Explaining, Easing the Horror of Mass Shootings for Your KidsCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/5/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019

3 Ways to Improve Your Eating Habits 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: 3 Ways to Improve Your Eating HabitsCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AM

Rugby-Style Tackling Might Make Football Safer 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Rugby-Style Tackling Might Make Football SaferCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/5/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AM

Smoking Creates Long-Lasting Risk for Clogged Leg Arteries 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Smoking Creates Long-Lasting Risk for Clogged Leg ArteriesCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/5/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12:

Football Head Trauma Linked Again to Long-Term Brain 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Football Head Trauma Linked Again to Long-Term Brain DamageCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/5/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12

Health Tip: Benefits of Yoga 2019-08-07 03:00:00Title: Health Tip: Benefits of YogaCategory: Health NewsCreated: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AMLast Editorial Review: 8/6/2019 12:00:00 AM


Avancée dans la lutte contre la maladie de 2019-08-05 13:06:00Des chercheurs californiens ont séquencé le génome de la souris à pattes blanches, qui joue un rôle crucial dans la

Bactérie E-Coli dans l'eau potable de l'hôpital Fleurimont 2019-08-02 06:40:00La présence d'une faible quantité de la bactérie E-Coli dans les conduites de distribution d'eau potable de l'hôpital Fl

Justin Trudeau promet l'accès aux médicaments 2019-08-01 14:15:00Le premier ministre Justin Trudeau promet de s'assurer que les Canadiens aient accès aux médicaments dont ils ont besoin à des p

Trump menace d'aggraver les pénuries de médicaments au 2019-08-01 05:00:00Le projet de l'administration Trump d'autoriser les Américains à importer des médicaments d'ordonnance du Canada risque d'agg

Les archivistes médicaux veulent éviter une fuite comme 2019-08-01 05:00:00Sans un renforcement des lois et une réglementation plus stricte du secteur privé, le système de santé québé

Maladie débilitante chronique: le public exposé à des 2019-07-31 19:11:00L'Agence canadienne d'inspection des aliments (ACIA) expose le public à des risques inutiles en permettant à la viande de cervid&eacut

Médicaments exportés aux États-Unis: Ottawa ignorait tout 2019-07-31 19:00:00Des responsables fédéraux ont admis mercredi que le gouvernement canadien n'avait pas été consulté à l'ava

Les Américains pourront importer des médicaments du Canada 2019-07-31 08:57:00L'administration Trump a annoncé mercredi qu'elle mettrait en place un système qui permettra aux Américains d'importer l&eacut

Québec veut mieux protéger les dossiers médicaux 2019-07-31 05:00:00Alors qu'une fuite massive touche Desjardins, le gouvernement du Québec entend améliorer la protection de sa plus grande base de donn&e

Salles d'urgence bondées à Montréal et en Montérégie 2019-07-30 06:56:00La fréquentation des salles d'urgence du Québec en cette période où de nombreux Québécois sont en vacances

Les cigarettes électroniques jugées «nocives» par l'OMS 2019-07-26 15:30:00Les cigarettes électroniques sont « incontestablement nocives » et devront être régulées, selon un ra

Global News : Health

Cyberbullying by vegan activists a source of stress 2019-08-05 13:03:33The Standing Committee on Agriculture and Agri-Food spent several months studying the mental health challenges facing farmers, ranchers and agricultur

‘Manipulating physicians’: How drug reps pitch your doc 2019-08-05 06:00:11Drug reps are swaying the prescribing habits of Canadian doctors — and their patients are often unaware.

Canadian doctors’ mental health is suffering — and 2019-08-04 08:00:24Physicians have the highest rate of suicide of any profession, and double the rate of the general population.

‘Not in My Backyard’: How NIMBYism impacts access 2019-08-04 07:00:17How do you balance harm reduction needs and people’s concerns about having those services close to home?

Why these scientists are catching rats in downtown 2019-08-04 06:00:22The Vancouver Rat Project has been studying rats in downtown Vancouver for years. Their findings suggest a whole ecosystem living under our streets.

What happens to your body during menopause 2019-08-03 09:00:32The average age of menopause in Canada is 51 years old.

New Brunswick confirms 9 cases of legionnaires’ disease 2019-08-02 13:44:35There is still no word on the source of the disease but all cases are believed to be linked by time and location. 

Congo Ebola outbreak, one year in: What you 2019-08-01 11:58:00The ongoing Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo is now one year old and has killed more than 1,800 people.

Dentists remove ‘sac’ of more than 500 teeth 2019-08-01 10:53:32The boy complained of a sore jaw for years before finally agreeing to visit a dentist at the age of seven.

‘Solve the problem at home’: U.S. plan to 2019-07-31 16:56:53The Canadian Pharmacists Associations is among those raising concerns about the Trump administration's announcement.


The question you should never ask a bride-to-be 2019-08-01 14:09:06It seems innocent, but unprompted inquiries about weight loss made me feel inadequate as a bride. Here’s why this question is out of line, and h

Can a DNA test improve your fitness and 2019-07-31 07:00:00Experts examine whether MyExome claims to show how your genes influence your nutritional and fitness requirements and sleeping patterns.

You don’t need vitamins, save your money, experts 2019-07-30 10:06:29“Every time scientists have compared taking a supplement of something versus getting it through food, getting it through food wins every time.&r

Jameela Jamil made her first real friend at 2019-07-30 01:30:00The actress on being a lonely kid and finding friendship in Hollywood

Why it’s important for dietitians to practice ‘inclusive 2019-07-29 21:44:22Sadly, it’s common practice for patients to receive one-size-fits-all nutrition information.

Is your wellness obsession stressing you out? 2019-07-29 08:00:00A strict devotion to healthy living trends, from green juice to meditation, could do you more harm than good.

Here’s how Baltimore doctors are using 3D-printed organs 2019-07-26 22:25:39Some popular applications of 3D printing in health care — like Invisalign, a braces alternative, and cochlear implants for restoring hearing &md

Oregon students to get ‘mental health days’ 2019-07-24 00:00:00Mental health experts say it is one of the first state laws to explicitly instruct schools to treat mental health and physical health equally.

Study: Millions should stop taking Aspirin for heart 2019-07-24 00:00:00A daily low-dose Aspirin is recommended for people who have already had a heart attack or stroke and for those diagnosed with heart disease. But for t

Flavonoids are the next big thing in marijuana 2019-07-23 06:00:00Cannflavin A and Cannflavin B have especially powerful anti-inflammatory properties

‘I want to date but I have herpes. 2019-07-22 08:00:00One way you can start shedding some of that shame: Talk to a pro about it, Briony Smith writes.

Say no to juice or soda, even one 2019-07-19 00:00:00Even about a third of a typical can of soda increased overall cancer risk by 18 per cent and breast cancer risk by 22 per cent.


Une clinique plus efficace depuis la réforme Barrette 2019-08-06 01:00:00Après avoir frôlé la fermeture en raison de la réforme dans le réseau de la santé, une clinique spécia

Chassé à vie de la profession 2019-08-05 21:40:07L’ex-médecin de Montmagny, Jean-François Rancourt, a été radié de façon permanente par le conseil de d

Son assureur refuse de l’indemniser 2019-08-05 01:00:00Une Montréalaise se bat pour faire reconnaître ses problèmes de dépression notamment auprès de SSQ.

Les trans manifestent pour un meilleur accès aux 2019-08-04 18:58:50Plusieurs centaines de personnes trans ont manifesté dans les rues de Montréal pour dénoncer le manque de services offerts dans l

Son enfant s’est injecté son EpiPen par accident 2019-08-03 18:13:36Un petit garçon polyallergique a donné une sale frousse à ses parents lorsqu’il s’est piqué dans le doigt par

L’hôpital refuse de soigner sa hanche brisée parce 2019-08-03 16:50:55Un couple de Québec critique une décision du Centre hospitalier de l'Université Laval.

Les hommes demandent plus d’aide 2019-08-02 01:00:00Jamais autant d’hommes en détresse n’ont demandé de l’aide, observe un organisme qui leur offre du soutien depuis 26 a

Réseau de la santé: des employés de cuisine 2019-08-02 00:00:00Du personnel de l’Institut universitaire en santé mentale travaille à plus de 35 °C ressentis.

De la massothérapie en CHSLD 2019-08-01 20:51:02Depuis quelques semaines, deux CHSLD de l’est de Montréal offrent des services de massothérapie à leurs résidents et

Des scientifiques ont réussi à imprimer des parties 2019-08-01 15:56:31Des scientifiques américains ont annoncé jeudi avoir réussi à fabriquer des parties fonctionnelles du cœur en collag

Ebola: portrait d’un virus-tueur qui a fait 15 2019-08-01 06:18:20Ebola est un virus redoutable pour l’homme, ses épidémies ayant fait au total environ 15 000 morts depuis 1976.

L’alimentation, une piste à explorer pour mieux traiter 2019-07-31 13:40:17Une nouvelle étude conforte des recherches récentes selon lesquelles elle pourrait aussi jouer un rôle dans le traitement du cance

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.